Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[eclipse.org-eclipsecon-program-committee] Re: Tutorials with part 1, part 2 (or worse, part 1-2-3) are not in the spirit of EclipseCon 2008

Title: Re: Tutorials with part 1, part 2 (or worse, part 1-2-3) are not in the spirit of EclipseCon 2008
The modeling ones are going to be broken up, as per my comment on #47; that is, they will each have their own descriptive title and abstract to indicate the topics covered.  The main submitter just hasn’t done this yet.

Perhaps modeling is unique in its need for these types of tutorials, as covering abstract syntax, concrete syntax, model transformation, and code generation is a bit much to cover in a single 2 hour tutorial, but which is important to cover in the context of a single domain.

My thoughts,
Rich


On 12/7/07 1:02 PM, "Bjorn Freeman-Benson" <bjorn.freeman-benson@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

We have two hour tutorials this year because the attendees asked us to have shorter tutorials. Thus having a six hour tutorial (e.g. https://eclipsecon.greenmeetingsystems.com/submissions/view/47, https://eclipsecon.greenmeetingsystems.com/submissions/view/48, https://eclipsecon.greenmeetingsystems.com/submissions/view/49) is really not the right thing to do.

I understand that there is a lot of content to cover, but it should be broken into three separate tutorials: not just three with the same name and abstract. And the three should be independent - in the sense that one would be for beginners, one for intermediate, and one ofor advanced (for example).

I really think is is a mistake.

I also think all the "part 1/part 2" tutorials are a mistake - the presenters are going to be unhappy and the attendees are going to be unhappy when people wander out of part 1 and in to part 2 without attending the other part. The conference is not structured to guarantee or even require attendance at both parts. That means that the presenters are going to need to write separate tutorials anyway, so the titles should be separate as well.

My opinion,
Bjorn


--
Richard C. Gronback
Borland Software Corporation
richard.gronback@xxxxxxxxxxx
+1 860 227 9215

Back to the top