Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [agentic-ai-dev] Jakarta EE Roadmap Narrative: your input needed by Fri 16 Oct
  • From: Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Mon, 12 Oct 2026 12:25:40 -0400
  • Delivered-to: agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/agentic-ai-dev/>
  • List-help: <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:rhJPLpL71UE=;qxOydH3uy9WuaVjvxZ6gVmR2ixF VGEr11yPPfhkeqyfXgXYcdPfJUDlKzX2ExzZgbg7zLfpiWqCh0g0XPlMpDfjQe2EmmYXpJYWu 0A2puMqmZemlPL75zxzdoC6Alrxegrlxv2XxLCibFLzZKYhjnMgGC+E89Oh92XJWz5IxPQk9j W3ajtQd07KY/iGoTtSmX6cFKtOyJiDDpqiKvEvrH8S6t7IcmR0xVX6SVGgnlSJUWUfiXqpZqh fJLfty1Wb8XY8WbSdGg0uvKKleUaekUFZ++a+WerOA13cWtg1RGW8pWHCsJmBIniSfy1dX2UW rDp9T0CymuxsksSGQ0UWN+PGywTVQ+BgHM3A72cdFESoAMXNMVJwIDyGnrlZ7oseI5u9PQII0 vtmMalGQrOVuuX4nCqb//Yuu3zfzI0XK+XAnIKPSkNneFT0xB+iwu4VaEiJ/FYFld65Dx7Lrm XmNnXwEFeWKd+4TUo2sIonpSfBtdS95h21eSwuWTY/8Agb3+85gJkXIcgWUBm7zVQtDu6eHdb tvpx2O7vVVx8HrEM/V9tLxIGuqIwfAD7nvY3vZYzLTL3tKSSB31vrKrIWr/4129RImPuoXnnC 7u/4/kUpXvFbu6AebxFrals4S0OjrTUe8JNnI0OMAugXK+E2hJz9XGLLw1Br7xDvfspXJIxEY rWd50LVcEpxvKkllDVeV7zkuNQfLjvlGd2+XssYQhYuyboPX1m+ITci2mOqrUFD063voTky/f 6vgSB22+IrNU0YTq7ZRjws39bq2RNxWehFvWPhy6DuRba2Nv9lgQeXFVBG6Bz3FGbxUCtH76Q 0HUyFB/LzM3S8zA+c0Aa1vCwOl5YVPq0H1R+kTjl4/r8YarTW4TuCntCA7xrQzfm2tsSoN3fo QFIfXnrfm/3BSwY4Q8h5KGfm/ontlXlSeYA4pxTQGTfX9W4asSFSYlY3TAOg5vVX0IfiEa0gr O6u0+FsNfdwmg8D17RRrvlI13zl3RuIwcNug9MZ+Q6nm+E4udrYNM33Fc+7x87/NAMnXg3Jwr eJ9K6hFvYn+kCA06I3bw7Kf2Bxt+r8pephQ5EaMXMNg4lQYK9fetMFdWn4HtJYW7lVJoG621W r/+GQhBdsEQw/vx7SYkPFm7yhhpe1J2c3Jxp6apxBWtfwZloALsIh0OwsYEDjdEr5ZqdGCOqz 5LjRZPA6IL6WfdxjII6vGo6kXVptKiMS3Ws+DYIe+h5xtshSWJoH91Opds7tBlOztMHKDDg2j ESiJEqubrVWLv+SgLYyhpTl89Bq/PNsx7bUapwCxfwQksQNtYjduQ3yyFhG+DefFHhK3HHzVc NiYmnXjxkC4TvoqzMH9cXSVq792sOSlA43O0/Mj41wwoeLdtQhTxpCNNWp/sZT8ZKksZRmnbp y1t4b7g9oJNDkHqF9AsRU32yepF7Rq7r3nTvc9sthrAtVhNkRobErk2zVzmbh49r90VmdglZs 9rbAGjnJJ6hvUX/tOwienGd0ctWE6MgoredZULQPz0j9UYZvUpv4fHdOIGhLtW3lKOzvrhjdS XcCMELcs9JCKa4WkoBEAatR84iSVFWbn0wZrogeRYVw0OpB8xkyOTqB1IF2lz0ZlMdwLIBp0S YB4UQA93m4vwixBazdwJgRmrcweDj9aG5RxUR3ldO1QYou6r2umZTBcgf2oaFvjqx4JG9yTq6 8wJ/IQUWwH/+7bvJAdS2TUgwaV6vLmb2rvfROr3qO3cY6AM2FKBmYO7NJINkMgz2hBkbti/mt UPvLn8z3uhCsIIe8Nznlzev7NhfptY+p4/B4V0x4PW3cwpUI5yCqMK3wbN2k6fOpV8qwCv6uS LL+sekhv3d/u3VUyD1N6Z6vhrUEcXZEq1to+M68JNsEyrl7n/NACPPfgZ2c+mG/CUwUwd59t0 dipaZBjdDP7bD5/PeWBYythtTnPDND7S0kog7BPV+lWFOwLNuoFCZ6j11e/v42w+W7yQ78r82 eu5zhBQ/QkVccbm1GXb1nXOR7sUNSTaD3SeYxqZQiz+/RmqiQ7TKRZ0pJnOrC3PvsOa4w3Ris 6DYTcNos/SSjaamlVdseCHxn73LKWXw2+kcBgXLDLYjNHlbg1G45zIh2sAvt9qowg4hZBbF8M 1MbVB+H5hVxDb9wuOp7+TR4b4zlEzgx9PtT5HG9+ySCYcrRDr//Hzfgu+rWnzDtixAqEp+DYe AjToofX/cxEMsQH8lvMb64zUO2mysey/Xc4g7gQanbE7rleEy/wNG+jZnjwOn339AL74DNvE2 6mc74rhiQs8ZAn6CWRnIy93FKecwZV7mOE65Ga8WFiWNYOSqrPqPXlsTcSOVznc4Q9zTlVtzQ QziWIRS1jl+HoFyx8PdeTeBr244AVVSsRhmthM7s0UIcZcqz5qCBBizABe8SLIe+XT75ooIEf ZahmyCBJX2GivF3YDOUuYkskydv3KzPxRdBA26NMaeGUG4H+4rEBLAH6e4P4S6pQvSEuQ7K5W vkCwcPn5/+WXpadBAlxbRR2RT23M1NdstATFTG21UBCFqZ+yx95C63Yzd8efJYoounIcuUKzN R8vCJJ0iUmNk4R2Zk4qiS7mLG98151MX02aTLWHzDv4gOJ8UV+/s3h3r/re2dZPNh2avhA8ed 7Kp87l8H7sVRwLz9R+eFUdQTwmtD1y6VBLNQx19K9HKJWT0MjyqQxy53jzbxClt7OvCWks2Id X8rDprA/lQZ3dNvjjOfSusXev9yPJswAEGR9JmCjTqxUrYDPgUf5RijZTwvY9YfXqu0c69z3V aLUZU5TLQQRleKasbiZ8xiNcAYjPW7SUHMlFBeOI2gnV0ecvU8kdeG4J3dVcs20Zh1HpVdEMA bffPBVibiThGUrjYyRJmluW0NG2tij5tXCJvGjpKPhVTo8DA+WRT8Xk2tMC/1/JU78mIrmwE2 8fnMaX99PzU7SNtkLmU8IRDMrOTNp0bIk5hQ/tPhyIh7l2IgpKqgPFB9r51z4XTOo3LQzQmdT g7VDsTyYEmv47dkE1esrgNPACqbnqFl6PdZU1wsHt0ZIp5zwVaRoqSocdjolMBgvxbBnQMRFj kd94YLUWIN1A7c8Qnzm3ex2MVVTdqcbJKwQT8Sz67KscyEozZ9MF3rm2zAR4pnA92uMZVnIg+ 6MMbUyx6BP2NmGcYw5QfdY2ySG/TvoV0s5wlC0JNo6i9WbVjL2Z7hF0QV5Vh0HQrewN6Xz+C/ /x429nXRdu61zr7QQssfIhIewNBll2JFq9Vpa9590uTOmLx9g/tMg1M3aKXKRgYUh3ukwkiIh gxWbTlhQ9NzqZ0pyayuVEFBvpwkUiqfCeqdqVqi0CcqRpq5OgMjORBiKpXtsESb/08YddVcQ0 J+wwS4kGa3i3spIXCANJsbk7Pv4RT6nkSHrkt4r8fUiYkxdGmwZ7b/9JqIYzJwktpGpfPK9K6 0ejqJTIHBURYo7+MblBFzFp64X0BWIjZBLvi84dHAnO4h0dgS9NLwWe7Zfy3mv450GSbvm2PM GBtjqyx3Nvxth7v/Vp6mBgZa/Vd0z3WD11CEEe1gaerBgzSrFcB3TmYaZGgTdVqbP23yDlEOd uGYc8qiwOay84H0dIConCeyWHbBbZdTs/Gn4WNArYGAkldSP1UxbNlaC//nRhxhz8p1pNYL/C DrcdzZUF/l26O+XVZ7GGj0I3+6mv6SNPicZKCdA+eO6wwy75sp7+a/7F3vBWRWMwSvfl8xRQa kU6A8ZmVFPZH28ppJfpgZdXrpThlcWaVufbRy2EdmA9sg0IFPt+cOfrqX47B/1HOBtz+evEN0 hFjIqauJqJWsiLMX0iXdzEF1zixD4+GzN80pe9IW50xoaOLLjwuPVu2SiOJJmq+a1qClVPTB1 goUVyaz7fugIwQchPfWGnkwS6q8v8eTCEoDtmx/mm/SK+zCA2bVRW1Sm4DgpYv7kE1rwVgNi5 Ky/P19ZViQup1D59Mm6GZgWTBnJUiCU1HAiUla/tJcjpehNo8BEFGyGJktPsBRHvaqCFrqRr2 rb9CljK/3ermHh81ZGtOKd9twhXIjwlglM1+GVqdYA3YyxY3VjZL4Nc7QSXwtKTk4X9qKw3px r//uWpozfukGWB2eDHJYcFu94ZSYbyPachq0xK0EdYtsJF6OfLytq3PyYrdz3V3GZkhUGzUOL QSYeQQza6AzP0fOnZYnWkbJOvbpv0kTJsSUgBuUENTTSxwqIJ6XN7zuchU+KQdrgGKZD30E/b 0UC9W6L8u6mqGTpA7A+sNJbCTyijqhZaE9w3OEsrjbijfzyE3RbBGgP6Ng5QqvlcYxhSjxfyl 6xcKIDl+Uu3jT+mIfyxSMZHV5VtOF4pKCHO1cOK7/6/JHpfgGdMIjreyp+DNGzc0kkLoifHQ6 5pUdhcankmP44i0HJcwzC5W7kBZBmN0cIjdbV4UtLyumIrxu0h7w7lzYWFqRKs9qtN5dCo+SK xTCmBFz1dP+h3Qgj2wB1axeSql+0KfBlxiyggbqk2lqmU9wYZ8PqdHEK/ZbmO7i6oLjacbLJL hnXfCJRLDyPYp0F/19izHIQdC9hnibCwH30VBNr9xfyAjakJVdKZwVzDgIm1gTGiAaamjyPfM AlSvnnr1b2FQAChqPKV2m7JnsSaajG11lBUA4URojFPoZL94ic6DQbVGcXPROJ2mItkiy8UUp 3OslrgWZR/hqugGXW/paXbtAz0Rv1ocUaajAAdqloX1RX1pgiwoWYOaHdnu29yWzaPap8Ni2Z PxBpcWipKx+0y+4//fqIwNoLTdd3E/Ldj0/2/Waur/Qk19gizfZ9C+5Ne83zmcDkov8mJJles LQi7HNbi/bO+GhqgEEzEQ5TBfo9Es8t6lkiQDjnAkpSCWBy6rCKUgEFYNH6561l5rIyEveKvC SVCY3IdVXne025JkmtztrGWko76d52G7zeUrFvvUQq++oPHVNKUQnatjrQpwfuJBoi4xIRad8 76IQbzbpECjezePItKj0fxLQsewhuRg/WJ7g3jvcjdvLheBTKpbGlFtBkd3PH9NIww6NdYWl8 0OatLXJfn0iMVVVbhKOFf1WSQ0LEenxW+V5CXeKR4Ex2E1dqWzyR2XZFx3o7NQS47QI5wFKBb gSorUblCkQqFYY46iMfZqyRPjSyAlKLAXbEepg8eEo0wU18u777gH52aqZ5ktQ3NeFKLKzIwf 9dH5qpgLEqbdV470BWWcazepZQ0IOUx0Ky7eB3phafmRVvQLecFY3mPvibzJAVAxK8HYFzhI4 k906oz4NA/oHk42fabdhPZTVeIlA+Nn8FpOhFhk96RT2PY8uVWeob2dapCsMnQ6IBrzSd8vld knsIQdp2GQSRmP5/RhKzb4eIvQev0pWCJUB4dGzeGcx1nsk/FJRhB78anNHN/1HVZN9ohb2qx GXSxfldErh2AMV4A+Xo0SphWbpA0wUfhtftFcffjQYfkqHQb96R+P+a9/gvKbfRVHMMss1V3Y OopyH6ECePRXnXiSHL8INkwgrZnQYNMa3ZNlm7P8FpGMU5SuVFAvEgw4DQ3IPwS1rGk/6drd0 3OkWjK0LRk4Fpyo3IYo6Ze56xqCzM3FBNzmv+04Qe1eCWwZ5sgJ7cVvwLcuXlkYKBo96UwBMj M0S4M++sQcU4X3hr388Cl5LyF/TRCbsfbzNyS+HspBQZStxMKsFyJfsnGggcVA/NHoyOLkpu0 ufOw9q73SYjUdO6/ExV0mif0a8nwMy3JA7frteOUddCl3HavfwgqWPDlOPYnf/Y3fvkP2+KXV /c8eRnZomNJsDyUodAAK2dYUNFejwlFviDmzp/B922y98EMaEtgNx+I/re1O3XHYURc1crILA fYNL3Vxxnzglbn/H327HMcTAd3gC6IkqTMkwA1KdMF1ENQk2qUi4MLTQu7gUuHi5CfQej8/Lk tjeHQVtRrevkqmm75T1TFVRHn6ndQuD6a+OheOCnLpKM3/J71QN3xucFUFRfBuf0a/R7Iz7zd GPSZUqDMkqlvEDApBvcMJfNjIEPUhdvx1YI5yt4wKHUzP0pgRMCgwBO0Ec3H2MBd6Hwob2KJ3 oEiZY/oUfvVbw6dqSokG14amFXuhTEEurxMY5ZbdVLB7CJZfCfk/9ws+hoyWr2sKz5JtVGgIL R/yyjHJplV6xP35svfOn2rR5RPcBsw1VVFVOL0jnzuPB6y2q7ts2nkTjwtTxBrFSH6O4D4l2b UcMP88B1YLrLnkpncz2XHZf0naQNlFPI7oTcRbomlgLFMahdhagdIWadhOodn29cLTTyVOuoN IV1pIlmAp1b7b1vkkk6Gp3h4P+7yYi/atFOULqa0oaO45Bh59S+wMzVPuDFlG7kDeDvRWCNZF fQeDiAKcxkLkndkeF4CoG4BD+g2ZbJb2fT0HfPqyu7fjJCVk3y9L05k3ZVGa42b8gvrMx5eW6 /VFtaP3KvTSszxjQcBTQ25PVEs9QMCfZpv6wU0UuZS8GO8+ilKJSSJfRgjPUyboGRkGskt5yx DB+8tVNeaLhK8d12xFDnjBQfgo1Ci0WJ7eXxqDuIzsNfILsV59FDGGhv9jlmNnQI3mttwW6fu Gq49iXKn3AuQESv70Yzluk1kBZMpkzE+Slo+fRlNHJkWPZXj7nhikLvY+DIa8B/0cW8P2XLHZ MkLi8OLuODbWGtNLZC3Es9XMb8qj0RBmeBqFC0jdQSDutJPi8Wl+0MMitSuGtB6PghwaXSqeU 7vk8QJUIo2o5fIX6qE1XnPxZ+Gu86vPs9xVRTHfLssTgwZuVFR6DmlK2uHt/PlP/VXOsy7eqn fvk1+x8JfC8JPLSHZUMr0Omv0lKU5i21YuQ9KqahYy8n+aE0FdNG/8zOml+xd0z0tofMojEaJ hpluavaK9u7y5BNzaLAL6N3r4cDeacH3WtmCwCVV4DnBXFn+KjH0VtxXBKIz4LBNgJcPc+uNb UfWjIQ1vMutUjF/+G1xEDZFbmIcbdYIz2p6/xggRB74APFNQKdu7sDl5g5/xS2FhY9zLcMorz 7d6RNrKGa9WE7/2NH8lA1keF3pE/KD/Qylpy5shLtAAGLBl0iqGo8SJXhF7MIlBp0MAkD

Honestly, up to you how you want to update the narrative. I don’t really have the full context there. I just want to make sure we are clearly communicating what we are actually aligned on in the project currently. Also up to you if you want to wait to see what folks think, though what I proposed is probably the closest to current known project consensus.

In the meantime, is there anything else useful I can share? For example, it terms of project status, the M1 is published and we are aiming to get the 1.0 release process started in the next month or so. This will ultimately require a specification committee vote, so there are no guarantees. One level down, the spec and API is pretty much ready to go already. The TCK still has some gaps that we need to work through. I think the supporting implementation is in decent shape. In parallel we are working on the website, tutorial, and examples, but those are really not part of the official specification.

On Oct 12, 2026, at 12:05 PM, Dominika Tasarz-Sochacka <dominika.tasarz@xxxxxxxx> wrote:


Thank you, Reza - the roadmap wording is only a draft, so it's useful to get your feedback at this stage. 

Steve and I are comfortable with the approach you describe: standalone by default, then evaluating inclusion after each release and asking the platform project.

One option for the changes in the narrative we want to make public would be to show Agentic AI as a standalone spec on its own cadence, with platform inclusion as something to be evaluated rather than planned. We can also keep the EE 12 data foundations (NoSQL, Jakarta Data) separate from the Agentic AI tiles, so nothing suggests it ships with EE 12. This is only a suggestion and I'm happy to consider other ideas?

Many thanks,

Dominika Tasarz-Sochacka
Senior Developer Advocate (Payara, Jakarta EE & Foojay) at Azul



From: Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx>
Date: Monday, 12 October 2026 at 16:23
To: agentic-ai developer discussions <agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Cc: Ivar Grimstad <ivar.grimstad@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>; Steve Butler <steve.butler@xxxxxxxx>; Tanja Obradovic <tanja.obradovic@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>; Shabnam Mayel <shabnam.mayel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>; Dominika Tasarz-Sochacka <dominika.tasarz@xxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: Jakarta EE Roadmap Narrative: your input needed by Fri 16 Oct

Caution: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

Folks,

I am starting this thread as this is not an insignificant decision, and I want to make sure we are all aligned before I respond to the request.

The suggestion here in the thread below is to include the spec as a pretty prominent part of the EE 13 platform (for perspective, that’s probably about 3 years out). This might be tentatively/directionally OK, but I do think in practicality the proposed positioning needs to be altered significantly. Let me explain my thinking but I really need folks in the project to seriously weigh in.

As you well know, we are currently a standalone specification with no short term plans to seek inclusion into the platform. We have been clear about this from the start and this was one of the key factors considered during the specification ballot.

You all understand the reasons behind this. We are forging new ground in a very rapidly evolving space. While I am pretty sure our ideas are well grounded and in line with what is going on in the space, the work is very clearly experimental. We might be exactly right or we may need to significantly evolve the specification in the next few years based on what we learn as we move forward. Being a standalone specification allows us the freedom to experiment and grow our community in directions that makes sense for us. It may mean introducing significant breaking changes to meet the needs of the space or it may not. Furthermore, we are clearly a long way away from broad vendor support. No other specification I know of in EE has been included into the platform under such conditions.

In my view, the right time to begin thinking about being included in the platform would be when we are sure the API is pretty stable, we have real production users delivered through at least one high quality implementation, and we have clear industry traction. That might happen in the next 2-3 years and it might not. I personally have a hard time predicting that far out in the future.

So here is what I am proposing. We should plan to stay standalone by default and continue to have releases working through the backlog we already have and whatever we discover in the future. After each release, we can evaluate where we are. If we feel the conditions are right to pursue inclusion into the platform, we reach out to the platform project and gauge their opinion. If they give us a favorable indication, we will seriously propose inclusion. Otherwise, we table the conversation until the next release.

Can you please share your thoughts on this in the next few days? As you can see, I need to respond by Friday.

Thanks,
Reza

On Oct 9, 2026, at 6:25 AM, Dominika Tasarz-Sochacka <dominika.tasarz@xxxxxxxx> wrote:


Hi all,

Thank you for your input on the High-Level Jakarta Roadmap so far. The visual has been agreed with Ivar - the next step is expanding each tile into a short narrative we can use on the website, in talks and in customer conversations.

A first draft doc is here:

Could you review and add to the sections you know best by end of next week (Friday 16 October)? Each tile has a suggested reviewer, and anything marked [NEEDS INPUT] is where I need your technical details please.

Who I'm hoping will look at what:

* Otavio: AI Integration (NoSQL and vector data foundations) and Ecosystem Growth
* Reza: the Agentic AI tiles across 2026 to 2028, especially the EE 13 platform inclusion wording
* Kenji: Cloud Native, in particular the supply chain trust and EU CRA tile
* Ivar: a full review, plus Java alignment (EE 12 on Java 25, Java 29 on the horizon) and Developer Experience
* Steve: Developer Experience, especially tooling

Please edit directly or leave comments, whichever is easier. Even a quick "looks right" on your sections is helpful and if something is wrong or missing, just feel free to add and change.

The roadmap will be presented at the open call on the 20th of October, then if/when agreed, handed over for publication on the Jakarta EE website.

Many thanks,

Dominika Tasarz-Sochacka
Senior Developer Advocate (Payara, Jakarta EE & Foojay) at Azul



Back to the top