|RE: [wtp-releng] Smoke Test Request for WTP 3.2.0 I-build|
Thank you for getting this thorough look at the J2EE smoke test scenario.
Your points are totally valid. I will appreciate if you spend some time in improving the scenario description with your suggestions.
As yesterday and today were my first encounters with the WTP Smoke test execution, I would like to give you some feedback and to ask for a clarification.
1. In the JavaEE 5 section, ‘verify the EAR project’ part, there is the requirement: ‘verify there is no application.xml file under the /EarContent/META-INF directory’.
Strictly speaking, this was true during my test execution, but there was no directoy /META-INF under /EarContent at all! Maybe this should be reflected in the test description as it tends to be a little bit misleading.
2. In both the J2EE 1.4 and JavaEE 5 sections, ‘verify the EJB project’ part, there is the requirement: ‘verify that under this node all bean classes and interfaces are listed’.
Maybe it should be clarified which exactly classes are meant here. The wizard for the J2EE 1.4 case generates a lot of code, for instance an abstract parent of the bean, as well as a utility class. And it should be clear whether these classes are part of the ‘bean classes and interfaces’ or not. Currently it is not clear which exactly classes are meant.
Thanks for the attention,
Back to the top