Re: [technology-pmc] Formalizing some practices

[Eric Rizzo <erizzo-eclipse@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 2/25/2009 11:23 AM, Wayne Beaton wrote:
> ===Electing Committers===
> The Eclipse Development process allows a project to set its own criteria
> for electing new committers. The Technology PMC requires that all
> committer nominations include specific rationalization of the merit of
> the individual. At a minimum, we expect that all committer nominations
> include a list of at least three bugs (including ids) that the candidate
> has worked on.

Like the others, I'm concerned about putting a specific number of bugs 
as a requirement. Seems to me that will inevitably lead to attempts to 
game that system. I would suggest simply omitting the "at least three" 
part from the last sentence.

Eric