Re: [oaw-wg] Milestone planning for Xpand and MWE
Planning and process sounds like a good idea to me. I'm not sure, though, if
the "you see the TODOs and grab what you like"-part will work. As you said,
both Xpand and MWE are mature projects with a diverse and distributed set of
committers. If all bugs belong to "the team", then everybody will wait for
"the team" (meaning: some part thereof other than myself) to fix them.
I'd prefer to assign the bugs during the milestone planning meeting. If I
commit to a task during the meeting, I'll do your best to really work on that
Sure, there'll always be cases where circumstances don't permit me to work on
Xpand/MWE. I guess we all can live with that as long as I communicate that on
the dev list and move the bug to the next milestone.
On Monday 10 August 2009 16:03:58 Sven Efftinge wrote:
> Hi all,
> (I'm sending this to the oAW working group, because you might not yet
> be subscribed to the EMFT-dev and M2T-dev mailing lists.
> Please subscribe yourself to these developer mailing lists, if you're
> not already subscribed there.)
> I think you all agree with that there has been too little process for
> the MWE and Xpand components during the last years.
> So it's time to introduce some process. For that I'ld like to hold so
> called milestone meetings. We have such meetings for Xtext and found
> it very helpful. The main purpose is to review the last milestone and
> identify bugzillas for the upcoming milestone (as described here
> http://www.eclipse.org/Xtext/developers/process.php) .
> For Xtext we hold it face-to-face, it lasts a whole day, and we always
> have very deep going discussions. I don't think we can and need to do
> that with Xpand and MWE, as the teams are not located at the same
> place and these components are relatively mature.
> So it would basically be a matter of going through the list of
> bugzillas and discussing the priority of them via phone.
> Between the milestones then everybody can see the TODOs and if you're
> able to fix a bug or add a feature, all you need to do is assign the
> bug to you, fix it, and close it.
> Of course it is possible to change the target milestone property
> between milestones. For instance when new bugs come in, which need to
> be fixed ASAP. It will usually be vetoed by other committers if
> there's a problem with that.
> Any objections?
> oaw-wg mailing list