Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[oaw-wg] Re: [oaw-dev] Re: Recipe Framework deprcated?

I think it is ok to have Recipe as a project of it's own under M2T. We really should extract the code from M2T Xpand and make it a separate project with a dedicated team of people taking care of it. This way we can ensure it will be maintained.

Markus, as you have been involved with Recipe for a long time now, it would be great if you could team up with Antony to create a project proposal. I guess this way you will be able to gather some community around Recipe, which is an important thing for a sustainable development of a project.

Cheers, Peter

Sent from my iPhone

On 10.07.2009, at 22:45, Markus Voelter <voelter@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I agree that it needs a major overhaul. I suggest either a
textual DSL to specify "code constraints" or an integration
with Findbugs and the like. We've planned on doing that, but
we don't get around to it.

However, I *strongly* disagree regarding it not belonging to
M2T. Since the purpose of it is that is checks the conformity
of manually written code to generated code and models, M2T
clearly is the place for it.


Sven Efftinge wrote:
In addition I think it does not belong to M2T, because it is not directly about model to text transformation. So, if people think it is useful and want to support it I guess it's best to find a new home.
On Jul 10, 2009, at 9:02 PM, Karsten Thoms wrote:

Hi Andre!

Regarding Recipe it is a bit unclear. The codebase is in Eclipse M2T Xpand migrated, and Antony Wilkins is willing to contribute. So if this component is maintained by someone nothing speaks against having it further in oAW5. I hoped that it would be deprecated, since no one seemed to use it and no one was willing to develop it further.


Am 10.07.2009 um 17:07 schrieb André Arnold:

Hi all,

are the Recipe framework and PLE really deprecated? Am I right, that we just
deprecated UML classic and decided to not include PLE and
Recipe into oAW5 but might include it into oAW 5.5 or whatever we call it. Is
that view correct?



Markus Völter

voelter - ingenieurbüro für softwaretechnologie/itemis
Ötztaler Strasse 38, 70327 Stuttgart-Untertürkheim, Germany
Tel. +49 (0) 171 / 86 01 869
Email: voelter@xxxxxxx

SE Radio Podcast:
omega tau podcast:

Back to the top