Skip to main content
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [microprofile-wg] Proposal: Host MicroProfile in Jakarta EE
  • From: Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Wed, 19 Mar 2025 17:19:35 -0400
  • Delivered-to: microprofile-wg@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/microprofile-wg/>
  • List-help: <mailto:microprofile-wg-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/microprofile-wg>, <mailto:microprofile-wg-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/microprofile-wg>, <mailto:microprofile-wg-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:V5vPrXKNjCY=;Ki48vOObTTMMplfv9B/+3VB9YP+ 4jvdBRW6A/eVMVElGMoXpI2d9A0MKu7v9BiXAltv98bz1fFNVSxqs7V8R+aoztR6nbBQZZBXK W1YoN3f14qIFduRVSeHmKCXLu+om5lVGrFvyjfgriNGpjS1SN25VToQPPVxJ647tGBX9F8LsL cJW34tfl/Nxi6FOIOeEPyEOy8/9gWU6PkgLeJR9SJS//9+VTVc8oCYHA8Op7Mk5x1wNiIpmRU 8+AdWcIf4O/mQ9upqU6VE9xgaR3his3y5DI7Ar+AooqGFqz6IeXA8bSH47zaTdtQXUljA8dru djQ5Te/qaqTGxHoaMsWQ5oZi2tbasv3mheIMcHVr71cJhtWvLEn7eyLu4XIfl1zv3bqhK/P1E 5yjn8GmAJyyfB0i3gbk1H90SPJblNhfQVImJM5SlDUJlBUf+0vPsJewaPEW7tY7ePwHS7/0VH q1dVMXzzXo/wcsgorEavHjCy3rmYctNA6kM5X3ES3zvlYtxBodNCod4wPP6wwKuWeqTEpqllE lDifb412H4Zk6Hcd9D8o1KVqXfrZtv7NrsHeYGYt+9eqg7vU6jU4OPDNTRARc9ppWq4rUEiXV /pav2hjwHBouEtaEcxBs4xynN7yEHlJVnwutYvfaHIgrCivdi1NLV/SMmowAkbtnyahJi/5OG f+AmdlSLCsHTrAOmDaexSSgEvYeqfnYE7M/nlFqfHwPY3Rwr1vRBpHzJCNATmP79qW1PAbMbv prsJNvHUaGANN/tvFTvvEnqf1kM/RKmqVKvni7J0N1wkITtWd4atTWoSxjlSCpI1Qru4qsBoW P28/+nIZFVZHN272rI7H/G3aAkB1vkcm0t7VErTSQCv2aeyEknLa1/zU9vVCsTY6+hO0r+BlC 6TCvAxjoE1JI76rp0m/FscXBWrQRMHkbCaspq7qh6lX53iEgTgjud9xa8sdpeRYjyjUad6ihu F9V6XY+/JiyvBRbXcZWsGWNSe3hLsvfLwbgTKsViyZtbSD6gIi+Zm01KwURhpEKZpnwDpt6Z1 aD7eqQPrPWbFtzKkB9rElgvtxsnvyTCGX6dBdDN3q+fyiRgwnvubIwk4j72QGfHfOkDaWXZSU 2ICylmDrIj0TToRPKZjVtxWZvT35sqdfyS/4zObgmN0jB0HN9hoJN2N8bBqCLQsfF+O2O/38Y XQ25/T3fTWo3U1XiEoSPXaftVrmlESIq0GuWe+YbOmPHBj/WQFRiKBUmpYhfPwEGD+i1bNbIQ eGMgo8WnK8D1xlXPvovfMyC7+0nUB8UDHj0fMB6KT/v7qfFQidWd9N5JBIm11A03qitZkgMmg w+22oOeTwBbMwAy8GjJB8U30I8AjXIMi9re+3fIFxXZUkoXH3nzdurmUHwuJ5tT2z7D0NYkk7 jmggEc/vVjI25x/KJ0UE0jaaWmJ1vPDlXjggrzxr8YVx20Q1fAFRKuSScNjyS0i65oge1i224 nu+l4kg==
  • User-agent: Mozilla Thunderbird

This is a great direction and it is an easy +1 from Microsoft.

In terms of naming, things like Jakarta Health is a lot less of a mouthful than Jakarta MicroProfile Health. We do believe maintaining the MicroProfile brand and differentiation is important and valuable. For example, the resulting new Jakarta Profile could be called "Micro Profile". Similarly, associated sensible package names that would be clear to the community and customers could be: jakarta.microprofile.*. Unfortunately things like org.microprofile.* inside Jakarta EE may prove to be too confusing as it implies a separate domain.

From a Microsoft standpoint, we will do whatever we sensibly can to ensure this is not seen as a zero sum outcome dynamic for anyone and only a net gain for all.

On 3/19/2025 4:37 PM, John Clingan via microprofile-wg wrote:
At yesterday's MicroProfile Steering Committee call, John and Emily presented "Proposal: Host MicroProfile in Jakarta EE". Before replying to this post, please review the meeting minutes to see what has been discussed. Please use this thread to continue the discussion. The proposal is at a high level, and some details would need to be worked out if this proposal moves forward.

However, for the proposal to move forward, we would need to have a vote.  We are not there yet because the details matter.

Let's discuss the details in this thread, which is dual-posted to the Google Group and the MicroProfile Working Group email alias.

For those that attended the meeting, please review the minutes for accuracy.

Thanks! 
_______________________________________________
microprofile-wg mailing list
microprofile-wg@xxxxxxxxxxx
To change your delivery options, retrieve your password, or unsubscribe from this list, visit
https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/microprofile-wg

Back to the top