[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
RE: [equinox-dev] modularized non-Java web content

Great post.
For structuring your URL space I'm a little bit torn -- I really think we can write version aware _javascript_ applications capable of dynamically finding the correct URLs, but for now...
...a technique I've used for handling multiple versions of a js library based around the use of URLs relative to an application base.
{Hopefully this isn't too cryptic}
Basically, I create one bundle that holds nothing but http.registry extensions that together define an application.
To get a flavour of the approach I've tweaked your example...I'm hoping we could remove the version from the path in the bundle)
  <extension point="org.eclipse.equinox.http.registry.resources">
    <resource alias="myapp/dojo" base-name="/dojo-ajax" context-name="myapp"/>
and then in the context of myapp (e.g. in myapp/index.html) use a relative URL:
<script type="text/_javascript_" src=""></script>
In some situations adding a prefix dynamically like Jochen suggests is required, however if at all possible I prefer using relative URLs as it will work with static pages.
http.registry provides an "httpcontexts" extension-point however one real challenge with the approach is that the default implementation only lets you gather resources from the bundle where the extension is defined. To date I've handled this by defining "httpcontexts" and their contributions in the various originating bundles however I've never really liked this. Your post's use of Require-Bundle might be a way forward.
We could add a "bundle" parameter to the httpcontexts extension
<extension point="org.eclipse.equinox.http.registry.httpcontexts">
    <httpcontext name="myapp" path="/" bundle="org.dojotoolkit.js" />
The use of bundle would necessitate a "Require-Bundle" in the declaring bundles manifest so that the internals of http.registry could do a lookup using PackageAdmin to track down the correct RequiredBundle.
I'll open a bug to consider.
      String dojo_base = request.getSession().getServletContext().getAttribute("url.dojo");
      String dojo_base = getServletContext().getAttribute("url.dojo");
should both work with either the servletbridge or the jetty based Http Service implementation. If that's not the case please open a bug as it should.

From: equinox-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:equinox-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Jochen Hiller
Sent: Monday, November 06, 2006 6:59 AM
To: Equinox development mailing list
Subject: Re: [equinox-dev] modularized non-Java web content

Hi Jeff,

On 11/6/06, Jeff McAffer <Jeff_McAffer@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Recently there was a bug report about some dojo stuff not working well with our http service.  That prompted me to try it out and indeed there is a problem.  In any event, in the process of trying this I got dojo and started to play.  I was not happy with the idea that I would put the dojo libs in my actual application bundle since many different apps deployed to the same server might use dojo.  Furthermore, I assume that browsers are not smart enough to handle the same libs at many different URLs in any sort of optimal way.  So I make a dojo bundle that included
  <extension point="org.eclipse.equinox.http.registry.resources">
    <resource alias="/dojo" base-name="/dojo-0.4.0-ajax"/>

Now an dojo-based bundle can contribute content wherever it wants and include something like
        <script type="text/_javascript_" src=""></script>
This seems to work fine.

I agree: This should be the target scenario, to support building reusable components, in respect to restricted resources.

This got me to thinking about modularized, non-Java web content.  For example, what if there are multiple versions of dojo on the server and different apps that need the different dojo versions.  We could have declared the dojo alias to be /dojo-0.4.0 and have apps reference it but then the app would be tightly bound to that version of dojo.

Then I though of having some sort of variable that would be bound to the right version of dojo.  for example,
        <script type="text/_javascript_" src=""></script>
and then dojo_base is set to the appropriate URL fragment.  This is better but in and of itself feels quite brittle and would require quite a bit of maintenance.

You are completely right.

So then I thought, is there some way we can use the OSGi dependency mechanism to handle this?  For example, I have a dojo bundle (called "dojo" with version 0.4.0 that surfaces the dojo function at a particular (set of) URL.  My application bundle could spec a dependency
        Require-Bundle: dojo; version=[0.4.0,0.5.0)        (whatever)
and then if we could manage to have the dojo references in my app's content replaced with the appropriate references as surfaced by the dojo bundle, we'd be rockin.

In a certain light this is like having a dojo service registered in URL space and wanting to access it from HTML/_javascript_ content.

Is there any precedence for this?  Other systems that do such things?  mechanisms that we could leverage?  Is this just a goofy idea?

We are using a component based platform including UI resources. We achieve this behaviour this way: the service provider is registering its resources (in this case: a tupel of an unique ID and the corresponding URL, e.g. in your case "url.dojo.base" to "/dojo", or "/dojo-0.4.0-ajax"). The services which refers to this resources will look up the unique ID to the registered URL.

We do it in a proprietary way. In OSGi context, this could be done via some kind of registry. Lets assume the http.registry component will provide an additional extension point, where the service provider can register its "public resources", e.g.

  <extension point="org.eclipse.equinox.http.registry.url ">
    <url id="url.dojo" url=""/>

Note: The
<resource alias="/dojo" base-name="/dojo-0.4.0-ajax"/> should not be used, as alias is the public URL seen by browser, but should not be used as identifier. It is also possible, that only specific parts of the resources should be made public viewable.

The "http.registry" bundle could provide a service (like "NamedHttpContextService) e.g. "URLResolverService", which can look up the ID to the corresponding URL (or provide a static helper method, for simple access).

For your scenario regarding script variables: typically a web application can store some values within its web container, e.g. referring attributes in ServletContext. The bundle "http.service" is just supporting this (but not yet used, or ?). If the " http.registry" bundle would propagate these URL's in some way (e.g. key is uniqueID, value is the URL) to the servlet context, a JSP could refer to it using standard language features:

      String dojo_base = request.getSession().getServletContext().getAttribute("url.dojo");

This can be made configurable via extension point:

  <extension point="org.eclipse.equinox.http.registry.url ">
    <url id="url.dojo" url="" addToServletContext="true" />

This would need additional implementation in Eclipse based HTTP service, as navigation from HttpSession to HttpServletContext is not yet supported (due to Servlet-API 2.1 only support).

From my point of view, such a "plugin" concept for UI resources would be a necessary mechanism to build UI components. I strongly support your idea !


     This message may contain privileged and/or confidential information.  If you have received this e-mail in error or are not the intended recipient, you may not use, copy, disseminate or distribute it; do not open any attachments, delete it immediately from your system and notify the sender promptly by e-mail that you have done so.  Thank you.