Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [eclipse-pmc] contributed keyword


How about partial committers? If committer only have partial commit rights on some project modules. Does his patches to other modules gets "contributed" keyword?

 regards,
 Eugene


Jerome Lanneluc wrote:
Now that we know what a non-committer is, can we define what a contribution
is ?

Does it include:

1. a change to a SDK project ?
Obviously yes :-)

2. a change to a doc project ?
In the last arch call, we said yes as well

3. a change to a test project ?
I would say yes, but what do you think ?

4. a change to a web project ?
I'm not sure about this one, What do you think ?

5. a change to a non-SDK project (e.g. the releng projects are not included
in the SDK) ?
I would say yes, but what do you think ?

Or should we say that any change committed to the CVS repository related
the Eclipse Project is a contribution ?

Jerome



Daniel Megert <daniel_megert@ch .ibm.com> To Sent by: eclipse-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx eclipse-pmc-bounc cc es@xxxxxxxxxxx eclipse-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx, eclipse-pmc-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx Subject 06/07/2007 10:47 Re: [eclipse-pmc] contributed AM keyword Please respond to eclipse-pmc@eclip se.org



Good, this means that inactive commiters don't get the 'contributed'
keyword as they are still single person commiters on that project.

Dani



             Philippe P Mulet
             <philippe_mulet@f
             r.ibm.com>                                                 To
             Sent by:                  eclipse-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
             eclipse-pmc-bounc                                          cc
             es@xxxxxxxxxxx
                                                                   Subject
                                       Re: [eclipse-pmc] contributed
             07.06.2007 10:45          keyword


             Please respond to
             eclipse-pmc@eclip
                  se.org






Who they work for is irrelevant. The important question is:
"Were they committers to the Eclipse SDK project when they contributed the
patch ?"
If answer is no, then use the "contributed" keyword.




             Daniel Megert
             <daniel_megert@ch
             .ibm.com>                                                  To
             Sent by:                  eclipse-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
             eclipse-pmc-bounc                                          cc
             es@xxxxxxxxxxx
                                                                   Subject
                                       [eclipse-pmc] contributed keyword
             07/06/2007 09:27


             Please respond to
             eclipse-pmc@eclip
                  se.org







Just wanted to get clarification about committers that no longer actively
work on the Eclipse Project. I heard different opinions about that issue
during the call e.g. non-active committers should also get the
'contributed' keyword. However, such committers that no longer work for us,
signed the single person committer agreement and they are still registered
as committers and as far as I know they also have the corresponding
permission on the server and bugzilla.

Can you please clarify. Thanks


Dani



Back to the top