Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [automotive-pmc] [score-dev] PMC Approval required for Committer Election for Nils Hoppe on Eclipse Safe Open Vehicle Core
  • From: Andreas Riexinger <andreas@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Fri, 28 Aug 2026 16:38:31 +0200
  • Delivered-to: automotive-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/automotive-pmc/>
  • List-help: <mailto:automotive-pmc-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/automotive-pmc>, <mailto:automotive-pmc-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/automotive-pmc>, <mailto:automotive-pmc-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:tu1EaNpf2jU=;wMdbsCUjMvFXnyLp457xDkypsta c+xzDgxmM3f/jaCxMMpWqjc6UY4rb1EL+Iz+87VJWxktGZ/NYTykabyR7arMFOOx54GX3s5sN fRyefpKmcyp45uQwnKxiIngNg8NawNRXj1upADyJ8hbYF0cCq36JUytWWnuESH0bPYMikC5KM vAMYYS+tpJuyPvwMONGNqsc7vQjFFbEdJ9cW/fsY3Qm3IJ23vZnlBGmdoRNzJWOUoWG9PzAy4 QDNUSW/pFJQY5z7HAdP5+TRTU+f25i9h2OxKUhY80m/l5dNLoHuA/bpxyGu/80/DUS+4jNDTx KHhBAUXLLK3Qo+Ncq0DxyEQ8DSGXXbA4DTKgsOeGpi7vLQsWJz+W19QGSe17hU5kH/dGv+h9d C4DP7NUSllN4l/NA6XVxEk2a6SgpqKLcMEBr27fpKCZ37vQSAybUVqxz4OkwAdvQ990Aht8j3 tEqX1kaWjKiExFZ3P37T3zNiK2BPHGGi5QNYGIRMajrWEcVzfCGcYTx4v59IA828TnzZ2H/W1 i1ZCWMIdCGCUy1UbZEk6cLpV25WISyb45tEoXOAhuVThDMEpWWFzLY+4YPFS8zI/qDj2rNMM0 zgwW1/rmH9Gi+zXmXtLYhn1sKzZ+EexMFJO8qGHfsNTuEAkrbL3pfD0HZgoNJbxJzw4JHtKey bcEnSTh+I/r4pwbw5EXBv7PwtazU47C+R6s02ihpiDzYUai68MFTBoDTGguTdyWRZcMTJHHxY a7f6c+dAELhMo9FTJjGx4FlvOjcvYI4JD1i2qUvhZMvBPOAU0dAFU2uVFg17C035pJcXIuICF NsKVZglmojy7FmFbrZmqRu7/shlul6WHcMzaR6b3lajLy20rGCFYAAJfOSagPQnPg4ZM/y68/ PBlxt0vwWHQLStZAfreTnSOSKY4c9jF+BFoUJWM0KEAupmDsS5uTWEqzUJAdOd6KlLyHDIoQj /ybUNo6B8cf5tNpJD/JzqBr8J3ANqCN5wBmUrVJ/M+p12Y90hDrz0Wice72pfdJtvhGE0wKpS giX7lhU5/OtKEY+7bpFESY55Abl1H9N/QJed82mY+Ml1dzdc5owVxkos9O1HBgOqdzePNKwpD xDc3uU9uU1E1UFSCocltSmZJg1YLvEeUCLFjbufSOeGazhK9d+vL4EwKf15j54TaRfaLfkKgV oyzGcjgsOLQbyCHUkVLz8DrOei2lje6a98u6XBLLiB+UAX5H5nIDa79euvUbm2IlyWArhrZ9N TN5b7exBf9uVbLUcRbH0f+TygZsE35XmE3NHnJOXVgqnlyipnauU/7aaHruUGSOUFf3ucB9M7 eCfrSNPJfmVUvDOw14+Ipk0mA+Z4ioj8QaLYtRQEa8uMNIRTy3FO4Zk6BciyHNk681YFiTX7Z yzQpDtMdMKBw/KKNYE7gAdA1WG96nYxQaawz/MhIgEdwkxtfUk7VfqZD8Da8qRfmrkgEeBMah JEbPqEurfOl2huux0ARjOq9kh6G23UvL65syqZcF32SqNSz9BWfSfg3k+QFPwFSPB/anOXgN/ uN0R6sYb90XqO6IuY5UIlBf9SyUVFuv3+SCA1Fr3u/gzaKWOHejrCgfPcIXiVCIvh2/WI379K tG1tfRiU7v16w2ib2yfZ7M7NhjBrBjqHxqK2aMkixNRkr0HjO2gPYC7YMotECVxQYIgdJxtpn vFun3YZGi+AosjuepoOJUbA9YnylPQeGEQH+rpWu5nZNaI4ghE/H263ebFinLM/F814JsRAub Ed1WYYTJg1R+JmPRdXw/9yQQ/iuaOWxrgsYbN2Y7Id6xSCpBAcTpaKVUN3fnWGV2OLoThy1V/ bbjxBxorUt50yYkBqIPmfk+LeOtYZkkRgqxoOvV/oKh8ZqK91n4Z9yHu3I6AO5mDfyOuoal2b a5S/xSJjSyJwjwWQZh1vZZqjW5yOZQmmKOaF4qSizY1LZuF5tmnce8i1clrSe5wrIZaJoulmn 9hXlAi5QkCCQv+rXFTKF/Rc5FkrLbnLyiuVo69eUh4SWxla7DkrBHC90afPFe8a9CIVtYBFNF V5LHFvMCKCkyPT57z2Ri1ZlZGCFrJfj3Ocip51pBQHDa/MjZ1oym0yx6hJqIPyMskLNtmQAyZ vGmYf6IdoyjUkViv/GfJzJNNS5fgKSgodVKi++6LWRxYIlB9bsmlmF5vY2ruW/u4cgT5VRKqV lThLxHbS2FPrOStT+NiVPvARnvnDkMQbyIioZ0FCCW688XFJzQaNP7bJggxO1Lq++SvzBMqDT D3wiuWG2kvYjXnYcoqCIT+k/NXL6LeqyihAIJRY+m+32+GdJvcUlUUBRkh2gDK9PdD68S0Xvz EvwUEH9x3fyKAOGAZCf3Av3zpUcgP67iLnWUxpnq3MWphAEQLYpYkxVGOPpnkcySHDSl1pCR1 xxbG35hezyzYIA6qgZ/bQvKswF8OtAnzM2mnvWyoABm6Eseh/4+tTC2ffZ1lSSamjNyrjDion V2GrDB9rA==

Dear Anton, 
Thank you for the update and for clarifying the situation regarding the synchronization issue. 

Unfortunately, we are unable to verify the attached log, as s we could not match the references to the Eclipse S-CORE repositories.
 
To proceed, we will need verifiable material that can be clearly and directly attributed to the future committer. 
As mentioned in our first mail: Please provide 5 to 10 URLs (from any S-CORE repo) to meaningful contributions that shows the merit of Nils.

Thank you for your understanding and support. 

Best regards, 
Andy
on behalf of the Automotive PMC 

Am 19.08.2026 um 07:39 schrieb Krivoborodov Anton, EF-80 <Anton.Krivoborodov@xxxxxx>:

Dear Andy,

Unfortunately, due to some issues with the way synchronization between S-Core and the BMW internal infrastructure was handled, many of Nils’ contributions were committed under the “BMW Contributor” handle.

This issue has now been fixed.

Attached, you will find an extract from the internal history showing Nils’ contributions to the logging modules over the last several years. I hope this helps clarify the situation.

In case you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to reach out to us.

Kind Regards,
Anton


Von: score-dev <score-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx> im Auftrag von Andreas Riexinger via score-dev <score-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Datum: Montag, 27. Juli 2026 um 17:44
An: Automotive PMC discussions <automotive-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx>; score-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx <score-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Cc: Andreas Riexinger <andreas@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>; Eclipse Foundation <emo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Betreff: Re: [score-dev] [automotive-pmc] PMC Approval required for Committer Election for Nils Hoppe on Eclipse Safe Open Vehicle Core


Sent from outside the BMW organization - be CAUTIOUS, particularly with links and attachments. 

Absender außerhalb der BMW Organisation - Bitte VORSICHT beim Öffnen von Links und Anhängen. 

Dear SCORE-Team,

thanks for the nomination of Nils.

We attempted to identify evidence of merit but were unfortunately unable to find enough meaningful contributions in the repositories.
Based on the commit history, the level of participation appears to be rather limited.
Additionally, we could not find any commits at all in the logging repository.  https://github.com/eclipse-score/logging

Please provide 5 to 10 URLs (from any S-CORE repo) to meaningful contributions that shows the merit of Nils.

Thanks!

Best,
Andy
on behalf of the Automotive PMC

P.S. Dear Nils, it is also fine, if you provide the requested information on this mailing list. 


Am 17.07.2026 um 06:04 schrieb Eclipse Foundation via automotive-pmc <automotive-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx>:

The Committer Election for Nils Hoppe on project Eclipse Safe Open Vehicle
Core (automotive.score) concluded successfully.

PMC leads and members can click the election link below to review and
approve.

Election:
https://projects.eclipse.org/projects/automotive.score/elections/election-nils-hoppe-eclipse-safe-open-vehicle-core-0

Project: https://projects.eclipse.org/projects/automotive.score

_______________________________________________
automotive-pmc mailing list
automotive-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org


CONFIDENTIAL

<internal_logging_contibutions_hoppe.md>


Back to the top