Antw: Re: [riena-dev] Various MANIFEST.MF contain wrong version infos

["Olaf Fricke" <Olaf.Fricke@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi,

 

I think you are right, since the default version is 0.0.0, meaning 'any version is allowed'.

 

Unfortunately maven does not like this kind of 'open version', I think I have to change my maven plugin. Nevertheless, I think it would be better for riena, if all dependencies are correct.

 

Besr regards,

Olaf

>>> Christian Campo <christian.campo@xxxxxxxxxxxx> 15.05.2009 14:44 >>>
Hi,

if you click on properties for these plugin dependencies, these version (i.e. 1.0.0) show as Minimum version. The Maximum version is empty so I read this as 1.0.0 is the minimum and maximum is anything above that. (kind of a range).

Same with equinox.log. We require equinox.log 1.1.0 as a minimum (1.0.0 is not enough) and 1.2.0 is equally fine.

I that sense I disagree that removing the version information is the right choice.

I agree it could be more consistent i.e. riena.client should not specify 1.0.0 for any of its dependencies but rather only its own version.

Or where did you get your interpretation that version numbers are this version and only this from ? Is there any documentation that you could point me too if I am wrong here ?

thanks

christian campo

Am 15.05.2009 um 14:27 schrieb Olaf Fricke:

Hello riena team,

 

I am currently trying to build some riena based plugins with maven. I have copied all plugins from the target platform into a local maven repository. I addition, I am using a maven plugin, that converts Require-Bundle entries found in the MANIFEST-MF into maven dependencies at build time.

 

Due to that plugin in found various entries in MANIFEST.MF that could not be resolved alone with a defined target platform. Here a some examples from the M7 platform:

1. The MANIFEST.MF of org.eclipse.riena.client_1.1.0.M7.jar contains a number of entries that define the 1.0.0 version of riena

2. The MANIFEST.MF of org.eclipse.riena.navigation.ui_1.1.0.M7.jar uses org.eclipse.riena.ui.core,org.eclipse.riena.ui.filter;bundle-version="1.0.0", but the target platform contains org.eclipse.riena.ui.filter_1.1.0.M7.jar

3. The MANIFEST.MF of org.eclipse.riena.navigation_1.1.0.M7.jar uses org.eclipse.equinox.log;bundle-version="1.1.0", but the target platform contains org.eclipse.equinox.log_1.2.0.v20090429-1630.jar

 

I thank it would be the best to remove the explicit definition of a version or at least to define a range, that contains the versions of the platform build.

 

Best regards,

Olaf Fricke

<ATT00001.c>