[
Date Prev][
Date Next][
Thread Prev][
Thread Next][
Date Index][
Thread Index]
[
List Home]
|
Re: [agentic-ai-dev] Re: Consensus on API
|
- From: Werner Keil <werner.keil@xxxxxxx>
- Date: Sun, 5 Apr 2026 13:03:48 +0000
- Delivered-to: agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
- Importance: normal
- List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/agentic-ai-dev/>
- List-help: <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
- List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
- List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
- Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:qJufwNvoJMg=;iJkrWsTuNgtRDdBhGKOc2nGTx9Y SNNOXD81JSEA9RlU0ka+gBmEgL1VYQe2fqYRQ+be3NGv9crstpwZRZ64X5lsfH68hzarFdYEz 0o1bds5ynNTTfg4VN2qQ6fM/3SuS3aJi1hbW4VznpOobhz24AZZkgrmV8V29gqWAgezIkf4LZ WIEVawUQ64V3FrrVpeF4FzDBX9dWtcJRk5yCAqxgs7FLWsJDCxuRK6LE10220G28dfZvm8pPV F8eW55Spvd2ZA0v1vH+2Nf1aYP52kkYqfrpr747nBEuq6J8IzdLAvgTGPwvClZJHrtz2j4Kas B4hewUd8VU5IA3XpkHX++7vzpN0m3r/ovnEnZfE5Oqlj2QY6pPPI0jdHFjkgd9imuPINgmyxR HsGwEW/kgkude9HL+q6Nh6Vu9SIduhOmizzIT9KGRMMLUHcebuQnGDxtSFVr+tcdEXFkackJ4 Jye12xPdidQeTiUEJvWhUASIgDoT4+r2lf2Rbk6NiCb3Tc6Ec4XjEo75lsD1aCnbBdb2VP8U7 fOZaazLYt0aL8qv0N1iImKH4iAqu8KRd9F47gxughyt6OHB97P3pr71FRL3fgNw7+7/uk+20d OWYTeksOO595SJ1jn0w/HJs4XUGVeXM8Je1yOuQcSs7wljQEi3c55C0EiC0enbuZooqS0P3Xy jxcsrc1K3O3qYlCoJ76AHnVhDhx0j6X98trtvfdQ6SE/kxAgs85bvWHSmba8QTW32eBYm3ym7 9upluEBkRq9EvCC1RaBBvhI0WHZtg1Q6os3MLgHbE6TySIJZ47FR1skUrHw69BbR57v470oZ5 uQ2KQ1DE8WDoaBPc5g5RB6LOfAfTXM/g6gfiDrZ3B3K8XgbsW1qtDJZtOGcjmX/RkURVyTsFe sbEb7HACUQWt0GfADfiYUCSna8MpoC6mPB3H6ucscRijqTL5aJOaRJR1YAZTpx7RbZOpCwQlY MaXRhId/4+O6qgKsVlTkzPfIGLAOjJ+YwN2Zye4xAAXY6T5zynpENF22LmV4oS7PjzjR66IXO hkrau85+2IhTyYpWv0QPxZnNx0DCqV1dTbImuRL9l7YHR6RwlOoyZ2ciZkKvoAWWyDAiFJ/hO y8S7dQcwYXqnhQxHeHGrsXWvoAWj/eT88wtIYBnz2TLzio2waMkamowu3FOZdOC+Xghsb5zU0 bL/aPbColB3nLpLDnuHnqebppXjFc9agCc+aK+lKY+L5b6N/4oXLuPEugZtVAPlZLBxGgwPAC LWJbJ1bQ/00ExV4MX5rOFv4drWf2HEqndLewizk9a/5q/w/yN8UMVohSRgjMzVPMl/2ZnBTDy 2XJQZxeV/QMcyrm2EVAKXgzul4+501yeC074Gei22Dufix9APaENPT9iQEg7BEk+iZEXEq9oU ONLeoBSRw8x9vsissnHI7e3LO3uTkm+xOzkmgERUhgfyBQbHEmdEa2HjzOvPNGfFPE40OTfEW 3u6EUSvTFegFL/ta+r1ktrfMp49GW0F/rOC1trRmr1PIV8NsJgMd4O2fRYmwb/mPLnZogEEjR JrKNRxbO0g37RMzBPq6gkmW0FJy22Ix8av7tbjddrlQM94OGqVm/AnLHxEaxFRmpoLkPhc812 L9kQmbnOV7SWP+Uy94cSW6JTQ7Y+S5WR43yUAgT7sPyxVdR2j/lq8sJPYw/JJzfn+IzW0FfMJ L7ARp6Uwf60sZs4hyT2fCM9j5bSLFum9myBMlBdmxH/GDjvUkDf3Hzvm8eBxpT5FJjgNfBDxG vbu+aQJJmhYv/P9X8s1gSJ2UmdL1KLCKb/ZysCaR2QLRA+fgI3tmlLJXsBREpTnWST6fiI3EF IlrNG8VZ6VH8nxPZnjRATzVndE++yen8BcCsGSHUO05Y27gAE5fJ/Xc1Gfis8OZrLlzLKjijQ pjNp6FuKWur/qLoIbJXTdG4MabI48gtsCb26/Uma/IoIyrjrBOizTE/wJKUZdcX+Kdk220mK4 xrFzcxwHtqrZ/S3joVaUZ7WPy9b7iWQ+kfbDTDi5FBIu+Obe1kR6PgV4y3WTlItRtj3nYtpzo b9AFacAlkT+thx+mO8geLkAbvZNTdOt6S0Fua5lQp7lYIqC+zYl8BLGy/8mAIA0XOqkezxwJZ wDJQSoAVg6m5QaZKAAsC7MgXLZRqP3YMdjag6qKtojbOXcsgNvB7xemHtaVw3YaSx1SUpTdpd a584xqaqR58ZXVsIsoKz/n3di/oiN7+ViUjPYSjMDKKmFHCuawSTJkZQnw36P+00j9yrE7kZK nxODgu+dzXNWg741IXcpQrKgeV28T74xX3twjrdGyL28puKx5zKUB9HkYMPPfNauxV5gxwtBx gqdCFc/sFVpGairzEiw/BTKOpkq08l0fYXdyE58lci2FxooUZOY6V1h0Gh1bOqWr9xOVSK1cr vsN5ELhHbc4HA6sDUl8ty+UHQdJeVwQtVAjj9mJAuWW7DHX0hAmP2PNb99V6uSzO0mNr++uY8 GjayIXjxgeQZCYHjPlR6e2b/LYu7OUhW6SghlltosN92I/7k3NjAJeuq5oy+d8eXyWnlLcZMb gwOZ1zzcOtSl3eZceMZFFSxvgeTwTOAmHWICizJWNQNWfe08eU6UKYJw/EeJv/+Q3m101TDHR RAKpOtmFgqhFKrxEdqCA1dtAqBXV3Noj2IHdT6poeg+8/NUNVOiS67YlJ+lAHmxXZbZbI74Kl u59hjB2bi/IDg1KwWagx/9JioSrfb/CItl0Ipa/+HqkpbalUYPSlWCbMkAKdMCzDmDr6F6eVj d6c4NkHOFtB0Suzduw9lYyq/L6HEwZjcTAML9Z9DrtxBVQlNASI0MrBHQeE/9sXzm5cbzuTBV Rlm3mWWWJT5SmhoRnGSzq8nCU5CYk1VcOM6A8pKmw/kWxtgtrz8EP5WhHgC4i8cmnisTprZ4P u7Qm/c4y7GKZbTtF5zs5Li+EJqbv4AcYCIiaU+lisM89+GzS1DttgUp8+6xJ7e3Le0dysaU/7 PFvahKkFBES8kVDHuhKHNJDCZLk9lfyVAG6CPJYTJnrf+nT2IaFCvJ/oQgjVXBufEKWcqc9Fw 58KyWarX19uM3K9MNE+EINxKsotXWm1zWGITXsvbyraKflhEMwk1sV63Vlb8OXrSQmOvzlPbZ //jm2W1fMSKJeFCJyYRABPyXmYSR/Di9erxlGnEYNzNuxiQs8ZD6yEuKkvry2QrJzzEKKUTA/ ts2bmTA1wNCiLp1o28LYb5OwLu0PFoglsAXLudxgHGG/Q+xnFibLKGFtykNrxRd7gLxqwhRuj hpdNlRDYmy+c3hcfG1ElNfIALfJ1BhJuBdhI2UZ7MN+FMvOGGrbW+irCZlZhnP9K6+SSFFFaN kPHl761gbr7CCRT27ZSdsYmo97GHNrsdrcexn12j9NY+NwladbD6C82X1/sgHPd9RUIV1wQG+ DaKslwwR6sWPoIAJ13Zxqa10gdbCiiLsGGRimWd9PIzzP/uMXnbLaeRrPhhI60nCHvXPkS3eG J+u7nLQ9VF3+ofxfUvU2OqSoJderh44LyrMpfTLRtKD3gCegSS/QA0qq+CCuOmLJSNn1h+mII JNAYS0US6t+CY3EXQwXifoP3a6yhPyJDQwsw4YcsBaM/f/7nZxOa3oDfUJfepGrdMi6S9QaL7 yiDMgsOOK2YclqBpBFKBVuuhrZ3FX7PJFD+GoRiOegWlWmVUisaOnxgndcT6SrQHmdBMcfqLA VTxQsFR9o1BoWgsWAcvxqcM69/+g1PGK5Y3rGoOOOppZt3bmfyOcMCp5X+DJNnvbHbnTZVR2N 2b71jg1MubWZF12vmeP4UQS9uzCLddKlBARu5Z7LV7hQJgDD66VkXmhnihnSiywWiybersi3i ytH+Arsn1dCbdvB+44kFjJzPQWhyX2o3fYmIl4coyg1lCjjTX1+Abzs8tbxqKOf1zY8YprhEK Zo4Ptbc898hSh0tamUfVYNJlW/VaMpLGGhIZJ+WvN6vCwWQx30XI0Awok8PJaQ/QRcse2JoNl 86m8wvb7RULedUKtLC46CAhMoceG0JxjLSnRKmzHuOY1RY2tXQmavzDAo4XRfy9JhdcYM2VVL BVQBy1mFvd2HWQ6zBhbV/+dhf94VqEpTBEolj21TLuo+f4DnLzhDHC2P3bTZHJadNQufwywFh Dtt6MPmSR3kJPgPZWcOANL7u+iH2XPe4P4CLtbfqPv5isayckpjrIqbaf/doYB2ulQW1nkBJv TMWAj7iqM9tn8Tzx0QsLnRTlOmflpdGPxERwd/5CHYyBR4wVw3QgWFm9kzEuiyQDyE3JWfRbR ptwSnTkV5AUdZwsPAJOYHXVQkA2m5xrs70+hZ9b05lI3aNWS0ZKVz28xB2G81RluFtgUKtVqB LfTbIEoNxSt1cLHa9MOhG0AlNqilbwXJqXKE68k7KwWXYq63YXLOukQNNtrRdWGoj6lC3/R4y h9wFsTISVN30jQ592qkTSwcE9vLdnBSiuIVipecu9E6OFYh0e1j8A0gnOhB0C9zKHkJifW46y XCIuTAHTwenfeN+mLHNpPkX75OXvdHRBis90mt7Xdf2GePQ4pBVjduKrKZa3fWgJ61tskCIUN 853gAXQUqnulIurKt+YmqMFVHsjJeAvxnylTue3RpH5RrGEUXJP5bApmsLxfwUxIc2XEQg3g6 csvjKMzsRdpZ9dBYMiqtYmG5+xyqEY2Y7YHyACpO8UO/eEcIQnVRlIEejb1KcTquYSrqf+LAy mXigAbhBPAqn329JSjYvH7pjH1rpBZfKSjdIKUMt1DFJ7iGx5jm9bMAjxiOBdzXisUkCe85S9 yVkVVXuDQ0dXz4aHyQAyUw44eubiV83/ANHCl/2j0UWWEsb4EVGqdgcUwHLUHF9JrIAH3vAqY 5OyGWU9qRF6HgPM02iRLVKbv6UXn3o/sIdl1k6zhtq2cgeI3iazNfIsUdbK+ArxMgGm8ImcO4 Nf5j1tQAJ8Era1PGf0eX2bGJQiHRgh69zfAVg+W8plRzo6G3P9mtNzB2Z5YGBxId7GJhK4ZZe pmWgF/Q34R8+GfPHfmwzT0kSqTQBtkwKl/U=
It's almost too late now, sorry I couldn't reply here earlier, now the holidays leave a bit more time.
The API looks fine to me for v1.
Rather flat hierarchy, but there are not so many elements. A bit like e.g. Servlet in the early days.
That added an "annotation" package later, but this API consists of nearly 90% annotations, it would move almost everything there.
If additional concepts and features like workflow became part of the API we should try to structure it, to avoid the top level package being cluttered, but for now it looks OK.
Werner
--
Gesendet mit der GMX Mail App
Am 27.03.26, 08:53 schrieb Reza Rahman via agentic-ai-dev <agentic-ai-dev@
eclipse.org>:
I still have not heard back from committers and that really is unfortunate. I am going to give us one more week, because this really does matter. After that, we should not wait any more and will be moving forward with the v1 API largely as-is.
On Mar 25, 2026, at 7:38 AM, Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@mail.com> wrote:
A gentle reminder. For v1, we would wan to aim for a solid, consensus based foundation. Review is instrumental to that.
On Mar 21, 2026, at 7:17 PM, Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@mail.com> wrote:
Folks,
Our next step is to publish the API to Maven staging. This will effectively make it available to developers. Before we do that step, I would like to reach committer consensus.
I do hope that by now you have taken some time to review the context. I now ask that you carefully review the proposed API:
https://github.com/jakartaee/agentic-ai/tree/main/api. While the specification document will have a lot more details, a great deal of the behavior is actually already documented in the API Javadoc.
Please provide your feedback and comments here. I will spin out separate threads to keep the discussion focused if necessary. I would like to see if we can achieve consensus by Friday. In that spirit, if everything looks good from a v1 perspective, I ask that you please respond with a +1 so I can count your vote.
Onward!
Cheers,
Reza
_______________________________________________agentic-ai-dev mailing listagentic-ai-dev@eclipse.orgTo unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org
_______________________________________________agentic-ai-dev mailing listagentic-ai-dev@eclipse.orgTo unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org
_______________________________________________ agentic-ai-dev mailing list agentic-ai-dev@eclipse.org To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org
