Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [agentic-ai-dev] Please Review Context
  • From: Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Thu, 12 Mar 2026 17:38:13 -0400
  • Delivered-to: agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/agentic-ai-dev/>
  • List-help: <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:HIZch5bSz2s=;S4POQvxgo8XkMIW/A/URt6d5W3E 7oz7GwSOONdrWMncKFqAnu9Ubr1EJv7uSq5jL87ezxBCBqpPeLLmQW6wMfHGAamxaPkU3z3sv No4sfs317n8WJ1j1Qpa9E9IukougbhnHsTSSgKlR1sOkwoVduLtga8B6KahY2Ma2QT7BdXru5 LvqfWQPY7TMCfpd0PfQoS0wjT2v4K5hrkiFibcFTKSrFrkNDmCpqmHKFBEM4cJg40K6CammD4 wj4EJfUg44jrYMDrkvE/S5/8tzlu85yKJG/94wewgvNUKrNqrYT652FvUixZBFz0qqDUCu15X Arrt9QnMfwYeaRzV4GimWQfr8cEqtrRYjBgd1a3w4I9/FyHQuTov3UTXXknvYZDMvt52QKyms tNFbiaGP3q2ISqKFXqE3/0JTIEXhc5snwd9RZJT+cacbnimWbzjmSzqoer8SZJUtk8Ge7PWeb VhFkzdYzf1qqRRwn2jDbvMra6kIX9p+t5+2rK4+dz5t4+Gi3ETNquxbXAhk2w+3W509WB3nhB 2p+XHk46RmiLzzf1Si6bXGvaCFTPEkLe/OYEe9A362zKmtV/RMMVBw7Aldi4LPBNvN9pJd42I DCx0s9/wSxlFsaS8ZVUWqn3nTaarYa6hnGcFiQfqaCuEoj6g4gT3hr83kvVivSdZ0JVmkAlOn aLeOFYm1RLd1PHWDie1O8v4xxLZi8+jc3tw2uCzTjufnzAC4R/B0zL7jITOM3Oph21yyImT/F u1kvubqPLN3EaXW9sa+8KVNon3uYDw0WCnnvlQfw07rnZcF8db/lSVeyUMPAGuIiOfSH/rQ9d Ep7ZaMTx2bZtdr8qZW9bxtIHeIX43yVhbs/mLypdxI2/lijnyJxGqVR2XfXhbSzUsSyifP3w2 vEw5Hv67JTUlFZSJdfVbMay++AdMpOALSubikvzQXzQvwp8hdHtzbG3z4O4o1JcoVbEhN9HKE lslOJz+d1Xb5aMTNttbtL7nDTlQebKyvzYteVVt3+Dx2EJYg6ytzxuEPUWY2GqGCo8dUG4zSk ggN4y01oIB1GqdYG8JGCw0sSMV9I5ArjKDD5c6ub/bI8BYBWFjAdAjpQUxX7xrwsTdMgQbT+Z YjIzAmN53lb6L8F0ksBaUUPhJHS2ol0dFweI4nhkZTjNsd9OLui8QtdVVqRpzaYuLzYUKfU71 54aoq972BQCOZpDc/zwaKCu7WAxpzkFkdFxVAD5BPDof++r3bpGT3x+jXYRz3xOeC01F4hvVh /etAbJJtOV4w8WNADYvj83UTFkSF6jsauIb55qh8EUUgk2wzryOkiFOhSgMEWbgYxnmeQYIa/ ktck1d86BwJ2r6pbIvD6IMOtvyfuCYo8XH+X/GyEyoPWfqNBarvaO7S08zelRzyOac0v7BKgA Q4VQ6caB+RbYO5tXhhXnCqFeXZwQIbIzzRV1vOs9CbGKDpOsXbYTa5l8WAs/sI1++6gTopQ/v IPyT0O8SmEYSTuTsHJ6KJEj/ab5A2aaHQyDwotJJNQB0G1Y1AuWh5Y2tTJ7ph2iXS5UCK1cjw ZTlkff9Kv8rBE1aJtN+zxyQK4TF5PqWlBG653BzzGa3H6BU8CHCKua2LnAeuqX9KmaAsP7I6f 6DS3UWNmD/Nze7wQ04OSSgOL2GysbSKWiQdfcbG3kyJDfcdYj00FXC5xN6a1/OqcoHggGjLnO hWqTcaE2BSgBHzeVKmhkoUYB3yL6QJNxvlZMBfxpqD4P/+utYj5ZcyZcLdvyE+bO6VZLs9WnA 4WnLhBExFN8FEg/WqxgpJP2Ga/V9bCM1Py6CJd+tQWB/fJwqamenxWiPkCR0eVLS4gNfaJEvK iizkYYVBL8cUXWEzg7RYBIKbmrnErH8+wqdNMAnXSVWwn8FrrgJp8ARtek3mHTDXQ/3YeQokc nxA3CMmSYMj8rk2uYcPtxZCcB2ISRGGtI8SAlLNu40ErjjpxHdAMtGabA5CL3oHID0JuT/IiF ptVPxDz929H3z++YYFfULivL19F0VRkCXLWZhbfwX3oMR1uj/DAzE77wsAwy9qminalYi1gFb VKwbJTQs+nQGrF4SJ51iX+3V8tdgplfVN8nx5/Zo6tUmBU9enteG++pqP3YHn3jEvC9SsEcjQ BWNao0P/nWxHpPeGyOg+uwvQfN/6Ry9KVdUdEfxVagbVql3kO9IVIXBHAipd1BjdQLCx5M+Vc KtbV59nsuQWPEtXNH261Pgkr+dzyBuE4kc6iMbCIgagBKcFeGg7MIcUzt7e/eHWJRw8aoG5G/ 2r6Dppgjr/pZn1BaPB5+lwBn5yGf0uIKKZ/SfQl12HnAEICdjaNl2Nt1qAmiFvTGp4XGVVYYL bwM3Zh+9Mh3x5FOb5FvwdHnVB/LTyhyrYlm2oMzzBulwa3oKzayO8vWMDUD6SabhnuIGopO27 mXnjuylqcqLmjcowN3npaj4CUdTJ+erZAiH/pGwb4AuUsoXEd83qkCgUY9sUQN0xKE5nz0+uM i7YXCrxTlZFXLV5pby1VDtwHXMJzG4UIvM5v+bHRObmvQY3QuIIXBRmkN91EksoWC5++LBbgS 3ND3+qgLQ2J9vzNyoKQUAMxlBI10hr94JvKOpPjznXKrMC8OHSQWVCqac5oDQac7BxHr3YhKM sx98+MStSOjQpuBoCFfAg87fHGqBbvd8dtXaCKh9Xym2s5qPHfxGlSoyrmnSd1pV1YIE0LMfD +spOodQG4ZvNZ2tR551cvat4/SB8K8F75VUCJ1cAGdEE5DBkIZCqwpWrhskvbXR4QuT+gwsYr vwdLxNrnqC2/LOvkzUM+beoOSZ7ScfFwRUFzCUZQpmX9yGPgqXxGSw/0YhqKFkFaSShwN1onK 6RvjoTVssNQXOyxfulpH7byPXU0UBdg9hjXqBjyzW18bAsBddSIi1w6n5S4PkEeGmak96p1jZ 3sIzrM2TRAWj5zGiCeju8oZ+TCNPZCK7IlKUeQpB8/rEfSpa5Tny6D/yVmUewDyXCxgtfl7D+ P5vVOnmCIxiHy8LZhxSM/NGCeU0au24JXg0YoKGmT7k6LAGXmEL+xiVsFjBlEmocwAcCV4JK5 5LftgFapd3JEv3+i7ylbeCnBvxtWMZqXiUFHiAoyq33eaKr0Xjai6pmrtMMkpgA93OzqOnQ/M Ul10ItV9fdCCBiFK6yJkmavhl4AlDgXqYn8OYVZkQHnzPAbLsAf4NOWp8P39d2gjLvulZi+0x ZYIToUw4ygtctErCI3HXHFNAxVQje22Vrzga0irPmcFmZpHW++fwPFIQWRUChppsqbSJnvTU5 7xWOoQ1X4l6iuQfTxEhwuQ6itda+1vgPikiEgQPJBI/joIk23eru5UqjaEuCmEI+Gcy3UPKhC RVFYX6kmEtGn7z7MH9gL2fiPqN+WW4ufBEl08PzLxtfzSu6D4M3gl54t73K5vb9eT/53OHvbk 4oMUIZRQ99+pbNOMbozO+moJggW2xoA2CUKIUtcC45gEHKMQSI0Pxe7dxz62jNozDS18hMdmb PWrh1pBlp9u66Nn01NMIayAw2rMpR0JKzABxbtxp5PRpR98eUc797l+Tb6gCuZbb2/9df75Z4 FSUZ9x3s9Ue5USpQRcDvSXcTYPvMK8Z0BPBA9un4QYj3Nbcuak+ySuuXYeSdRbh4kJqbhxdz0 GXIx15uF5+fhKvS4/5MU6WU/s3oEg8E3UMzSthcwQ1QQcyepVWTGgF2l54fnBnBBQkof5qWpI 1hJpyCW56Zfxmh4HxIdCUnlPSxKjkuP/yA+z1Sqpr/9iPHfqQvewAqYgrpIBBvFcc3mOagDnx ZQZNaMU3zaC7svOwmew2hyHj6x2/TwMyGhoc5kGcUsDt5rjzRc63GakQWy2wLvv25/Yqh7RBC Ag1Qs4lytLw5n03Z57C9YwmX6Bb12/QrQq/mDrjCqlR4XNOoBlfHvM9FF+UOe3V1hloI2hI4e ZJ4lppiC6stXtTsI0TJ70SPPkFObmDIcJeWCTYU7AcThu1vSEfpqpCv2/6Y5jXkel0VqVU612 0owEl7tjX+wz4ewpszOHUYfx2i72jytbrUX+IbirxwX8i/BeW5cqIn/wPFC1koLZ1C9J2zT5a jklWfeCYTKLSLA799VOD2p8grMP6Vf+EKltdfG305h7fZGEyFZ0ZoOOBOks9MIKJZCd5+RvcV 8/ZFLCukqfvbiGBzLLe9HsYopU/MFeuTDmgeRPF9/FFeHUm89qn3OHbwMA8BDVsMJtU8q9lT7 nsuvz0KvddDovF/eM8rmA1y+kuIVNtks3XYpKaCz+/Uw6u6bedZbDfww/xKqlnLZ67DYMAkiA 6vN1zEwNGaYP71jupzUBJ0bj8H5kESDhwC4MZqJpgpFaGeQr3L7XxM0Y+QOyUVVTPqfb4BK4L UsuopzkgzSQou/YSOlr/yM6CkBc3EAHaNb9/jiiXsBXFOHSHComxyOC6Bpz6+c+kU07ZfsSCR RTPWvjkGDWiqo2Uz6IuXtsenu8VAMgxzPTrUELNpyKxfh8JJlGHAjswY1CGwutqap79DmhhQd CqKTf4EuJzImVQNpU9FMzi24dsxcixgdmkrSZvbaGCesDSp9wqryDEwT/dbBmmnFKg3JrFMh5 6n90GN+GHMV8mOYx6zaKisPczQs+HhhlazQuXUQD4137fiqnLmqZq8hadN4vPrD/yVILH8NE/ mPonQ4VVyrDoJe93uzIu0xl8QwYTp5ZAAXweGyguO6bVPM5zi0w8vv7tTSQEsVbooM3pgdlub ogBk4dcqm7JZRpd0y6WxE4Nkz3igSyaR1NgPiA/kDoJTaAdjUcZkczrTzWHuntvS2Ea12TDcX MLXimdo4LUBShTuxRRpQNAZOzMvWiC/ioAQZOB2DDkYMkbeeVo+tUFdYSRCmBsvb9I2ByXWX2 E9VkkQS4FpTnm/oDw7FUgJs3PmZRBxyMHXD2mAkkeib9GgxtfxG1nZ+baQY1yFICjW5L42z4q RwP9rCxJ7zoE8fh7N1z62s4/Sc6kLZNPrLFedkrh5gzS+/nc/Rr4iKhfp6SRadWspdV2E/VHO O4lBbpqxvIS15Y+2y7En7cfMRbziNPo4GisY3pL7qxMImmlGYD6Q3+txhx3tw012jpbj8iJR6 4X1inRzN271Cfii4Tix6Ae8d7u7erXHFWBhdF/3CWQT5Xz+BU36a/pbzSNwmwV3j0mRkZgzQF MJ/oFexnKfhV4OuBt6/ozIB9f4IjdhV7q1ySNEcR4UsMOyNbR+9SAnhrRYO0fkPbZnP455Bto nUb6VjfV357PnGyPKufGMygdGSQIuFFQUMLLhLLvBKKKPXFZ/EasoG9wUgm4oK9cgtXG3M+cb yiQp81aSlSC4B7Zzxypn8BWSnqYUgprTFN5Q5CHxuJdQDVgxNxxyS3A1djAoonFgECO8riE3l FeSnlhYEQHKZh70bFpOHMs6mO9TZN3RdpkwEywlgEGs2wJ5pePL2iLr6tFm6rlYiFq1SLkuCm BKlOsP6Dwfxj+K+JrZkrvND8swwu8D6S/AXp3sVDJj+R4Fvoj728xNvkNIEnO7Y9kh

I do think we have something available for folks that really need it. Luis can comment.

To be transparent though, specification discussions typically often don’t have implementations right away. I think that’s the norm rather than the exception, certainly for Java EE if not Jakarta EE.

On Mar 12, 2026, at 5:04 PM, lenny@xxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

Hi,

At this point, I think it’s would be very difficult to have any useful feedback without having running code available.
IMHO the best way to do this is to have a publicly-accessible artifacts on an open nexus instance.

On Mar 11, 2026, at 7:22 PM, Reza Rahman via agentic-ai-dev <agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Hi folks,

Our next order of consensus is the current API proposal. The API actually contains detailed embedded Javadoc that defines quite a bit of the specification behavior already.

However, before starting the API review, it’s important that you actually review the broader context that is already available. So, can I kindly ask you to review the following over this week and next week?


Do you mind replying here with any follow up thoughts after you review the above? I’ll split into separate threads if necessary to keep discussion focused on specific areas. If everything looks good, especially from a v1 perspective, briefly indicating that is helpful as well. I know at least some folks are well familiar with the material already. After the discussion of the context winds down, I’ll attempt to start an actual API review thread hopefully followed by a vote to record committer consensus.

Onward!

Thanks,
Reza
_______________________________________________
agentic-ai-dev mailing list
agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org


Back to the top