It doesn't appear that there are any rules regarding dependencies on
incubating projects in the EDP or for the simultaneous release, and
I don't believe that WTP has any particular guidelines in this
area. There are rules for "Incubators", but that doesn't apply to
this discussion.
We should probably first decide as a PMC what we think is
appropriate for WTP regarding dependencies on incubating projects.
I think in general this is seen as taboo given the perceived risk
associated with such a decision, but perhaps it is reasonable to
have exceptions for certain cases. In any case, I think it
warrants further discussion, so let's add this to the agenda for the
next meeting.
Neil
On 11/30/2010 11:37 AM, Raev, Kaloyan wrote:
Dear PMC,
I am really sorry for being awfully late for the call. I
had an important meeting before the call that took longer than
expected.
Here is some update from me for the last week:
- OSGi Enterprise Tools. The Creation Review is delayed due
to the trademark check. The Eclipse Foundation requested the
OSGi Alliance to use the word “OSGi” in the project name and
is waiting for approval. Until then we can use the time to
think up a shorter
name of the project. Please, join the following forum
discussion if you are interested: http://www.eclipse.org/forums/index.php?t=msg&th=200807
- JPA Diagram Editor. As I mentioned in a previous mail [1],
the Graphiti project plans to join the Indigo train, but
still remain in incubation state. I have involved one of
their mentors, Bernd Kolb, to clarify with them why they
wish being longer in incubation
and if they can change their mind.
Bernd requested me to ask the following question Neil and
the PMC: Is it *a must* to have Graphiti graduated
before accepting the JPA Editor as a component of Dali?
Perhaps, this is a requirement of the Eclipse Development
Process. In this case, there is no question about it. But, if
EDP does not require it, then it is up to the decision of the
Dali project.
Greetings,
Kaloyan
Raev
Senior Developer
TD Core JS App Model & Dev
SAP Labs Bulgaria
136A Tzar Boris 3 blvd.
1618 Sofia, Bulgaria
T +359 2 9157-416
mailto:kaloyan.raev@xxxxxxx
www.sap.com
Save a tree - please do
not print this email unless you really need to.
_______________________________________________
wtp-pmc mailing list
wtp-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/wtp-pmc
|
