| Re: [wtp-pmc] JPA Diagram Editor Release Review |
|
Hi Wayne, Any news from you? I missed to tell that there is a time pressure.
We would like to have the release available on December 1st at
latest. I hope we have enough time to go through EDP. I am reading the about EDP right now. I find chapter 6.3.8
Restructuring Review relevant for our case: “A Restructuring Review may necessitate the construction
of one or more new projects. This tends to occur when an existing project is
decomposed into two or more projects. In this case, a Restructuring Review is
similar to a Creation Review. Any new projects that are created as part of a
Restructuring Review must have their scope explicitly specified as part of the
review. The scope of any new project must be a subset of the scope of the
original project.” So, in our case we would like to take part of the WTP Incubator
project – the JPA Diagram Editor component, and create a new project for it
with the same scope, code and committers. And we want to combine this (chapter
6.3.9) with a Release Review. Please, let me know if this is meaningful and possible. I will
appreciate any hints about required documents. Thanks, Kaloyan From: Raev, Kaloyan Hi Wayne, We have just discussed this issue in the WTP PMC. We decided
that the best approach should be that the JPA Diagram Editor, which is
currently a WTP Incubator Component, “moves” to a new subproject (yet
incubating) under the WTP Dali project. So, at the end, we release version 0.5
from this new JPA Diagram Editor project and not from the WTP Incubator
component. Now, the big question is: “How is this going to happen?”. We
suggest that we extend the Release Review to a “Pre-graduation Release Review +
Move/Creation Review”. We will include some more slides in the document, which
describe the “move mechanics” – what infrastructure moves where. Does this sound reasonable? Do we need to create a new proposal
document? We still have the one from the time we introduced the JPA Diagram
Editor in the WTP Incubator: http://wiki.eclipse.org/WTP/JPA_Diagram_Editor/Proposal Greetings, Kaloyan From: Raev, Kaloyan Thanks, Wayne. We will discuss this in the PMC. Greetings, Kaloyan From: Wayne Beaton
[mailto:wayne@xxxxxxxxxxx] There is no notion of releasing a component in the EDP. Only
projects can release and projects designated as "incubators" don't
tend to release at all. Hi
Wayne, We
would like to schedule a release review for the JPA Diagram Editor, which is
currently incubating under the WTP Incubator. Which
is the next possible date to schedule a Release Review? I
attach the docuware, that Stefan (the project lead) has prepared. The only
thing left is to generate the IP Log. Could you give us some instructions how
to do this? We try to use the Woolsey tools, but we are not sure if it is
“production ready”. Could you point us to some documentation how to use it? Thanks,
Kaloyan Raev -- Wayne Beaton, The Eclipse Foundation http://www.eclipse.org -- Join me at EclipseCon 2011 http://eclipsecon.org/ |