Skip to main content
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[tycho-user] How to require exact bundle version (including qualifier)?
  • From: Andreas Sewe <andreas.sewe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Mon, 9 Jul 2018 17:20:42 +0200
  • Autocrypt: addr=andreas.sewe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx; prefer-encrypt=mutual; keydata= xsFNBE52BNoBEACptXWaCffDNBO22AKe6avrANiUm+eH0NG0j0t47ZYBzO4p5oN+k8yDy4K+ Y0BR7S4k5s+6oND7dN3klzX0tXVz04oT+6OanKXcSZ7B2jyTuljvDPsMAKDDCPupNwIfRqyj tM4CoQTG7Ypsz3l+jctqT/fHG7aLGNC+8oNHyBhVTtGWqWNTpOZb66gJF3O80bD9CTdjQt+X YLtHu1evJTlyCfWTnS5V3YcvAyiKIYftesyEubt5zPnMNSVCLst1zAN8+rDLsYL1Ag37NRwB aR/Fu/nW1k22dNv1N2cZGXHBGFJYmXVpkOum7v9G0cnnpIuXbQMmv2YRkMCzg6Me0czK9tvD wjLFbeqgtNTmXSj/Vp+V4kBN9LIJQM6D6p7gG54JLy1SOm2LpJ0jsS70sXmHP+nq2lnDHdoX UvaWkyeMQQTTcRoAl8Q3SJrSYKy2GD423V7X0rfyyyTbsfD4ekPkENbjGhp1IrkxpFSx77oH GHruAiDMq3XCYmILdAs7it7LyRdgNMOPfOU15Csnb5EDsczbnfvlWk54BR3NRyGZV1mJJ8dc XfTEBDssXcM452bPnD/kCufKi23j9LrHH+LnlSAGuwmRRx3pe19AYasf2ffO8QUrFPYSFBWG iRTbZF3xMqo849iHGYLBcfow2oIecNqG2xe7RlbzjCQskb0+vQARAQABzTRBbmRyZWFzIFNl d2UgKGJvcm4gb24gMTk4MC0xMi0zMCBpbiBUd2lzdHJpbmdlbiwgREUpwsF3BBMBCgAhAhsB Ah4BAheAAhkBBQJUMEKABAsJCAcEFQoJCAQWAwIBAAoJEJiqtuMaAfob9hEP/RlebenKRmTC rKQC7JVikQOW9Jn+rQqq3U1FpC7Dz6uR7XA0d48xz1F1rLu0twyYeD5aPHv+ckA0DLCuiK/N OBiVH1D6vLRyi7LMf9ksfE1PZqYet8DS8/ftQAcZRd5ULJyJ84I73PNt/PEccNbh5xX4AJyE X/sf/ttKHdtSgQJiSxGcYcEgsawmCVAWxhkJRvwdnXCe/dS6W7ovxnuv4fsh3WAqAUyBPfZI 9bIelrC4s9065Wh/bx1vY3z4Ys4Igj9pzwuj1DFgbPwBYutE3s/wmoOMS7dIT1aKzfl799k3 T2Q1kM2EMEXE6uG1CL7nPCxjoXb4Z+rfBE86KvOTNGvBV+uwMh8QoOWUSxWUZu9geLiRvS13 IFhLofn+RBMTV1Ui/bCCnv5RRw7+2I+NjCcBGGiUUnCLbD8AK2du6cLf2byHsgRqysd/auMi JtW1lWzgPGUPCMKeLYbzJZcovAE1cD8u2QFbD0SKFvceS7ENbGqBEzhapA/W7cQCUR0NDrpe AIx/K2XWCARkq1Hw2eglsMMfUkaMFDf8zO640SDgbihwrNUxiSiOmzI0c+dYCGifNjE9AXvf Zd0ILc0dGcGdgTZ90NpfA3Nf0mjOtOLxxVEFDpot6UR8DGu2JWbl8/LCvkvU+v7dNO3+kz/o lLaU8gk8yhGsEEOjlSdwREz+zsFNBFm5X1cBEAC3xwrk6uPFe1ZbCLQFzTSLUGBA+fDByx4w T4rTpXc5Zl7jv2n8nwM60M9m36L14jxma0q/b+DXk1hlP0U90qroygamhxqvriQXWnkHn5yj 1D0a7BdkUaiHWCUh/VWzB5G/wHUy7302SmbywzZIjf33MRaD7zc0k6gvoMqyCSZOZdeTKkco dY+LN3UzoAEAl/zj+x9jbmaEdx13wSACyLTBRvqNBmQD45wsYJ3L+5K0ZSBE3LV9I+BHDaKa MqcSahGvshW2h35Nh8vemUBm3U1Yg6cV2rX2qlncJGfZIXr4PB21On2XquRHjaanAqjQbC6u bJSz3+6hjBMp9ucTo8btJQDfQSdAkahZlj8xgdc8Jlv/ctp0SR2/REteZQuNtj0xuKDaE5Iv b8SqBk46zkN6N/xjfrsur7HsX/lCLazKcyp7o7YTJas+ZLv2OA+SkH6HyvNi8wah77bFgAIz LYaD/Wo0QslK3iHWE8DixDy9L0Fr6Lu3sAkF3/WToAtg5f2HdPKu4GsBh5aswSdOiw8ibIpy bGzrve5AkkM9h2sR5i+ikDlS8NWmuNlAdYNQ/4sfELnVprUjVNjIemLrKSY/HdOLYKH59apO 196RcNWrK6wDiPNngYCkq01MFfD7yylhnMVxHXHtDxmL+C7Og8j3Xd5SjRt2pMscwpqFOaVY iQARAQABwsFlBBgBCgAPBQJZuV9XAhsMBQkDwmcAAAoJEJiqtuMaAfobIIQQAIoqqX6kcF7u rEJFJleqFKYMYgn/n5dQwK+6BSCs6KTzZacvVDRiXWQw3xv6rt2kabfvpjyt2IT0xABrnMc8 Azxxp7d8kSxqMcD9v69vP9pNNtMREl0+BJKLyO3d3mstAaV4+NfYNJ+Yq+ShFm1qjiGU8LX9 qa45xTsFLUm9Jb8iR3wLbistvG+qlRpN1B6zt3BLygfbyibP/UK7AWvD+eQ6tOqdW9K8xN4c ubkQTDCDuMzHuuCA63b4zPa5l9AKoVqc7H3k1dcyGj3VON3caTTruC7N9DT+h7HQlQMOLZvy uyquix5aGsZLdkQhdBD7JdG8rdGQmiEQCgdF/ujeBE80EpYPsPU71Y0DoArvSKygz8X66YHb nIFvEGKw+ZQkmv62t3RdtndIZIbwx7GNFeB07UnJG7edkm2JX9nYMx/Ueduj3ILAhRej0M1w owP7yQOCZtPUCyKe49wKRzZKibtLi8lIly/C4Rnzpd7nItNX4fXkpD9J8rGJ6RQD7JJo3xb7 3I90m93H1hOALTWMj/7neeAxQVyfMQDWGUBl/p/lMsQENfq5/DG1F1jFv8vi13q3BuqkJC1V HteRX+uj0VAqZnV1NIscb2EipqCe6gt73YQyZZR/MBktquPoZ73kOrKhHUzSeCdPUuGHpbTU vzqMMJ3s+pfUcbogdcbss8Z5
  • Delivered-to: tycho-user@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/private/tycho-user>
  • List-help: <mailto:tycho-user-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/tycho-user>, <mailto:tycho-user-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/options/tycho-user>, <mailto:tycho-user-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Openpgp: preference=signencrypt
  • Organization: Codetrails GmbH
  • User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:52.0) Gecko/20100101 Thunderbird/52.8.0
Hi,

I wonder whether the following is possible with Tycho: For historical
reasons, we have two bundles A and B which need to be installed at
exactly the same version, including the qualifier (in a sense, these
bundles are not versioned, let alone semantically :-( ).

But how can I express this?

In A's MANIFEST.MF

  Require-Bundle: B;bundle-version="[1.2.3,1.2.3]",

doesn't work if B is at 1.2.3-SNAPSHOT, as that version is larger than
1.2.3 without qualifier.

But writing

  Require-Bundle: B;bundle-version="[1.2.3.qualifier,1.2.3.qualifier]",

instead makes A compile with Tycho, but ultimately, the update site
fails to build:

> [ERROR] Cannot resolve project dependencies:
> [ERROR]   Software being installed: update-site raw:1.2.3.'SNAPSHOT'/format(n[.n=0;[.n=0;[-S]]]):1.2.3-SNAPSHOT
> [ERROR]   Missing requirement: A 1.2.3.201807091513 requires 'osgi.bundle; B [1.2.3.qualifier,1.2.3.qualifier]' but it could not be found
> [ERROR]   Cannot satisfy dependency: A.feature.group 1.2.3.201807091513 depends on: org.eclipse.equinox.p2.iu; A [1.2.3.201807091513,1.2.3.201807091513]
> [ERROR]   Cannot satisfy dependency: update-site raw:1.2.3.'SNAPSHOT'/format(n[.n=0;[.n=0;[-S]]]):1.2.3-SNAPSHOT depends on: org.eclipse.equinox.p2.iu; A.feature.group 0.0.0

Apparently, the string "qualifier" isn't replaced during the build in
this position but instead taken literally, where of course it doesn't
equal the real timestamp-based qualifier: 201807091513.

So, I wonder whether this is possible at all? If it is, I'd really
appreciate some pointers.

Best wishes,

Andreas

-- 
Codetrails GmbH
The best code possible

Robert-Bosch-Str. 7, 64293 Darmstadt
Mobile: +49-170-811-3791
http://www.codetrails.com/

Managing Director: Dr. Marcel Bruch
Handelsregister: Darmstadt HRB 91940

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature

Back to the top