Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [tycho-dev] conversion from normal jar to bundle - private packages
  • From: gm <guenther.mahr@xxxxxxx>
  • Date: Sun, 13 Apr 2025 10:36:24 +0200
  • Delivered-to: tycho-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/tycho-dev/>
  • List-help: <mailto:tycho-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/tycho-dev>, <mailto:tycho-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/tycho-dev>, <mailto:tycho-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:rIpVUd99R3U=;Rmgdihq583mB9T7vRf9iV9WgVaK GYmAm9bIvpcJRhMKyl/jBoY2aeJCifNvm+nta+qhEDcKUBaxEDqw5wHCkFnEjJFAKQRUa7Z9G k+nOmwDclOYQbuH4Ju3M8RPk9GLkyf8QHAowlrZx2MAJV/wqVq26WR3Hc7aLW3M7UUEyIQyRk UJFkXuK3MZbj/WjVYR/nsn6IiwO8ySRGjksP4JMeaszWpthsX4U01h0nI2Tla+SED95dvNkQ1 nEsFfV2vZl1ETrgB3d8XCPgjGE/nRbw9zHI8beQ9E/Ue2dxo3IxcLPigy2YHG7u/moiCr93Jh 18ksNGDzkmTi4GDf7mypfs8VMdgYmT+E37kciP7/ERFjwfo6Wg3uCRrlk6Bg64o7SvoT71Hz5 gXHElWsej6jCPnOTues6/bWxscl0GXjiGwlbIZmoaFZalt80YS10UZxTpSjiR6ZCXY2MqQnAM ORRB7iFnqzTMtfVK4oF/kg/yc1LCZGd67Lna4t6a7oHyUFpoWua4jdk0ScadN0pgSSPGM5U2x H0ZOFSQCK+jaXLslCC+bf0Pp0bI/TSmy7YcDGS0nVZHi1kPUlsxb3h4R/4Io8OdIrvQ2B4YUq eEQVgh19FlAWsZvBIDBWQPsm0uqoGWblOeu5PEnWjOFkOGsnxOKrdJeg2JGJqEhw/AUmiMpqM PXdOsNabifubO4RyXgNQi322EFx8n+BX35Ju2tAwsvDvfWMdnW0tNoOpmhXIglWXoAWWEsJtj kDXlxDAfNxP9/HiM+L+5uVPNaluj/KpspYCHMEn/rKEELbm7wNmOvF70kkKOKukVK9ELZqbHn M/Ck7YGCPdsoRjtS38uKteFH0Lb9U8K6kP+/diP9suj8n3uYbTXYPlsOiLrTHEjEbZv5L1HfL yfHjiVnTOQOdXhqhhKVgwzmZkYODJfGeZLHPVIWXIHRFiPBvvJY5Oyd22eqgSyeJPCifja7B2 u8lHcFpAg9POYx4YeyYt6hQT+g8KLvAGXC9SJeAuhN2rYwgeqHpesEjgC5fn4+hELr4uHmsia pEGnZqQaaL/zYz0a1o6Y+eXgJJQw7sC4GKy0insUg+vSR8hZEiJWHL4UZDb66f2I1U/Mswpiy ukVNzO7WAJPNxf9cceZUXdd5frlSDMXkYXouJ7qtbXJq5UqhVAl9IyvQMhbbJS2hGsoAAbmZL su/krdGbAG5IK45tIj83FvOhO+VCvDw/NVIFFq2hgyTmrvudo9UybruwXGhXt75W8ihmn1EEP k6krszNoQQBQGEj5dIYDOO1JmBZr396erUvBQUhaOUvcmeVVq1RvTXWQZ0c8tWCXRygLzYjuU cIGHXtaS2p/icQJblg9+erwJYPveFDgn739QnGYG+YgYWGPkddbzfUWbznin/Uf7eSds970BX ceecTE6CqS4INO7pf08D0l+DNrJkkqPGTk+BxHylmIatJ5lPsCRYwBEiKDNnPwnL/Qy/yaI8V wV+W1E9eWB5573Hz8WpKtodJJoztwQYT9sD+2IvPzz5PrizvE

Thank you Ed, 

for your quick answer. I didn’t see the mortbay version, I only found

org.apache.tomcat : tomcat-el-api : 9.073. 

Still, the question why private packages are created interests me and I will put it, as you proposed, to the discussion site. 

Kind regards, 
Günther Mahr



Am 12.04.2025 um 17:49 schrieb Ed Merks via tycho-dev <tycho-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx>:

I think it's better to ask on the discussions

https://github.com/eclipse-tycho/tycho/discussions

I don't know the answer to the question (and you didn't share the exact coordinates of what you used), but those packages are provided by the following bundles in Orbit

<w9FZLR4DxNIldzyS.png>

https://download.eclipse.org/tools/orbit/simrel/orbit-aggregation/table.html

And the former is also in the update site of the Platform and SimRel.


On 12.04.2025 17:07, gm via tycho-dev wrote:
Hi, 

when setting up the latest Eclipse target platform 2025-03 for a project, I ran into the requirement for the package „org.apache.el.util". I finally found out that this package can be found in "tomcat-jasper-el.jar" which I then tried to add to my target platform as a Maven dependancy. But when looking at the created bundle, I saw that 2 of the packages had been converted as „private packages“ meaning they are not exported. One of them was „org.apache.el.util". So now I wonder why that is - why are some packages marked as private at the conversion - in the original jar I found no hint why that could be. 

The upshot was that I could not use "tomcat-jasper-el.jar“ and had to find a way around by not using the feature org.eclipse.platform.

Thanks for your help, 
Günther Mahr



_______________________________________________
tycho-dev mailing list
tycho-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/tycho-dev
_______________________________________________
tycho-dev mailing list
tycho-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/tycho-dev


Back to the top