Hi Technology-PMC,
the
 Code Recommenders projects want to do a 1.0 release with Juno. We 
already spoke about graduating Code Recommenders a while ago [1] and I'd
 like to follow up the discussion here on the list.
The project 
started in January 2011 and has since then quickly made progress. For 
Juno we have the opportunity to join the Java, RCP, and Scout package to
 present Code Recommenders to a broader audience - which would in my 
opinion be a big thing to get the idea or Recommenders in Software 
Development out to Eclipse users and developers.
The project 
as such is still rather small. We have 5 active committers, 3 employed 
by Darmstadt University of Technology, one from Queens University, and 
one independent. In the past year we had roughly a dozen contributions 
of varying sizes (one-line fixes up to complete features such as local 
code search engines, code snippet completion, or code summarization 
features) - of which seven have been applied so far. 
The project
 also has a good recognition in the Eclipse user community as the 
Eclipse Community Awards have shown. 
The project also has some 
effect in research circles. Other universities consider joining Code 
Recommenders (as Queens), actively start reusing components for their 
own research work (Bejing), or consider doing joint research on areas 
related to code recommenders (McGill).
The code base is 
getting stable and the CI build is doing its work - although the latest 
integration into the Juno package popped up a few issues that have to be
 addressed.
Features such as Subwords or Chain completion 
have improved significantly in the past months and their concepts are 
now evaluated by JDT and may find their way into many more areas than 
just code completion, see for example [2].
In terms of 
documentation and recommendation model coverage there is still some work
 to do. However, we are confident that we'll improve on this until Juno.
PMC,
 whats your opinion on this? Is there anything you'd like to see 
addressed before graduation can happen?
Thanks,
Marcel
[1]
 
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=365594#c4[2]
 
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=378699_______________________________________________
technology-pmc
 mailing list
technology-pmc@xxxxxxxxxxxhttps://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/technology-pmc