[stp-dev] SC subproject issues

[Daniel Berg <danberg@xxxxxxxxxx>]

I have several issues with this subproject
first of which is the need for the subproject.  It is not very clear
at all and has a great deal of overlap with what is already defined in
the core subproject.

However my biggest problem is with the
exemplar contribution.  Why in the world would we choose to use Celtix
as the exemplar implementation?  First of all Celtix is a specific
runtime technology and is not a simple implementation type.  Second
we should be using standards for our exemplar.  In the core subproject
we are planning to contribute the Java implementation as the exemplar.
 That seems much more reasonable than Celtix.  If you want a
more complex implementation type we could look at Java EE 5.  I think
having Celtix integrated in this framework is fine but not as the exemplar.

Anyone else have an opinion?

Regards,
Dan