| Re: [open-measured-data-wg] [open-mtechnology for future ODS Version |
|
Thank you Dietmar for this aspect! When we can take the ODS 6 Version from ASAM for us now, then we develope directly open MDM 6 without Version 5. The Corba problem can then get away. How is the status of ODS 6 exactly? Can we use it now. Mit freundlichen Grüßen Gerwin Mathwig Daimler AG 019/D658 RD/FNW 70546 Stuttgart Stuttgart, Mercedesstr. 122 Leiter NVH-Signalanalyse IT-K-C für NVH, Aerodynamik und Energiemanagement Speaker of the open MDM IWG Tel. +49 711 17 34312 Handy +49 1 608 607 608 Geb. Ut 122, T23, Zi. 2.A068 Mailto:gerwin.mathwig@xxxxxxxxxxx From: open-measured-data-wg-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx on behalf of Dietmar Rapf Sent: Friday, October 16, 2015 12:23:21 PM To: The open MDM Working group mailing list. Subject: [open-measured-data-wg] technology for future ODS Version Dear openMDM working group,
as we are discussing technology topics in the WG and the architecture committee right now, I would like to point to an evaluation of the technology for future ODS versions (6.x) that was ordered by the ASAM office and carried out in the first and allready finalised step by Fraunhofer IAIS and will be continued in the second, still ongoing step by s+c (performance tests).
It is the “Evaluation for the applicability of Apache Thrift and Protocol Buffers for ASAM ODS 6.0” where the two technologies are evaluated for serialization and RPC capabilities. In the first step the evaluation was on a more formal level adressing activity of the projects, documentation, language support, encoding support (types of variables), API / RPC features, security features, … but also basic performance tests. The second part focusses on performance with the typical bandwith of ODS data.
As a result it became clear, that the two technologies are very similar in many aspects. Apache Thrift is recommended in the report mainly because of better support for the realisation of web services. ASAM members can download the report and a presentation here: http://www.asam.net/home/trainings-events/proceedings/ods-technology-update-sept-2015.html
Best Dietmar
-- |