Update: I now have the watchdog working
        as before. Don't know what went wrong with the broker
        authentication but I suspect the update threw a wobbly. The one
        change I did make was to alter the dependency of my daemon that
        replies to the watchdog message in its systemd .service file
        from syslog to rsyslog. But I really don't think that is
        relevant to the broker problem. Reinstalled mosquitto, rebooted
        and the watchdog now works fine. So the old cycling of the O-N,
        O-F-F strategy worked :-)
      
    That said, I still cannot see the
        /var/run/mosquitto.pid file. This is a minor problem for me
        since my technique of running a round trip of MQTT messages is a
        far stronger test of whether the broker has broken(!) than
        merely checking if the pid file has been removed in an orderly
        termination by the OS. 
      
    I note Greg's comment below, but he is on
        BSD whereas I am on Linux Mint 19.2. Is anybody on the list
        running Mint 19.2 (Tina) or Ubuntu 18.04 (Bionic) and can see
        the /var/run/mosquiito.pid file with version 1.6.7? 
      
    My only wild speculation is that when the
        broker tries to open /var/run/mosquiito.pid it hits an 'access
          denied' error (why? no idea as surely the process should be
          running as system at that point?) and fails silently. But
          before I dive into the source code, it would be helpful if
          somebody could confirm that they see can this pid file on the
          same Linux distro.
        
    Peter
    
    
    On 16/10/2019 13:52, Greg Troxel wrote:
    
    
      For what it's worth I have been udpating to minor versions for a while
now.  I am now running 1.6.7, and my pidfile is present and working.
I have experienced zero issues with each of the 1.6.x upgrades.
This is on netbsd-8/amd64 with mosquitto from pkgsrc.
Given that you updated mosquitto, it's also possible you updated other
things, and TLS is often tricky and has certs expire.  Good luck
investingating.