Skip to main content
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [jakarta.ee-spec] [BALLOT] Creation+Plan Review for Jakarta CRaC
  • From: Werner Keil <werner.keil@xxxxxxx>
  • Date: Tue, 13 Oct 2026 15:32:28 +0000
  • Delivered-to: jakarta.ee-spec@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/jakarta.ee-spec/>
  • List-help: <mailto:jakarta.ee-spec-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/jakarta.ee-spec>, <mailto:jakarta.ee-spec-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/jakarta.ee-spec>, <mailto:jakarta.ee-spec-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:JInPAGhVj30=;aMJrI03OlHpFgvexiPkbibrpL6S OuqoOKSOWbA3SKmRbIy+GUOnf2n3w8Cy9/JzoVNZqvbNVDNnZ0JR7m5/LS/LiJdkXIaE4/6wo MFt7RtjIXJorbNWHrnciln/YnQRudgYAOJOup+JOp33Q0Uc8OEORA4OKOpYtt2Cwz+Jbb2GC8 xjr5mcomnA/J6toNwErrh1mPkG3JG6/rAe11fTLXNK0VAwrNYHEOqt8Kp36viSxC7BgMVaLcz agJKzuyodn+vM/M9heSASTtUCp+15ZU2wVTMQjfMGzsF441PJVKZPqAvugaHiT47Zf3GRV6Lg hWljdsl46uPePMij0uBoeH1tmOnxS8PBPbjFlTQ1t4rwdX578URDApRAov3WyXqmSOlMvKTGa pg1qo8EiSQ9czGIiD0bnDOgSTvUrJjD8+sqduXwNUceXes0oJYJN6f7Y4ivJW+Zfk8N/66tpe ldD5TFNxjQRWtB1w3fTGpTsgYgAvTNiROHDEUieFxvg1lopisGnbNB5+/ySVllXlzohwCkyry xqm6xaO9yvnrJkTrReIpbcnQYCBpj/xSbu8yRHbWnZZu/JSoxt+dJ2dZOwAeqfM8l/wt4QBqF 5ADNGqgYohLRpRChyA7Qz2Y9tWHIDcJO0U5flUiVlPSadLa2jj95+f+mE7wJLtcNAm+jiCcNn Zy/i/wHl293M3KlxKBW040493q01lmyZbtPHdwuhYC5ZuBavIcC1hDVyNHDKzibVZRTNXUtPw sWHLHL6qnM75u4ry/Ao30izrYmBPHCPRDrxo7Bi0YQ57hO8Ycm4spMD61kH9qkWAGHUCODFbo 5cF/zplG7wrxc0iebVWFGk6uk8diXdtev/hjOqxmWBIwpC+tunHGWH/xKjcqsU9J+eYibRW7/ e7G+Zs+WuEBuoEUwLBCO/VVY+k+oIXJmRK1IlANBM/MnfuuKqCCQ3FG38LTh8BtgbJ0ppK2IO 3uoHG+GuSgqzcYWfRe+9SeI04+IzUxpuz6oqdyBs58DV/eWhWvRxCVKDco7NYGobJm/1YFGb8 jznvLuirEjzbEQw3/pvOyLMtb1PLeQuHuBwXVhf6GyrUoexKX7XidRYnnRA39ZtGnQmnlx3V7 0mcxk9FGxR61g4Sw+wD4hlnkJ1qVu3JA5UJg400E+E/N9N5KF60+STZ58skTGnGibC80jywj3 ttivzQOxaDnV1XXCOoW894hRvwr24PLDs+UYyIKdozJ2gNZhb54huW9jg6K1QCPD4Kq04m1pA zXxCJU5h2Sxz6RdIHm2XfevZsHom1ey/xBGW6qIQwWvNLsv9p30hDKx+KFECOzUrJD+DZESpQ YQXO6On3DwglBo6qMJR6zrtAx+1VFZXQOoIL2UwL8DpgvS2p/DiLyaTPp4CiU3Ib7n82JB/KF vSe/urp9qRHnHlkSC1B+pYiQyUjn4/qgfhyVF7Qscrk/4/CsCyruiFpwuliLH7Yra3By0TDhy 01BOBt/6+cUPtxrpV4BrwRpOlqCx0qIHCRxUVbwM389GQS8N8mJj62gtQQYeOaSsltl/02AnI 26lpVJOvY6hHFRTDyLFOo/FWot+GROsho9bnYK6JE6GcCQwz5iSoMJK+2lt4UY7YF/5q63Rnh XKPb7LsZ+oNt1wx8nQEKHVU+Fnz37r9MV8th628Duynpm/65+i0EE1gRKLxL0kgA8Mk81JFvn XiOYkLr7wc9mycgB1Mv4Lyz1jAOdNzrJmv1bn1H3zJFqSVEVCxD8iL4/hKbDpYTbEEDDnMXl8 pQBVKRcXy2vJXm9nhv9H70ddWqvVpwZJ8adwA249GcBfztA75ZIRElDnUyLNxWRdHL9QjdHw4 QdlzFnc1JaNwTzUzjbi/rh81V8Y52pgiSufMoa7Iwq+EHJz4me1rfK7x140v/9pCjAKuSXzD3 16i+86XhBQNK2mP/+wXGkiqobsXlV/w1T0ov7y0wX/7GnUIb6mo77iXcKvOH0TXpqpqSsqD3v gwJdUZXw54oisfzXJ5Gz1hjFTJKVhj/co2ammUrbtLp5URz4eJcqNIUSdkcjfnFLPFzNsRrSb oL5HEfvDmzGD6zOFm75dHcrQ/VgFdtL4uaCipwwiCpmV+ScVdG/Sn0OTxP9eackJD0Cq9x0Va 2R4BX4tirexcp0s+RueZyBUP6DSY9XP1rt3tXgjs5Min9+wKetkxP3tsL/EHT2cIEqP2FpA4+ riYkuxOj48XYjv8PY+15sYq7lftgfqLKrRv9KHeDGdyF6qPTV4Y1o2fqpZa/6gBjlDdkH7wbT Ex6nbqjvk3kKeJLRxGNzhTyv8Yq1gGZU/DO05+nGm7eC5imn4U6LisRpczQyI6Hf5TOP9rLsU xpd+CSADTg2BvMpP/tpw+qMbvvk/w3Cd2cDw/Zid4a126xprqlPJpapAqCuQcwYl3KqzMuyaU iVGG0iTBR1iu6v2+qO1HpH3wH0mEOq7Qf8Vism7hMYg/gDoJZgEWR32BK1qQd0tXdNEwXe4g+ 6eLgOiL6DAWNQCEJRqeGiCEilUKnkrVWWPCl/yqsNl3TFAFs2UQzYdZd92obPvXrhTKsVLop0 E/LsC4iWmUKkkwQTp94cbRrTEIJmIcBjdvmaMMFdf1I/Gemo6qewtgexywWaQosm4p9m6mu7U IuQfJ0G8f3Ds9Ik3zhs1waDzW8/XCsp63+ii+qXCbcVQV9klYtf8QkQsbvZF61wpiNo4aEqMd zu5EGKIbZNGuBN9nwXbOpk81M1rDRjUKEZynqH1zpDlxmjBzuLebHJgVmkZqpRa7rnjynSzPK +IeQGOF7wW4XPZg8SMEPtl5yADc0pMNMuDLHAWbV0c6DIN8sQJ3hP+WaaQjZiiANPvPN8Uj3E nJHpiNN0+9DINIql2iMmD/gvJbXvr4s0cztFXZTdmKWZut/6aNENPIdyYveBncLTXk3naGInK mtHkSvdnFK4HIiRHuu9TVP10HUchPxoCSp/8mbwjEDnEv44kn6HUzcd8mJQw2sut3mHPPgN/Y rXw77gJ40+uK+wQFH9W7SOPnMtM1UV6VThz2lgbQqCqvqZXaT6fMhmo3XUxvijst9XLwQmgq/ 8zgdmJ4nonBD1d68Izv/avG6EBRXzEyRvdz2mGW4qmLHJ6O9DSlezFkIsRD3OY18B7v7pgCBv 94SncWI/oq/Wahg5YeVhIuZr/qJSgDXi6LRmX1mteAh1sU33dxOUImDapEb2kzr79iSH/k8qo 9YMnUa2xF7UMXAXXJGmmvdqeEYDEmLpIVbjxP6z4ht8RM6VJMCgJTkh6YDFBKMZ9tEvZX9EC+ 9I1hW707f8P641vfv0/LkuvqBzmc44Sh9HZi+a5B7N2sB5c6swHc47QPWcD6ss+CEBBGxN1uV 7NyAEEBDKTv9V8nyLVO1GG1OG7xFuplZXVWOQtzq66zFZt0pPPxB+OB8CVpJuhmoZ41t/XOHj 89AVwXd79wer71oBbXNPubMpnh8r6bqe5RvaP4ty63UKbq5EFYwrye97PqbRYtZHd8rlh6HQH QTW36XBJu4uBQbnhKD7HTODXbiagW/UZA36mej070qR/LSpJZM/nR+hjfpxA95aEyOQKUnKLN vMoGbDe0eWJYzOTa2UU6U70N2TyCqSwLLbXPIUCTo0fSywdcyX7WasplMwPss/BSm1mn8jJmX TdarWZNRtOJywEEbVUrcljwoV9uVA9hMgOMNreL0CK8+aIdA9eKVy1o0+PYI6h3HEaNtEepxz HomOzVIHR9b0qCT6XNBdBTuXn4Fyvou50JdefQaD7Lwdf0Q+hFV2bYJm6vMU511zV6czdA+nP 8ZFmkhvEfrHs0XjN3MaJT7nug/7gmbaG4Qj1VZDe4rfd6Hf4baT1gKjpNNtfKHn9Fd4MHlVmE XfVpu5og0JO8xaA+ESqi1OtKgMX/+RWiWwLelZ0eWaLC5LmYGFIO3r/lqFmJDxytGdmJuzzsV IfEPNeB5d6D4QM9gPhu1Lciwxdq4ZV0YeZzPj0HW3k8DMKRnNgZqcf9EvF2+eb6Wq6yI6Pccd ktU3szPtXuzcec8pDVIIZm1CE087FKwxHgfvzrsru8NCFm1oyyXPnyzWoYHYDwu+5x+8yBEma 7TX/HLMasrKd9jXcDHlLUt3FX06Fqzx9N+JldFzJfcF1t0Jo0Ot8gVzWQ7cPw6ECK9TplgMqg /S8e5/oEI5HAJ51pYJ15ma0w3P5ojTygtkBYec4pYLGPTfo59QPuSxPwVbvTetuPu3M87cUz2 zAomvgpRrcdAPig4B/G16E5+1udqjUQOenRdclDV4VygYzopuhHHncE2PImLVeeCwlPLk/ZTk wMQ4Je/viutpqVsiVFkbrfbqQfQIMSb+7IVWVtHQNyo3gtaX48bnxAO3nUU9ZNfVLMUY6LyOk Z0UcBXTsvz5HqiOXWVa3FFqCcw8nb3FfbnERZo1ot205ECWjSMpV+BFkGPaNLybwr7x88JzaH ZHSEVmwI2rdnPolBP7IOpjMNM16HHq6+133zCPlhfaXIsuhaV5FRhTsD2ewivEQc6qRyudAuO frRf/Pn7ysEC+1XqYq6wYA6EKbhNH2X3QnPq0b1NEwCy9xlw73qgWdB26eu0Au+GC6wXkWL2/ O+A8G0Hzh5DUc6VpM7Nu2JC5wq0gktUCBQc1EZrZobbxqcqldlPNwzz/ZYK/HxC3ch1MPiycp lSN3sJIsbvbQlJU1G2dMk0Y9Bia2VH/RbAvjbgzhi2YhghHRH4ff2PO4WqaLe4JmmDn9c9jsi qC8FIivKkW9kIb2HT2wxqb5OxJySiKqEXzpM2oESPOo9ql1jaBKb5GTHkeKltSaMH/kG667Qi k7E4J+JRIE2RSApN8ZqJh1629p1M82xJogkzQGh/ie+pIA7g9LXJ9jjJwkufOHRLn1WAbRJFW ruTeTtuBmoTJjwrCew8MogNxR/YOEW4SZvn8DIKpYXx+OyAVcT7NCFdq98P9j+Zqxc1ieLFJK /LCAu0KSX1z2bAKBOuXFTzA0UkfLAZbjZtTQeqcjxil4uOOa2vHQlzlKCfrcoXvIUxfenT+z3 L5lGMXBSdGK2zD/1Av3e3j3y9guwznsCYJi8OWv4SKEAH9KrSN+u5Wr/uYeQQjbBjY5kM41vF nOtl6v9tPYRKwm1PCPvvt5aJj3QAKW4QehwBU2e/ecbdYpJd5c20X4+qh2mHmHlmllOJt7tQ3 lOz+83M8/CbrLuOmOsYu7w9+HZSbrq19d9rs/5SGl37yE9qFiN7xZ/MDuteoAZasw6OxrwaQ8 8FxRv4k9+PSOb7Um+VdFrzuzimnRpEfBu+r1i3R1tH7UJnyLgWTuj+437GsMXq0hdHIgY+DHm 5dscM5O7hqfKRM9hA1G+zGoLISJsx9JFMMyfJpNmMJYA3dVOHEm0J7VKT+XlvBhynu/fBI6GJ PGTvM4xj5Jh/HN1pW1wcScGjld4XwyLTe44SYaekrWJmjFN3QpieLUtc4eoe7+tLUlnWsZOdG mkVTid4ghQm97YAIC48IBQWpcgJ5sbZPSWCna4JiUZQE/giW2H2QWatycbapPoQVl+aT7zDXH UG1HDdMCVBLglpMbgDGjtMm5I1kU4WE9achuzV1QvJgDFB1fGa/FoCHfc5Gekoepo8ulZR64G wdJLaO3p5ey3XtAvxHifi2n/XVM7k6glcokG0xgfBpyNQbxCkfHh0HMOwFsKD7MtXIIgrPP2V iKtf8PXD9wWBaoYvQYtb2udo5s5oFVfQ9bpqy3PZvi6GxobAEzLNRqXs9rmjtIr1o75Fkvd+A OubKHyr5bRsV3t/psFfhemgOAMoZj72WL0hjP9FMOf0C+v0W7c3NqPsqPvf1cY2vhjPm6cctB fr4lWTBeoXUD4ioB3kBiIGMiLFGeLMuqXjk/mTSLqVsddRCR7ltYSSGNlPJ+6MqD+qNR10YB0 kxpDCfttLFee5YDkfWmxaAvbVYFdSw8XIPSZN7TfR2m0gUZaUPG/v9Hbv+TIYZ97Lun610ZAd EXP/Li4fqBJOJghwhTXpTnvjYdTQdfdBvSWcr9cETBe9jhQvrZMwYPCZK1iw6jTtJEJHj8zJD U0HuNshY5O55A+0g==
+1
 
I had some doubts during the discussion, but Azul's answer seemed satisfactory to me.
 
Werner
 
Gesendet: Dienstag, 13. Oktober 2026 um 16:07
Von: "Thomas Watson via jakarta.ee-spec" <jakarta.ee-spec@xxxxxxxxxxx>
An: "Jakarta specification discussions" <jakarta.ee-spec@xxxxxxxxxxx>
CC: "Thomas Watson" <tjwatson@xxxxxxxxxx>
Betreff: Re: [jakarta.ee-spec] [BALLOT] Creation+Plan Review for Jakarta CRaC
+1
 
IBM supports this effort but we have an overall concern about Jakarta depending on externally defined APIs given the history of Jakarta blocking similar efforts around MicroProfile:
 
https://www.eclipse.org/lists/jakarta.ee-spec/msg04295.html
 
 
Tom Watson
From: jakarta.ee-spec <jakarta.ee-spec-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx> on behalf of Ivar Grimstad via jakarta.ee-spec <jakarta.ee-spec@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Tuesday, October 6, 2026 6:52 AM
To: Jakarta specification disccusions <jakarta.ee-spec@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Cc: Ivar Grimstad <ivar.grimstad@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: [EXTERNAL] [jakarta.ee-spec] [BALLOT] Creation+Plan Review for Jakarta CRaC
 
Greetings Jakarta EE Specification Committee, I request your vote to approve and ratify the creation of the Jakarta CRaC Specification Project and the plan for Jakarta CRaC 1. 0. The JESP/EFSP requires a successful ballot of the Specification
 
Greetings Jakarta EE Specification Committee,

I request your vote to approve and ratify the creation of the Jakarta CRaC Specification Project and the plan for Jakarta CRaC 1.0.
 
The JESP/EFSP requires a successful ballot of the Specification Committee in order to ratify the creation of the specification project. 

The relevant materials are available here:
 
Per the process, this will be a seven-day ballot, ending on Tuesday, October 13, 2023, that requires a Super-majority positive vote of the Specification Committee members (note that there is no veto). Community input is welcome, but only votes cast by Specification Committee Representatives will be counted.

The Specification Committee is composed of representatives of the Jakarta EE Working Group Member Companies (Fujitsu, IBM, Oracle, Payara, Tomitribe, Primeton Information Technologies, and Shandong Cvicse Middleware Co.), along with individuals who represent the EE4J PMC, Participant Members, and Committer Members.
 
Specification Committee representatives, your vote is hereby requested. Please respond with +1 (positive), 0 (abstain), or -1 (reject). Any feedback that you can provide to support your vote will be appreciated.

Thanks,
Ivar
 
--

Ivar Grimstad

Jakarta EE Developer Advocate | Eclipse Foundation Eclipse Foundation - Community. Code. Collaboration. 

_______________________________________________ jakarta.ee-spec mailing list jakarta.ee-spec@xxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/jakarta.ee-spec

Back to the top