Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[jakarta.ee-spec.committee] Output format for TCKs

Recently there have been a couple of comments about the difficulty implementers are having when it comes to parsing and collecting up the output of TCKs for presenting as evidence that the product is compatible. I can attest to this challenge. This output has been left to the discretion of the TCK development teams and it varies from non-existent (the test returns status as a value) to nicely formatted HTML.

Do we think there is consensus around regularizing this output? Is this something the Specification Team should take up and try to develop a guide, or possibly a requirement about? It seems, organic development has led to differing reporting formats. As we continue to expand the list of completely refactored TCKs from the Platform TCK project, I would hate to see this problem get even more acute.

Perhaps some kind of recommendation ought to be generated -- followed by some outreach and possibly even supporting effort to try and bring this change about.

I can imagine lots of possible directions for this -- but first -- is this a Spec. committee related topic or should this happen somewhere else?

Thanks,

-- Ed




Back to the top