Skip to main content
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
[higgins-dev] FW: In preparation for documenting the I4 results...
Title: FW: In preparation for documenting the I4 results...
Folks,

I’m trying to figure out how our project should respond to the OSIS email (way below). I copied below the Higgins-related (B) and (C) status bullet items that we need to work on. The three headings below are I4 wiki terminology:

Identity Selectors
  • Higgins AIR Selector [(C) no testing] <-- Propose we delete this from the OSIS I4 wiki
  • Higgins RCP Selector (Higgins) [(B) Partially Tested] <-- Propose we complete the testing. Would IBM or ?? like to volunteer?

Browser Add-On
  • Higgins Browser Extension for Firefox {using Higgins Selector Selector} [(C) no testing] <-- Would someone like to volunteer to test this?
  • Higgins Browser Extension for IE using Higgins Selector Selector [(C) no testing] <-- Would someone like to volunteer?
  • Higgins Browser Extension for IE [(C) no testing] {This is the Browser Add-On used only to launch the RCP Selector} <--- Would IBM or ?? like to volunteer?

Information Card RP
  • Higgins RP [(B) Partially Tested] <-- Propose we compete the testing. Would IBM or ?? like to volunteer?

Please email the list if you’re willing to do some of this testing. It doesn’t take long. BTW, if we’re not willing to do the testing on a given solution, then the OSIS process is to drop the solution from the I4 official results.

-Paul

[PS: I will email Pam Dingle and ask her if she’d rename “Higgins Browser Extension for Firefox” to “Higgins Browser Extension for Firefox using Higgins Selector Selector” so that it is consistently named WRT to its IE equivalent.]

From the OSIS user-centric-identity email list...

Conversation: In preparation for documenting the I4 results...
Subject: In preparation for documenting the I4 results...

Solution providers,

As we’ve discussed on recent OSIS calls, we’d like to wrap up the I4 process. Before we do so, we’d like to remind you solution providers to complete your testing so that your solution can be included in the official results. I walked through the solutions here [1] and sorted what I saw into three sections:

(A) In Good Shape —Most or All Tests Tested
(B) Partially Tested – Room for improvement. We’d like to include these.
(C) No Testing (or almost none) Has Been Done – Candidates for removal these from the official I4 results

In a few cases it was a judgment call, and I probably made some clerical errors. But if you’re a “C” try to become a “B”. And if you’re a “B” try to become an “A”. And if you’re an A, you get a gold star. You’re a hero!

Cheers,
-Paul

[1] http://osis.idcommons.net/wiki/Category:I4_Solutions

(C) No Testing (or almost none) Has Been Done – Candidates for removal from the official I4 results

Identity Selectors
  • Higgins AIR Selector (Higgins)

Browser Add-On
  • Bandit Firefox Add-on (Novell)
  • Higgins AIR Selector (Higgins)
  • Higgins Browser Extension for Firefox (Higgins)
  • Higgins Browser Extension for IE (Higgins)
  • Higgins Browser Extension for IE using Higgins Selector Selector (Higgins)

Information Card RP
  • FederatedIdentity.net (Microsoft)
  • Franhofer-IC-Java, JInfoCard (Franhofer)
  • FriendsWithCards (Microsoft)
  • FugenRP (Fugen)
  • LeastPrivilege.IdentityModel RP
  • LinkSafe.name
  • LiveID Login (Microsoft)
  • MSAge RP (Microsoft)
  • MSAnyIssuer (Microsoft)
  • MS RP for MS IdP (Microsoft)
  • MS no-SSL RP (Microsoft)
  • ooTao Ruby RP
  • Ping Advanced RP
  • Ping Drupal IC-C
  • Ping Simple RP
  • Rob Richards PHP
  • Shibboleth RP
  • Signon.com
  • Sxip OpenIdCards
  • Verisign PIP
  • Zend IC-PHP

Information Card IdP
  • FederatedIdentity.net (Microsoft)
  • FugenIdP (Fugen)
  • Ping IdP
  • Rob Richards PHP
  • Shibboleth IdP
  • Sxip OpenIdCards
  • Sun OpenSSO
  • ThoughtWorks IC-Ruby
  • Verisign PIP
  • WebCard Loyalty (Fun Communications)
  • XMLDAP IdP

OpenID RP
  • Janrain PHP
  • Janrain Python
  • Janrain Ruby
  • Movable Type
  • Sxip Attribute Exchange Demo
  • Sxip PAPE Demo
  • Sxip OpenIdCards
  • WSO2 OpenID RP

OpenID IdP (OP)
  • AOL
  • Blogger (Google)
  • LinkSafe
  • MyLID.net
  • Orange OpenID Provider (Orange)
  • Sxip OpenIdCards
  • Sxipper
  • Trustbearer
  • TypePad
  • Verisign PIP
  • Vox (sixapart)
  • WP OpenID
  • Yahoo OpenID Provider


(B) Partially Tested – Room for improvement. We’d like to include these.

Identity Selectors
  • CardSpace (.NET framework 3.5) (Microsoft)
  • CardSpace (.NET framework 3.5 SP1) (Microsoft)
  • Azigo AIR (Parity)
  • Higgins RCP Selector (Higgins) - very little tested
  • Openinfocard Selector (openinfocard project)

Browser Add-On
  • Codeplex Firefox Add-On

Information Card RP
  • Bandit Cards (Novell)
  • Bandit Podcasts (Novell)
  • CA Siteminder (CA)
  • Oracle RP
  • PamelaWare for Joomla (Pamela Project)
  • PamelaWare for MediaWiki
  • PamelaWare for WordPress
  • Siemens DirX Access
  • Sun OpenSSO
  • WS02 Java RP
  • WSO2 mod_cspace RP

Information Card IdP
  • Bandit Cards (Novell) --need to test
  • Higgins RP (Higgins)

OpenID RP
  • Blogger (Google)
  • Plaxo Signin

OpenID IdP (OP)
  • MyVidoop.com
  • Signon.com


(A) In Good Shape –Most or All Tests Tested

Identity Selectors
  • DigitalMe for Linux (Bandit)
  • DigitalMe for OSX (Bandit)

Browser Add-On
  • Bandit Firefox Add-on (Bandit)
  • Codeplex Firefox Add-On
  • MS IE7 icardie.dll (Microsoft)

Information Card RP
  • Bandit Python RP
  • Bandit Trac (Novell)
  • FrancisShanahan RP-IdP
  • IBM RP (IBM)
  • XMLDAP RP

Information Card IdP
  • Bandit Wag (Novell)
  • FrancisShanahan RP-IdP
  • Higgins IdP
  • Siemens IdP
  • WSO2 IdP

OpenID RP
  • IBM IdP
  • DotNetOpenID Project
  • WS02 Attribute Exchange Demo
  • WSO2 OepndID SReg Demo
  • WSO2 PAPE Demo

OpenID IdP (OP)
  • DotNetOpenID Project
  • MyOpenID.com
  • WSO2 OpenID Provider

------ End of Forwarded Message

------ End of Forwarded Message

------ End of Forwarded Message

Back to the top