Hi Ed, 
 
I'm speaking about the *content* of the package and not what it
provides through the discovery mechanism, I might not have been clear
enough, sorry for that. All the provided content is already marked as
being in incubation or not in the discovery UI. 
 
Papyrus is not part of the *content* of the package, on the other hand 
EcoreTools and Mint are, leading to my question regarding their  Indigo
roadmap. 
 
And no, there is no such thing as a "not even incubating" status,
either Papyrus did  it's graduation review, and it's not an incubating
component, or it didn't and then it's an incubating component. 
 
Looking there :
http://www.eclipse.org/projects/previous-release-reviews.php
I can't even find a release review for papyrus..  which is strange as
the Papyrus website says the 0.7.0 has been released.  I'm adding the
papyrus mailling-list as there might be a problem here,  either you did
had a release review for 0.7 and then the web page need to be updated
in some way, or you don't and then the R201007251735 (2010/07/25) 
build needs to be removed from the downloads. 
 
 
Cédric 
 
Le 29/10/2010 11:07, Ed Willink a écrit :
Hi
Cedric
   
   
Amalgam currently publishes Papyrus, which is not even incubating.
   
   
Surely the 'incubating' applies to the Amalgam code, not to the content
to which it provides access, which can be clearly marked as regards its
status.
   
   
    Regards
   
   
        Ed Willink
   
   
On 29/10/2010 09:37, Cédric Brun wrote:
   
  Hi,
     
     
we had quite a lot of feedback about users complaining about the fact
     
that the package is marked as "incubating",  so far the components
     
leading to this status are :
     
- the Amalgam Project itself
     
- EcoreTools
     
- Mint
     
     
As the goal of the package is to provide a sound platform on can extend
     
and build upon, one of the Indigo's roadmap item is to graduate whole
     
the package.  Consequently the Amalgam project will have a graduation
     
review for Indigo, are EcoreTools and Mint willing to graduate for
Indigo ?
     
     
     
Cédric
     
_______________________________________________
     
emft-dev mailing list
     
emft-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
     
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/emft-dev
     
     
     
-----
     
No virus found in this message.
     
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
     
Version: 10.0.1153 / Virus Database: 424/3225 - Release Date: 10/28/10
     
     
     
     
   
_______________________________________________
   
emft-dev mailing list
   
emft-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
   
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/emft-dev
   
   
 
 
 |