|
Miles,
It looks like the existing BIRT feature project
"org.eclipse.birt.chart_3.7.0.*" includes all the BIRT chart plugins that you
listed.
And it does *not* have dependency on the
o.e.d.sqldevtools.sqlbuilder.feature, which brings in the org.apache.lucerne
dependency.
Linda
[cc'ing WTP and David in -- trying to avoid spamming cross-platform if
possible]
WTP, have you seen any issues with the dependency below?
It is indeed a mystery on what got
changed recently that would lead to the issue. The related
changes in DTP were done back in January.
So it seems
that the Buckminster build step does not allow building with different
versions of a bundle?
Yeah, I *think* it is something like that. Buckminster
grabs everything that it thinks it needs, and in fact it actually correctly
grabs both versions, but then it fails when it actually goes to build it. I'm
hoping that Thomas can shed some light on this and what might be done about it.
Which BIRT components do you need to pull
in? How about the other existing BIRT features, like
o.e.birt.chart.osgi.runtime or o.e.birt.chart
?
We
actually only use
<import plugin="org.eclipse.birt.chart.engine"/>
<import plugin="org.eclipse.birt.chart.device.extension"/>
<import plugin="org.eclipse.birt.chart.device.swt"/>
<import plugin="org.eclipse.birt.chart.engine.extension"/>
<import plugin="org.eclipse.birt.chart.ui"/>
<import plugin="org.eclipse.birt.chart.ui.extension"/>
Along with their dependencies, of course. What I think
I'm going to try next is to change my build time dependencies so that rather
than grab the entire birt feature I try to grab all of the plugin dependencies
individually, but I'm not sure that's the most robust way to go about
this.
Presuming I can get it to build, I'm trying to think of
whether that will create any provisioning time issues, but I guess that worst
case the aggregator build will let us know.
On Jun 6, 2011, at 7:57 PM, Linda Chan wrote:
Miles,
It is indeed a mystery on what got
changed recently that would lead to the issue. The related
changes in DTP were done back in January.
So it seems
that the Buckminster build step does not allow building with different
versions of a bundle?
does explicitly specify the 1.9.1.* version of
org.apache.lucerne.
The
o.e.datatools.sqldevtools.results.feature is required by
o.e.d.sqldevtools.sqlbuilder.feature,
which is in turn required by
the o.e.birt feature.
Which BIRT components do you need to pull
in? How about the other existing BIRT features, like
o.e.birt.chart.osgi.runtime or o.e.birt.chart ?
I'm
not sure about +n dependency
on BIRT in Indigo. BTW, WTP also has dependency on
DTP.
Linda
Hi Linda,
[Thomas, I'm cc'ing you in, hope you don't mind.]
Thanks for the link. And it makes more sense now since these changes are
recent but OTOH I don't know why they took a couple of months to show
up. It's a mystery is why this showed up now as opposed to earlier
in the RC cycle. This wasn't an issue until the build this week. The
issues I am having are with the Buckminster build step. It appears that the
initial resolution works properly but then it fails because the PDE resolver
is unable to locate the bundle. Therefore we end up with this error:
Please see this thread for more details on the specific issue:
This is a dilemma as obviously you have functionality dependent on this,
but I can't build my components without this dependency. Unless there was a
chart runtime or BIRT core feature somewhere. Again, I don't actually need any
of the datatools stuff but it all gets brought in as part of the BIRT
feature.
Are you aware of any other release train projects that have a +n
dependency on BIRT?
thanks for your quick response and cheers,
Miles
On Jun 6, 2011, at 6:34 PM, Linda Chan wrote:
Miles, The o.e.datatools.sqltools.results bundle intentionally
uses the 1.9.1 version of org.apache.lucene. That is why the 1.9.1
version is included in the DTP Indigo release distribution. See
comments in https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=333514#c14
and onwards. Is the 1.9.1 version of org.apache.lucene installed in
your test environment? What exactly is the issue that you
encountered? Linda -----Original Message----- From: birt-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx
[mailto:birt-dev-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Miles Parker Sent:
Monday, June 06, 2011 6:20 PM To: birt-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxSubject:
[birt-dev] datatools org.apache.lucene dependency Hi
folks, There has been a dependency issue with DTP but naturally it
only actually started failing today, two days before the release train. I'm
not sure if the failure is something introduced by a build change, but I
don't think it is. Here's the
problem: o.e.datatools.sqltools.results specifies org.apache.lucene
1.9.1, but every other eclipse project using it uses 2.9.1 Normally
that would be ok, but IIRC there *are* issues with whole number differences
even for non-singleton plugins. I'm wondering if you would be able to
take a look at sqltools and see if 1.9.1 really *is* necessary and if not do
a quick change, build and promote. In the meantime I'm trying to determine a
work around. (I don't actually need all of this, but it is the only way to
get it because IIRC there isn't a separate feature for the chart runtime.) I
haven't filed a bug yet because it seems more appropriate to work out these
dependency issues pair-wise and of course we're really under the gun
here. thanks, Miles _______________________________________________ birt-dev
mailing list birt-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxhttps://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/birt-dev_______________________________________________ birt-dev
mailing list birt-dev@xxxxxxxxxxxhttps://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/birt-dev _______________________________________________
dtp-dev
mailing list
dtp-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/dtp-dev
|
