Skip to main content

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index] [List Home]
Re: [agentic-ai-dev] Consensus on API
  • From: Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Fri, 27 Mar 2026 03:53:04 -0400
  • Delivered-to: agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
  • List-archive: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/private/agentic-ai-dev/>
  • List-help: <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=help>
  • List-subscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=subscribe>
  • List-unsubscribe: <https://www.eclipse.org/mailman/options/agentic-ai-dev>, <mailto:agentic-ai-dev-request@eclipse.org?subject=unsubscribe>
  • Ui-outboundreport: notjunk:1;M01:P0:17Rs/p3+zJI=;+IkWtvJ4i6Q3Q+LIP0tU81D8J8m m3zXFVfvJyIqAICIrMefr0TBZP+fX5hPhHUyYgQM6G1ZcmKcLYmC3ZcMavu179ITs0hKQf8wE blDHe+6LBKD1Zi3Uq02d7wCt17jq3oJnledarZhb0M70CXgEQPautcP2YgEc5mWVxEXF803vT xr6cm9ru1gYfkiz1g7v6TGfXsE7oVYpXvbiQq7VRahL1JpXV2uegCtTs6nWj6uXlaH7ozk5w6 Rrlj86AJ1t8Iw0fwSJSSziScSa2IKFysnb+AEALWaA5ga5M9yY/CPX8egjWtN4yvXom39l+iz Z6py8nfo5picc4t3J8YMJ6fL5/bslzLFtBXyFPNl03SNqpOuIck/of0sd1uUswFiXcGu+qdtH aGh4g2tUVgVjuWxaIlmrXdlU7OucWG8M+01wzCG9b9QoL9utQe0vFLyi38Y/rNK21XNlREDN+ QS9oTf0xb11J4UNi8BtTi9zJgcw2JEY4Pk9POiIXitn06tn0WoWON4HdWpTzeJW2jPZJe3MfK 9P+LSc6FUUAWkD4wLgx6V0mPLfDWh5i5CgjfWwNuAMnA7jfoQzkNGy67M4aNCLql+9tsONXub 6KHj6CpqlS6T9AyiFxy0H93VAJzrhdwIypuli7PkFrXVZawFyAbhYNcQFEaRn1YKQgoAPyz6f dF/B63JSB2C4OCQh6phbbj/9IWlC2z9qkFtw+lV1gEafLd9CzjfIIq9lYxdk3Ws073bdcIzPJ Xqy/PmVBON1eX5yI+lPrjJtZ6gaTaNImtsgcVBuSDoYSjKzM18aYKAAfDy/oNz1+QCKooUPlk YPoCaXntdYuEg+So0TenfENtYrVRYksJngbqCm7TQABaI5KSaJHVFY9N9I6AqP8uq92nRPaPi Cl4oGbJQfZ3Oa81p+PbR+UkU24og0BDg4prKDONnrAr8CVCLrDbo8e97UZf0cXgjJcdB1r7Cm b/YE135Qzn6P8fNzJqeq79ATTOFLjr5W0U/efbqeYteU5YMZKqhECutY9rCW5d32yBjN940Mg hQrpa5cZP5YHQ0IMFA+U2Waq78tjmy4roa8U1XcI9ORzWvPSRtHZOokuhYcNEt/9w3zYJvgNA M9isoyoL9EHPwtL3fw5tHdG//XxBwa+BcluK4xEWMQzK3deJYQOvEW+8WVpsdFOt2vrduYkyL SrwWhNV9H/GU1Lr6LZyz3V9W0s2wu2Ys74AA0o7cJxrpFKTQ9SVANq/asd6l45nBFYtVDtXo0 62deI0I1S/RCt0Qes1zLkbCPSuK/akVL5IDL5aokQkA70TFddnovPPQ3VFnQhTwXNtN/eDfAO 0vAV3onRHWDfk1UGs1saKEWzn1wZSNWpKh6ArP55Yr/GF6cgcPrEorCmrIzNq7BRTDPiDKdYa K0ZVJxyjT1yf+dC34xXTN/ENOmrPN1PvhDtKfgFDRs0qPQgLgAsDYi9omCWfhHfus3WRWwX8M F+LcUbHj4UxkvHPwgDuhetIi+5px0YOI531bQTo90zqVmUFnbHOEDJ2kcXPLNDnqvz084nYE3 fSpqySW2KQkMK2OJcFWATs9R+2PuyaWjyjiaUtvh20Tr/6ch0VSXD/fg6a3Fmyvxkn6MSmark nXWblds5rkH1Z9clFCiGmyECutKXyFaEAXKYR3rYAJjVIrNidx/vjnXcphhrWWU4FWvzIq7L4 P6V1FGV8RzDhh8CjW1l6aaBSCXykQ8oS/ZFOeNAmXNGwgwW/3lCV+LKTnNnKPYQ75Lqhj/r0q oIH/1IhTgSMaNzyOsCqpjckyVZWPS1CQ9Dh3aR+zAE9chZ89JAUFQE+OcGWxmfM627JZhfmHC /aBhILgkhbIAUubNe3T9MjCfU/i5G1LAf/3GQs5vZel7Tj3QFySBSACEQXIFIWISwitl53Vo/ 0Q+R+6gdmCkirCQdXL/OqobzCU0Y10+jbpjLA2g0DKP1J3Oc5gkajc0KiO/TirzvFyYNMelHz ZregiNJvMmYwlD0vMArba6hvgjKjdIUsxKXzTaibSUkkQhPoIYVLxxzdQZpp52j9pY5jO5UeC z5QiuAgfm6p3AswF6e410xXf7qenG+V+tZSLlxEee8gOsFVReTXhk+arv8C3lTl4F4iRlvL4Q wdCluO7KGGYA7iDZDqmNmAoRkog7kJYpnD4WJzy0E9ttCJfcZ5C6ir7ahe0BM/xO7fLA7T3ve Lq/c1EbySuEEI/jRoCsUDUNu8EgYLOL9ufUZFFXEgIwdVqk7wjyzpVwkgsrg0I49+8seowUJk 3m2vWjQedlaai0sxanyh4l0CWOjjBefkpwx6Q+GhxIMpcKDtVFcAfVTu2KRjWTeS7lHDDf5f/ hUCR4BD32ZbGyo+vXIzOqHaD3pueVik9aCIGexHb9xE8Uc7T9ei8IhYWfRWuTYRWcydZasimW x80PqKiVv4QpnrI1m00L+cehqCn/0v/qzNPPqbLHH92BELUAAb6BYvPhyo6M/2n7lfJs+3QIB Z7Blssg1MAjsS7DUSdNw6SHm8lwyCFnznU4eCTjPIhaDZUrljUZu55rlr0Gi2oiqGfUu4NQ28 OEk6Cz+47OP6BDN9O6Q3x1plwWYCPv448AtWOEa2hnN8UIYBvLXrRfcYlrV/N7X4EVkgU8K8t 0uWT157FhrwYL5gas8cQhNDiBl+yIOoOuaBxfiNUYqB4vs0Y6ZiiM0FqWPnQmpNKq/vpAt1+Z gkxSgJuzlpOVtxN5ckNkgDmxdEOw++Kit3V/kE3Utq18Mdlq+sITKWn6wyLf9gDDeJyM7evTW W/FU1m9bhN5ms+eifap6AIcri6AuXpfADukw9N9T8rn6zJkZZSdEtGbHEF69driBIJ/3RkP5o wvs1MTSVDKUySZzqhX2TypgeyWIjzkLDT59sdpuZp7xBN9ohBzQ37TLbKE7cIuH6js8Up2EhX a3YRald2PTEBJOY3ARLED0t7tAO2XO2qE9W/h+R1oXuUI/Wsa1njICXZIIaOGWHWGZwvXR38n AHMI0wqlhhijYjjZYg+tVJURJZcwQNuuF7gV3xw2cqDkfNipeQzaTowpMxWy4m8t74TI/KbOl sBnbifYNUbTQZHnd3oLWPuWcvfTsHloKFK66Kmzp/StQDomePfqYhMzUENiFZY5Rhpz9yKU4U xIbv7KyljiPTYktvThfm2Qgwt3/SZO6jm2yV4FeNTjBZSnqY1lwx+zEQpfHrQlN4BUX4wRPV7 8XN/Mok3TLkoJWMVM+SvAcz6+14dJgVx9o2iSOjZq7GkCo80Pm/oeBhRS9AC2gZuG4krE1qTM FKzDIe4b8new+qpMBk3PGK6E9uoCe5tBxaA3bla7hG6Pci7SdcTvxLhLwiBPvmR4TqEyDH3QN OIwQU1T4UFu/ELXm0E/nK8VY81YpQmYJag7jqbecMgtaA5pChQYBYyU0ww7LCXaSMl1YEaKwU m8q8U/0qRQpVxuluwIdyHK6VX/qjogCGoZtK7I8h1Yod7Gve9/L9axn9ckBt2XPSoglGdUFpz UDR0DwLbobjuoVvS2GWhYEL2wI7WiqsenVwuUrkE6qNzhCJqx/DZ1lrr5qJkXy0GoaoRd4dOw ML0K5oVBpYipAq2N5j5Fz6bSPf8JheiNBBCy5KV4/5TC6nvR3uh/txiQ+u7X7RmG6PUgCby59 rdvWCgKd3vFGlWsLTzR9a8iignuKhCoVNnBwj/g7sa4uJf+9RFzt6Bk1fAb+L2LYQW5VGgNnt wIr4NZMrzT+JsppcCLxTHPoYK3+DEayJLM6ioIpLB8qVIH9OVw8F26earzlQ7BnaUZY/JitkL dcG5E0iqLB3+lOTH5N8mFnmJVqk8yK9pIvmY09sfwVuTeWuolqi8cF6dMnRp1paWh53vAqCRk Pa9LEaJyfH56fQGR9asF05wiOaEv1qxTPxNvAMRGiJ8gSwr9s5ijS3Vy6usJQEI+QqE5gfnEk 9yLezJAaHvTUk/M6yLaF+MfvcJqqPvYy0ERGlNil3+08/95n9o3o9u34enCBZaDeXVskYPCMv TvhBnu5JKq3TEq34UDNnasOl4TE+ogtSbA+hUCtDj8Tx7x7QJ8oKdXpNDoTqVnMzR6HC/B+YS T4B/jZANRf50qrV11BWSyu0EvkS6ev2qBrYlpk418+eyXiqyhQ/7wNpzddwdh0dkcQqx+Nspm fHtNfoBXGqBMt6ZHIEMN9H/aD64M2KEARMVK5slj5FM2qoW5d3E6M9zHS8wToEeYw/rtEULfE 4SHqvKpEm6u5B8wgYutsjSSCSj9qMxd+6DRZ6br3TnHZxZhWIJzhsGdD1YQpLAavHl1hkNOjF AZCOlfEniFwzRSSpwWUg1FFDRvXWDLSCBMw9k+DfSzJmaAGcvG2o3b15dNgsACLk+C3SvSfMc aeWZOnApQIH3SaWQkX/E+pPv0YRsX7wL5463ZSv6WyukACCKXVfuHsYsPCLyY3Cf8cvD9y00t 9pb/6Vlvm9Dd/A/w2ta2fNRcE2JzoBCb1gSvefbxJ9Q9LiiIfJLujfNdpP20Qs6Iz6R/pJSGt 6nuwAYrySWMiBM7OBC0TxBcxfHWpgSpgYXxcV9TniTWPncyrytX/Hs4oxLDrDzU+NHIyYnAcE 7xW3UdJloDLyBe7gL6xwZTX1Q9B+bU/1Yi+Z/vDr8QJ+og/0Bz52hVbM91IwGyBeofCqf2OQy ACzea+6QHZsCmlmmQJcB+hkxQhIyTrjqJNv2VSz+svk+Y6sboqRbYCpzI3x/wy0lUvjPGOjPF PogztbUOWdrhNqBYk5WnmoFwcgAHnsMrmUGoAw0r3LbtDf5XNZGUwRfMYWwgsMfwyHQ22EPHA qi4+40iQAkm80uHmoXVzWXhSfJFCa2tZR4XnS1teY5SAAakhCqfAat4UzN8NNYdt86gyfZuGX juuJpDxfQNztUsmApCnde36DF0xkAaiZOGQgiy3HOn4oB2CzP4GQ3x6xBWrtuuAXMJKLdA6xn dX1hIEZQp9nYqWYy/JVLujMd8kWXFk+SUXCqd9PDejnRk4XaH91+S1jZiQ8xo+iYdciUmwNQu ygoj8lhtw7Wa6ZFp/FysuEEYVxxnrcuQ1QCVIz3F/K4woRje63PZkek1XQg+cJjO1LwYKczKv P3BCIsIXjsmg196lPWd40GH6ZtwPtscz1NmtwBUtc2EfP3OCf2Nnj8Zf5Y0p+FElTtIcU3ngz a9vzVjKw3hvSDUNAqpHw4NtYDrby1MmNYAk+GHfTrKQKQN92ObEiqQLrq0rnTPsMt1WIyMlxj 4I3qUajWULmRyvU/gr8hHqSgWlRVHoIf2vv8N49JWGauncV8ukTr/G1TdF4bMEAoZx5tIYO/3 QiTiOsHtEE0NbymXe0iw/Sp3OQ86c5N8ZLOykXMTdYnLgBXfrz3St4LhFSEOK/jIT3HA8HdUJ r/V3rXEBya/H6fl9340fBk3oWgWaLB4fBMnC/wcZxIUAHoxPj9C+CAF7I/50n902RY+KxPsqs QhWpb/JWE4pyjRoP5OF2QFUaGUHamkNOTDrdp+nrd1fkZO07uXRAjACc+awXOjZ0y6

I still have not heard back from committers and that really is unfortunate. I am going to give us one more week, because this really does matter. After that, we should not wait any more and will be moving forward with the v1 API largely as-is.

On Mar 25, 2026, at 7:38 AM, Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx> wrote:


A gentle reminder. For v1, we would wan to aim for a solid, consensus based foundation. Review is instrumental to that.

On Mar 21, 2026, at 7:17 PM, Reza Rahman <reza_rahman@xxxxxxxx> wrote:


Folks,

Our next step is to publish the API to Maven staging. This will effectively make it available to developers. Before we do that step, I would like to reach committer consensus.

I do hope that by now you have taken some time to review the context. I now ask that you carefully review the proposed API: https://github.com/jakartaee/agentic-ai/tree/main/api. While the specification document will have a lot more details, a great deal of the behavior is actually already documented in the API Javadoc.

Please provide your feedback and comments here. I will spin out separate threads to keep the discussion focused if necessary. I would like to see if we can achieve consensus by Friday. In that spirit, if everything looks good from a v1 perspective, I ask that you please respond with a +1 so I can count your vote.

Onward!

Cheers,
Reza
_______________________________________________
agentic-ai-dev mailing list
agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org
_______________________________________________
agentic-ai-dev mailing list
agentic-ai-dev@xxxxxxxxxxx
To unsubscribe from this list, visit https://accounts.eclipse.org

Back to the top