Hello,
I am using SUMO, SIDRA Intersection and PTV VISSIM simulation programs in my thesis study. I have prepared a table comparing these programs, but there may be some mistakes or omissions.
I would like to share the relevant part of the table with you and ask you to identify possible errors or omissions and help me correct them.
Your support in this matter is very valuable to me. Thank you in advance for your help and contributions. I look forward to your reply.
Feature / Software
|
PTV VISSIM
|
SIDRA Intersection
|
Eclipse SUMO
|
Developer
|
PTV Group (Germany)
|
Akçelik & Associates (Australia)
|
DLR – German Aerospace Center (Germany)
|
License Type
|
Commercial (paid)
|
Commercial (paid)
|
Open-source (free)
|
Modeling Type
|
Microscopic and multimodal
|
Akçelik M3D model
|
Microscopic and multimodal
|
Driver Behavior Model
|
Wiedemann 74 / 99 (calibratable)
|
Analytical model
|
Parametric models like Krauss / IDM / CACC
|
Output Types
|
Video, animation, raw data, graphics
|
Graphs, performance reports, tables
|
XML, CSV, animation
|
Code / API Support
|
High (Python, COM API, MATLAB integration)
|
Low (closed system)
|
High (Python TraCI API, SUMO net tools)
|
Visualization (2D/3D)
|
2D / 3D dynamic animation
|
Basic graphical outputs
|
Basic 2D/3D
|
Reporting (Delay, Queue, LOS)
|
Yes
|
Yes (very detailed)
|
Yes
|
Graphical User Interface (GUI)
|
Advanced, user-friendly
|
Basic but functional
|
Limited (SUMO-GUI or TraCI-based)
|
Key Strength
|
Realistic and detailed modeling
|
Easy and fast intersection-level analysis
|
Open-source, suitable for large networks, customizable
|
Gönderen: Eclipse Foundation <emo-records@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Gönderildi: 27 Mayıs 2025 Salı 07:32
Kime: AYŞE GÜNEŞ <202251015009@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Konu: Eclipse Account Registration
|