Eclipse Community Forums: Eclipse Platform » Religion: netBeans vs. Eclipse

Home » Eclipse Projects » Eclipse Platform » Religion: netBeans vs. Eclipse

Religion: netBeans vs. Eclipse [message #168462]

Tue, 09 December 2003 23:24

Eclipse User

Originally posted by: steven.colby.comcast.net

Hey, I hate to ask this -- but is there a clear direction yet from Sun
re: Eclipse? I note that Sun is still pimping the netBeans IDE (in the
form of the "Sun ONE Studio IDE").

So far I've found Eclipse to be better at text-ish things, but netBeans
*does* have the Swing GUI builder...

On a related note, how about an "eclipse.pointless_rant" newsgroup? <grin>

Steven Colby

Re: Religion: netBeans vs. Eclipse [message #168553 is a reply to message #168462]

Wed, 10 December 2003 03:05

Eclipse User

Originally posted by: hcs33.egon.gyaloglo.hu

Hi,

"Steven Colby" <steven.colby@comcast.net> wrote in message
news:br66vt$rj6$1@eclipse.org...
> Hey, I hate to ask this -- but is there a clear direction yet from Sun
> re: Eclipse? I note that Sun is still pimping the netBeans IDE (in the
> form of the "Sun ONE Studio IDE").
>
> So far I've found Eclipse to be better at text-ish things, but netBeans
> *does* have the Swing GUI builder...

Eclipse *does* have Swing and SWT GUI builders :)
See http://www.swt-designer.com (SWT) and http://www.eclipse.org/vep/
(Swing).

>
> On a related note, how about an "eclipse.pointless_rant" newsgroup?
<grin>
>
> Steven Colby
>

Regards,
Csaba

Re: Religion: netBeans vs. Eclipse [message #168580 is a reply to message #168553]

Wed, 10 December 2003 04:20

Eclipse User

Horv�h, Csaba wrote:

> Hi,
>
> "Steven Colby" <steven.colby@comcast.net> wrote in message
> news:br66vt$rj6$1@eclipse.org...
>> Hey, I hate to ask this -- but is there a clear direction yet from Sun
>> re: Eclipse? I note that Sun is still pimping the netBeans IDE (in the
>> form of the "Sun ONE Studio IDE").
>>
>> So far I've found Eclipse to be better at text-ish things, but netBeans
>> *does* have the Swing GUI builder...
>
> Eclipse *does* have Swing and SWT GUI builders :)
> See http://www.swt-designer.com (SWT) and http://www.eclipse.org/vep/
> (Swing).

swt-designer is comercial, but VE is slow on Linux - netbeans is superior
for GUI i WEB development, but eclipse have refactoring (netbeans anounce
refactoring for Mart, 2004, but eclipse is superior)

regards

Re: Religion: netBeans vs. Eclipse [message #168618 is a reply to message #168580]

Wed, 10 December 2003 04:53

Eclipse User

Originally posted by: jmedina.on.com

I think this is not the forum to debate about netBeans and Eclipse
functionality.
This newsgroup is dedicated to use Eclipse as a platform for other
applications.
I would accept a debate on what's better to create an application using
either netBeans or Eclipse as a framework.
My comments on that are:
The concept of Nodes in netBeans are really helpful. I find it missing
in Eclipse.
Creating a new tree-like View in Eclipse is easy -faster for a
Eclipse-newbie than for a Netbeans newbie- but, the advantage of Eclipse
ends there. You end up creating the concept of Nodes in Eclipse to make the
code more generic. I even have had the intention to use the netBeans API as
a plugin to Eclipse... Some of the netBeans libraries are useful even in not
netBeans applications: filesystems and nodes are a good example.

-Jorge

Previous Topic:	[3.0 M5] Regular expression replacement expressions...
Next Topic:	Markers don't show up in overview ruler???

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

Current Time: Wed Nov 05 23:11:58 EST 2025

.:: Contact :: Home ::.

Breadcrumbs

Sign up to our Newsletter