Eclipse Community Forums: Eclipse Scout » Not sure if we've found an SDK bug

Home » Eclipse Projects » Eclipse Scout » Not sure if we've found an SDK bug

Not sure if we've found an SDK bug [message #1153133]

Thu, 24 October 2013 07:58

Eclipse User

In our Scout project, we use the "Window->Preferences->Scout->User legacy target package=Yes" setting.

When we right-click on <project>.client.Forms->New Form; name it "Bug" and click on Finish, the following files are created:

<project>.client/<project>.client.ui.forms\BugForm.java
<project>.server/<project>.server.services.process\BugProcessService.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.security\CreateBugPermission.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.security\ReadBugPermission.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.security\UpdateBugPermission.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.services.process\BugFormData.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.services.process\IBugProcessService.java

However, if I try the same on <project>.server.Services->New Service; name it "BugService" and click on Finish, the files are created as follows:
<project>.server/<project>.server.services.process\BugService.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.services.process\CreateBugPermission.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.services.process\ReadBugPermission.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.services.process\UpdateBugPermission.java
<project>.shared/<project>.shared.services.process\IBugService.java

Note that the three Permission files are created in the services.process package instead of the security package.

I can reproduce this with the Scout SDK 3.9.1 (Kepler SR1) and 3.10 (the nightly Luna build).

Is this intended? Or have we stumbled across a long sleeping bug?

I'd be happy to create a bug, but before I do so I wanted to check that it really is a bug.

Re: Not sure if we've found an SDK bug [message #1154276 is a reply to message #1153133]

Fri, 25 October 2013 01:11

Eclipse User

According to what we had defined in Bug Bug 405687, with the setting „User legacy target package =Yes", the SDK should behave like in 3.8. This is not the case.

In my opinion, I think you have found a bug. I will ask the SDK Team for confirmation.

Re: Not sure if we've found an SDK bug [message #1158908 is a reply to message #1154276]

Mon, 28 October 2013 03:06

Eclipse User

Jeremie Bresson wrote on Fri, 25 October 2013 07:11

According to what we had defined in Bug Bug 405687, with the setting „User legacy target package =Yes", the SDK should behave like in 3.8. This is not the case.

In my opinion, I think you have found a bug. I will ask the SDK Team for confirmation.

Thanks. Let me know when you have confirmation and I will create a bug.

Re: Not sure if we've found an SDK bug [message #1171544 is a reply to message #1158908]

Tue, 05 November 2013 04:57

Eclipse User

For me this is a bug.

Thanks for reporting this!

regards,
m

Re: Not sure if we've found an SDK bug [message #1172921 is a reply to message #1171544]

Wed, 06 November 2013 01:52

Eclipse User

Bug 421126 created.

Re: Not sure if we've found an SDK bug [message #1173131 is a reply to message #1172921]

Wed, 06 November 2013 05:04

Eclipse User