Eclipse Community Forums: Buckminster » Error "Dependency X is defined more then once in component Y" should not occur

Help

Home

Home » Archived » Buckminster » Error "Dependency X is defined more then once in component Y" should not occur

Show: Today's Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator

Error "Dependency X is defined more then once in component Y" should not occur [message #383584]

Sun, 29 March 2009 05:02

Scott Hendrickson

Messages: 69
Registered: July 2009

Member

I'd like to import org.eclipse.emf.sdk as an eclipse.feature. However, the
feature apparently depends on org.eclipse.emf multiple times, which causes
an error. I'm not sure why this is an error. It seems like this should be
okay. DEBUG output includes:

ERROR [0002] : Resolution attempt ended with exception: Dependency
org.eclipse.emf is defined more then once in component org.eclipse.emf.sdk

-- Scott

P.S. it should be "than" not "then"

Report message to a moderator

Re: Error "Dependency X is defined more then once in component Y" should not occur [message #383586 is a reply to message #383584]

Sun, 29 March 2009 07:57

Thomas Hallgren

Messages: 3240
Registered: July 2009

Senior Member

Hi Scott,
Buckminster had a bug earlier that caused this behavior. It was changed
so that no exception would be thrown unless the dependencies had
conflicting version ranges (i.e. ranges that does not intersect).

I can successfully resolve org.eclipse.emf.sdk. Both from their CVS and
from the galileo update and both with the 3.4.x and 3.5.x releases of
Buckminster. What Buckminster version are you using and from where do
you attempt the resolution?

Regards,
Thomas Hallgren

Scott Hendrickson wrote:
> I'd like to import org.eclipse.emf.sdk as an eclipse.feature. However, the
> feature apparently depends on org.eclipse.emf multiple times, which causes
> an error. I'm not sure why this is an error. It seems like this should be
> okay. DEBUG output includes:
>
> ERROR [0002] : Resolution attempt ended with exception: Dependency
> org.eclipse.emf is defined more then once in component org.eclipse.emf.sdk
>
> -- Scott
>
> P.S. it should be "than" not "then"
>
>

Report message to a moderator

Re: Error "Dependency X is defined more then once in component Y" should not occur [message #383829 is a reply to message #383586]

Sun, 29 March 2009 15:23

Scott Hendrickson

Messages: 69
Registered: July 2009

Member

"Thomas Hallgren" <thomas@tada.se> wrote in message
news:49CF29DB.8050508@tada.se...
> Hi Scott,
> Buckminster had a bug earlier that caused this behavior. It was changed so
> that no exception would be thrown unless the dependencies had conflicting
> version ranges (i.e. ranges that does not intersect).
>
> I can successfully resolve org.eclipse.emf.sdk. Both from their CVS and
> from the galileo update and both with the 3.4.x and 3.5.x releases of
> Buckminster. What Buckminster version are you using and from where do you
> attempt the resolution?
>

I installed it yesterday from the update site. The version numbers are
below. The attached project has a cquery/rmap that reproduces the error on
my machine. Hopefully that helps :)
-- Scott

From the Eclipse config...

eclipse-SDK-3.4.2-win32
eclipse.buildId=M20090211-1700

*** Features:
org.eclipse.buckminster.core.feature (1.1.0.r10068) "Buckminster UI Plug-in"
org.eclipse.buckminster.cvs.feature (1.0.0.r09930) "Buckminster CVS Plug-in"
org.eclipse.buckminster.maven.feature (1.1.0.r09904) "Buckminster Maven
Plug-in"
org.eclipse.buckminster.p4.feature (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster Perforce UI
Plug-in"
org.eclipse.buckminster.pde.feature (1.1.340.r10061) "Buckminster PDE
Plug-in"
org.eclipse.buckminster.subclipse.feature (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster
Subclipse Support Plug-in"

*** Plug-in Registry:
org.eclipse.buckminster.ant (1.1.0.r10009) "Buckminster Ant Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.cmdline (1.0.0.r10068) "Buckminster Headless
Launcher" [Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.core (1.1.340.r10056) "Buckminster Core" [Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.cvs (1.0.0.r09930) "Buckminster CVS Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.download (1.1.0.r09983) "Buckminster download cache"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.executor (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster Executor
Plug-in" [Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.fetcher (1.0.0.r09849) "Buckminster Fetcher Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.generic (1.0.0.r09794) "Buckminster Generic Plug-in"
[Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.generic.ui (1.0.0.r09795) "Buckminster Generic Ui
Plug-in" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.installer (1.0.0.r10015) "Installer Plug-in"
[Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.jdt (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster JDT Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.maven (1.1.0.r09904) "Buckminster Maven Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.opml (1.0.0.r09811) "Buckminster OPML support"
[Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.osgi.filter (1.0.0) "OSGi Filter Bundle" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.p4 (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster Perforce Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.p4.ui (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster Perforce UI
Plug-in" [Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.pde (1.1.340.r10061) "Buckminster PDE Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.pde.ui (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster Ui Plug-in for
the PDE extension" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.remote (1.0.0.r10056) "Buckminster Remote"
[Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.remote.cloudsmith (1.0.0.r09666) "Cloudsmith Remote
Resolution Service Connector" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.runtime (1.1.0.r09986) "Buckminster Runtime Plug-in"
[Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.sax (1.0.0.r09855) "Buckminster SAX Parser
utilities" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.slf4j (1.0.0) "Slf4j implementation using the
Buckminster logger" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.subclipse (1.0.0.r09848) "Buckminster Subclipse
Support Plug-in" [Starting]
org.eclipse.buckminster.subversion (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster Subversion
commons Plug-in" [Resolved]
org.eclipse.buckminster.ui (1.0.0.r10056) "Buckminster UI Plug-in"
[Starting]

Thank you,
-- Scott

> Regards,
> Thomas Hallgren
>
>
> Scott Hendrickson wrote:
>> I'd like to import org.eclipse.emf.sdk as an eclipse.feature. However,
>> the feature apparently depends on org.eclipse.emf multiple times, which
>> causes an error. I'm not sure why this is an error. It seems like this
>> should be okay. DEBUG output includes:
>>
>> ERROR [0002] : Resolution attempt ended with exception: Dependency
>> org.eclipse.emf is defined more then once in component
>> org.eclipse.emf.sdk
>>
>> -- Scott
>>
>> P.S. it should be "than" not "then"

Attachment: buckminster-multidependency.zip
(Size: 5.55KB, Downloaded 151 times)

Report message to a moderator

Re: Error "Dependency X is defined more then once in component Y" should not occur [message #383831 is a reply to message #383829]

Sun, 29 March 2009 16:28

Scott Hendrickson

Messages: 69
Registered: July 2009

Member

I went ahead and filed a bug here:
https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=270387

If I somehow have an older version of buckminster, then my apologies for the
noise ;)

-- Scott

"Scott Hendrickson" <shendric@uci.edu> wrote in message
news:gqo3p6$n1q$1@build.eclipse.org...
>
> "Thomas Hallgren" <thomas@tada.se> wrote in message
> news:49CF29DB.8050508@tada.se...
>> Hi Scott,
>> Buckminster had a bug earlier that caused this behavior. It was changed
>> so
>> that no exception would be thrown unless the dependencies had conflicting
>> version ranges (i.e. ranges that does not intersect).
>>
>> I can successfully resolve org.eclipse.emf.sdk. Both from their CVS and
>> from the galileo update and both with the 3.4.x and 3.5.x releases of
>> Buckminster. What Buckminster version are you using and from where do you
>> attempt the resolution?
>>
>
> I installed it yesterday from the update site. The version numbers are
> below. The attached project has a cquery/rmap that reproduces the error on
> my machine. Hopefully that helps :)
> -- Scott
>
>
> From the Eclipse config...
>
> eclipse-SDK-3.4.2-win32
> eclipse.buildId=M20090211-1700
>
> *** Features:
> org.eclipse.buckminster.core.feature (1.1.0.r10068) "Buckminster UI
> Plug-in"
> org.eclipse.buckminster.cvs.feature (1.0.0.r09930) "Buckminster CVS
> Plug-in"
> org.eclipse.buckminster.maven.feature (1.1.0.r09904) "Buckminster Maven
> Plug-in"
> org.eclipse.buckminster.p4.feature (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster Perforce UI
> Plug-in"
> org.eclipse.buckminster.pde.feature (1.1.340.r10061) "Buckminster PDE
> Plug-in"
> org.eclipse.buckminster.subclipse.feature (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster
> Subclipse Support Plug-in"
>
> *** Plug-in Registry:
> org.eclipse.buckminster.ant (1.1.0.r10009) "Buckminster Ant Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.cmdline (1.0.0.r10068) "Buckminster Headless
> Launcher" [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.core (1.1.340.r10056) "Buckminster Core"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.cvs (1.0.0.r09930) "Buckminster CVS Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.download (1.1.0.r09983) "Buckminster download
> cache"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.executor (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster Executor
> Plug-in" [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.fetcher (1.0.0.r09849) "Buckminster Fetcher
> Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.generic (1.0.0.r09794) "Buckminster Generic
> Plug-in"
> [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.generic.ui (1.0.0.r09795) "Buckminster Generic Ui
> Plug-in" [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.installer (1.0.0.r10015) "Installer Plug-in"
> [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.jdt (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster JDT Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.maven (1.1.0.r09904) "Buckminster Maven Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.opml (1.0.0.r09811) "Buckminster OPML support"
> [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.osgi.filter (1.0.0) "OSGi Filter Bundle"
> [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.p4 (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster Perforce Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.p4.ui (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster Perforce UI
> Plug-in" [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.pde (1.1.340.r10061) "Buckminster PDE Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.pde.ui (1.0.0.r09842) "Buckminster Ui Plug-in for
> the PDE extension" [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.remote (1.0.0.r10056) "Buckminster Remote"
> [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.remote.cloudsmith (1.0.0.r09666) "Cloudsmith
> Remote
> Resolution Service Connector" [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.runtime (1.1.0.r09986) "Buckminster Runtime
> Plug-in"
> [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.sax (1.0.0.r09855) "Buckminster SAX Parser
> utilities" [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.slf4j (1.0.0) "Slf4j implementation using the
> Buckminster logger" [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.subclipse (1.0.0.r09848) "Buckminster Subclipse
> Support Plug-in" [Starting]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.subversion (1.0.0.r09908) "Buckminster Subversion
> commons Plug-in" [Resolved]
> org.eclipse.buckminster.ui (1.0.0.r10056) "Buckminster UI Plug-in"
> [Starting]
>
>
> Thank you,
> -- Scott
>
>> Regards,
>> Thomas Hallgren
>>
>>
>> Scott Hendrickson wrote:
>>> I'd like to import org.eclipse.emf.sdk as an eclipse.feature. However,
>>> the feature apparently depends on org.eclipse.emf multiple times, which
>>> causes an error. I'm not sure why this is an error. It seems like this
>>> should be okay. DEBUG output includes:
>>>
>>> ERROR [0002] : Resolution attempt ended with exception: Dependency
>>> org.eclipse.emf is defined more then once in component
>>> org.eclipse.emf.sdk
>>>
>>> -- Scott
>>>
>>> P.S. it should be "than" not "then"
>
>
>
>

Report message to a moderator

Previous Topic:	mspec bugs? and a feature request
Next Topic:	Problem Materializing Buckminster into 3.4 Workspace

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [

]

Current Time: Sat Apr 27 01:21:59 GMT 2024

.:: Contact :: Home ::.

Breadcrumbs

Sign up to our Newsletter