|
|
|
|
|
Re: StateInvariant visualization (StateMachine Diagram) [message #1849242 is a reply to message #1849239] |
Mon, 10 January 2022 08:56 |
|
Hi Alberto,
I am just an Eclipse Papyrus user. I have no stakes in the development of Eclipse Papyrus. As a result I feel not being the right person to confirm this.
But being more on the SE process side, establishing (MB)SE at my customers I already used almost all MBSE tools available. On that base I can confirm you that Eclipse Papyrus beside Eclipse Capella is one of the least buggy. All these tools have issues. I presume every non-trivial piece of software has issues. But I faced the least issues with these two MBSE tools. And I used both a damn lot.
And all of the issues I faced with Eclipse Papyrus and its predecessor Topcased so far are non-blocking issues.
As an example of an issue a personally rate blocker issue: Try the following steps with a commercial MBSE tools, I am not allowed to disclose the name due to its EULA (end user license agreement):
1. create a new UML or SysML project
2. create two elements connected by a directed relation
3. get the provider UUID of the provider element and safe it in a text editor, on paper, or else
4. delete the provider element from the model
5. safe the project
6. to be sure no cashing effects are involved, transfer the project file to another PC
7. re-open the project on the second PC
8. export the model as XMI
9. open the XMI file in a text editor and search the provider UUID
You will face the relation is still in the model and the refId of the provider has no Id counterpart. That tool cannot even ensure referential integrity of the model.
Ok, I first reported that issue some 15 years ago. I have reported it two more times so far and the two times I got the statement: "Thank you for reporting this issue, which is new to us.". Ok, when I confront them with the old tickets, they simply get upset ;-)
/Carsten
[Updated on: Mon, 10 January 2022 08:58] Report message to a moderator
|
|
|
|
Powered by
FUDForum. Page generated in 0.04203 seconds