Eclipse Community Forums: Sirius » Edges between contained elements disapear when horizontally stacked containers are moved.

Home » Eclipse Projects » Sirius » Edges between contained elements disapear when horizontally stacked containers are moved.(Edges between contained elements disapear when horizontally stacked containers are moved.)

Show: Today's Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator

Edges between contained elements disapear when horizontally stacked containers are moved. [message #1801898]

Tue, 29 January 2019 11:35

Neil Mackenzie

Messages: 129
Registered: December 2013

Senior Member

In a Sirius specification, when a container has children's presentation marked as 'horizontal stack' and then there is an edge relation between items in a sub-container of this container, the edges display very neatly, even with very large diagrams.

However when a container is moved on screen many of the edges just disappear. This problem does not occur when I choose 'free form' for the children's presentation (unfortunately I need a horizontal stack)

I have attached images here, based on a simple model where a TablesSet contains some tables, a Table contains Columns, and the Columns can have a dependency on Columns from another table. Model and .odesign specification is attached also, with example instance.

If this is a bug I am happy to raise a bug report and if pointed to some code, I can help to investigate also.

The images attached are:
1.) nicely laid out container with children presentation set as 'horizontal stack'
2.) screenshot after moving this container (edges disappear)
3.) nicely laid out container with children presentation as 'free form'
4.) screenshot after moving this container (edges do not disappear)

I am using the eclipse modelling package from the December 2018 release which uses Sirius 6.1.1.

index.php/fa/34749/0/

Attachment: containerWithFreeFormPresentation.PNG
(Size: 16.72KB, Downloaded 213 times)
Attachment: containerWithFreeFormPresentationAfterMoving.PNG
(Size: 21.61KB, Downloaded 237 times)
Attachment: containerWithHorizontalStack.PNG
(Size: 12.92KB, Downloaded 327 times)
Attachment: containerWithHorizontalStackAfterMoving.PNG
(Size: 12.42KB, Downloaded 178 times)
Attachment: model_and_specification_plugins.zip
(Size: 49.39KB, Downloaded 39 times)

Report message to a moderator

Re: Edges between contained elements disapear when horizontally stacked containers are moved. [message #1801914 is a reply to message #1801898]

Tue, 29 January 2019 13:59

Steve Monnier

Messages: 508
Registered: May 2011

Senior Member

Hello,

Indeed, this seems like a bug that is not listed in the documentation known limitation of compartments [1]. Can you open a new bugzilla? In our defense, I am not quite sure that having edges on compartment is visually a good idea. Depending on where the edge connects with the compartment, you have no idea if the edge is connected to the compartment or to its container (like on your first screenshot).

Regards,
Steve

[1] https://www.eclipse.org/sirius/doc/specifier/diagrams/Diagrams.html#containers

Steve Monnier - Obeo
Need training or professional services for Sirius?
http://www.obeodesigner.com/sirius

Report message to a moderator

Re: Edges between contained elements disapear when horizontally stacked containers are moved. [message #1801920 is a reply to message #1801914]

Tue, 29 January 2019 14:28

Neil Mackenzie

Messages: 129
Registered: December 2013

Senior Member

Thanks Steve,
I will raise a bug report.
I understand your comment. I am building a traceable data application, and this is the only way I could find to show the column traceability neatly from my model (where tables are listed vertically and columns horizontally, tightly packed) .

This layout is very very neat for me, and I benefit from the fact that I only ever have one column in the column container (so it is not important to me to know if the edge is connected to the compartment or to its container).

I would like to get this fixed quickly, but don't have any money to pay for consultancy :)
Also, I would like to learn to compile Sirius because I am keen to contribute in the push to sirius on the web.

If on the bug report someone could point me to roughly where that layout code lives I can help investigate and contribute to the fix.

Regards,
Neil

Report message to a moderator