Skip to main content

Eclipse Community Forums
Forum Search:

Search      Help    Register    Login    Home
Home » Eclipse Projects » XML Schema Definition (XSD) » XML <-> ASN.1 : Developer response?
XML <-> ASN.1 : Developer response? [message #592984] Fri, 03 December 2004 03:40
Sean Champ is currently offline Sean ChampFriend
Messages: 2
Registered: July 2009
Junior Member

* Background:

I've started looking into ASN.1, for incorporation into some project

I've worked with SGML and XML, and I've not been terribly satisfied with
XML Schemas, honestly -- and I am not looking to start a "flame war" about
it, but maybe it will serve to explain the background of this message.

I've not been terribly satisfied with XML Schemas, myself, and I am quite
satisfied, with what I'm seeing about (and of) ASN.1[1].

I'd noticed, also, that there are some standards, available from the
ITU[2], for tranlsation-or-something between ASN.1 and XML/XML-Schema

Now, I don't know if XMI has "anything, directly technical, to do with
any of this" -- though, of course, it seems that XMI might accomplish
an end simliar to that of ASN.1. (I've not read much of anything about
XMI, but I think I can guess the intention of it -- and yet, I cannot
guess about how it plays in with-or-beside SOAP; I saw XML mentioned,
in one of the UML 2.0 standards drafts; it seemed worth mentioning,
here, also).

* Question:

Has anyone looked at any of the stuff (standards and/or tools) for
managign XML<->ASN.1 "translation" work?

If so: What has anyone thought of it?

* Motivation

Perhaps ASN.1<->XML "stuff" could ever be pertinent for the Eclipse
project - "off in the R&D wing of things, for now", heh.

(and beside that: I'll have to "dig" into some more research about
such standards & tools, myself. It will be easier, probably, if I know
of anyone who's found such standards/tools to be useful, now or in a
clear-enough prospective end)

** end **

hadios o wiedersehen,

Sean Champ
Fresno, California

[1] "FWIW", there is one /very well written/ book about ASN.1, freely
avaialable for download, at:
It was written, originally, in French, I think; the version,
available at the page referenced, above, was translated into
English, and the translation was quite well done. Regardless of
choices of national language, the book is quite thoroughly
descrptive about ASN.1, regarding: the basis and motivation, for
the development of ASN.1; the language and the specific syntax of
ASN.1; some example-type uses of ASN.1, "to get the reader going,

(Yes, this is not an advertisement; I just wanted to be thorough, heh.)

[2] ASN.1 standards:
...most, if not all of which, are available, freely, for download.

(The ITU, thus far, has liked to charge fees, for download of some
other standards of theirs; it looks like they've put ASN.1 "in the
clear", though.)
Previous Topic:Running out of memory..
Next Topic:Running out of memory..
Goto Forum:

Current Time: Thu May 24 08:18:44 GMT 2018

Powered by FUDForum. Page generated in 0.01938 seconds
.:: Contact :: Home ::.

Powered by: FUDforum 3.0.2.
Copyright ©2001-2010 FUDforum Bulletin Board Software

Back to the top