Eclipse Community Forums: Eclipse Platform » Unable to contribute to editor menus using org.eclipse.ui.menus

Home » Eclipse Projects » Eclipse Platform » Unable to contribute to editor menus using org.eclipse.ui.menus

Unable to contribute to editor menus using org.eclipse.ui.menus [message #499101]

Thu, 19 November 2009 15:30

Eclipse User

Apologies if this has been asked and answered before, but I can't seem
to find a reference.

The documentation in org.eclipse.ui.editorActions extension point would
have one believe that it is possible to contribute menus created by an
editor's action bar contributor. However, this doesn't seem to be
possible (unless I'm missing something?) I can provide a simple test
case where an editor's action bar contributor creates a top-level menu
manager with a unique id; a menu contribution targeting that menu won't
show up. Should this work?

Re: Unable to contribute to editor menus using org.eclipse.ui.menus [message #499305 is a reply to message #499101]

Fri, 20 November 2009 13:02

Eclipse User

If you mean you'd like to use editorActions to create the menu and then contribute to it using o.e.ui.menus, that won't work.

o.e.ui.menus can see programmatic contributions, and o.e.ui.editorActions can see programmatic contributions and o.e.ui.menus contributions (because of the order they are applied in).

The old action extensions (actionSets, editorActions, etc) are processed last.

PW

Re: Unable to contribute to editor menus using org.eclipse.ui.menus [message #499320 is a reply to message #499305]

Fri, 20 November 2009 14:05

Eclipse User

Thank you, Paul. Actually the problem I have goes the other way around.
I create a top-level menu in an editor's action bar contributor:

public void contributeToMenu(IMenuManager menuManager) {
super.contributeToMenu(menuManager);
IMenuManager editorMenuManager = new MenuManager("Sample Editor Menu",
"org.eclipse.ui.menus.test.sampleEditor");
menuManager.insertAfter(IWorkbenchActionConstants.MB_ADDITIO NS,
editorMenuManager);
editorMenuManager.add(new
Separator(IWorkbenchActionConstants.MB_ADDITIONS));
}

Then I want to contribute a menu to it using o.e.ui.menus:

<menuContribution
locationURI="menu:org.eclipse.ui.menus.test.sampleEditor?after=additions ">
<command commandId="org.eclipse.ui.menus.test.commands.sampleCommand "
style="push">
</command>
</menuContribution>

The command and a handler for it are defined and active (also
successfully contributed to a context menu).

Am I missing something? Do you have an example where this does work?
Thanks again.

--Peter

Paul Webster wrote:
> If you mean you'd like to use editorActions to create the menu and then
> contribute to it using o.e.ui.menus, that won't work.
>
> o.e.ui.menus can see programmatic contributions, and
> o.e.ui.editorActions can see programmatic contributions and o.e.ui.menus
> contributions (because of the order they are applied in).
>
> The old action extensions (actionSets, editorActions, etc) are processed
> last.
>
> PW
>

Re: Unable to contribute to editor menus using org.eclipse.ui.menus [message #499328 is a reply to message #499320]

Fri, 20 November 2009 15:15

Eclipse User

Ah, editor action bars suffer from the same problem. They're part of the legacy action system and are not exposed properly.

PW

Previous Topic:	How to force editor to foreground?
Next Topic:	Using a java.net.URLConnection with a proxy

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

Current Time: Wed Jul 23 09:40:16 EDT 2025

.:: Contact :: Home ::.

Breadcrumbs

Sign up to our Newsletter