Eclipse Community Forums: Eclipse Platform » [RCP] WorkbenchAdvisor vs plugin.xml (menus)

Home » Eclipse Projects » Eclipse Platform » [RCP] WorkbenchAdvisor vs plugin.xml (menus)

[RCP] WorkbenchAdvisor vs plugin.xml (menus) [message #256590]

Tue, 29 June 2004 04:10

Eclipse User

I'm starting to learn RCP and wondered whether declaring things in plugin.xml is
equivalent to creating them in my subclass of WorkbenchAdvisor. In particular,
I'd prefer to declare all my menus using actionSets extension point instead of
overriding fillActionBars method. However, it seems that if I don't create my
menu there it won't appear in the workbench. Here is a part of my plugin.xml
file (suppose fillActionBars is not overriden):

<extension
point="org.eclipse.ui.actionSets">
<actionSet
label="%actionSet"
id="actionSet">
<menu
label="%fileMenu"
id="file">
<groupMarker name="fileStart"/>
<separator name="fileEnd"/>
</menu>
<action
label="%quitAction"
class="org.eclipse.ui.internal.QuitAction"
menubarPath="file/fileEnd"
id="quitAction"/>
</actionSet>
</extension>

Note also that the same plugin declares extensions to
org.eclipse.core.runtime.applications and org.eclipse.core.runtime.products (if
this makes any difference).

Any help would be appreciated

Michal Tkacz

Re: [RCP] WorkbenchAdvisor vs plugin.xml (menus) [message #256698 is a reply to message #256590]

Tue, 29 June 2004 11:15

Eclipse User

Originally posted by: eclipse.removeMe.guide.andRemoveMe.earthlink.andMeToo.com

They are equivalent but not interchangeable. Looking at your extract, the
QuitAction class your example wishes to contribute doesn't appear to
implement IWorkbenchWindowActionDelegate as expected by the <action> tag
(ergo "ClassCastException"). Take a look at IDEWorkbenchAdvisor. It
creates the standard menus and has a lot of the code you can emulate for
your own menus and those contributed by Eclipse plug-ins that you may wish
to reuse (e.g., text editor plug-in assumes you've created the standard Edit
pulldown).

-- Dan
-----------------------------------------
co-author, "The Java Developer's Guide to Eclipse"

"Michal Tkacz" <mehow@neurosoft.net> wrote in message
news:cbr852$6vo$1@eclipse.org...
> I'm starting to learn RCP and wondered whether declaring things in
plugin.xml is
> equivalent to creating them in my subclass of WorkbenchAdvisor. In
particular,
> I'd prefer to declare all my menus using actionSets extension point
instead of
> overriding fillActionBars method. However, it seems that if I don't create
my
> menu there it won't appear in the workbench. Here is a part of my
plugin.xml
> file (suppose fillActionBars is not overriden):
>
> <extension
> point="org.eclipse.ui.actionSets">
> <actionSet
> label="%actionSet"
> id="actionSet">
> <menu
> label="%fileMenu"
> id="file">
> <groupMarker name="fileStart"/>
> <separator name="fileEnd"/>
> </menu>
> <action
> label="%quitAction"
> class="org.eclipse.ui.internal.QuitAction"
> menubarPath="file/fileEnd"
> id="quitAction"/>
> </actionSet>
> </extension>
>
> Note also that the same plugin declares extensions to
> org.eclipse.core.runtime.applications and
org.eclipse.core.runtime.products (if
> this makes any difference).
>
> Any help would be appreciated
>
> Michal Tkacz

Re: [RCP] WorkbenchAdvisor vs plugin.xml (menus) [message #256733 is a reply to message #256698]

Tue, 29 June 2004 12:46

Eclipse User

Dan Kehn wrote:
> They are equivalent but not interchangeable. Looking at your extract, the
> QuitAction class your example wishes to contribute doesn't appear to
> implement IWorkbenchWindowActionDelegate as expected by the <action> tag
> (ergo "ClassCastException").

You're absolutely right. I missed that (however no exceptions were thrown during
workbench startup). The point is that I'd like to reuse some common actions
(like Quit) but declare them in plugin.xml file if possible. It seems that I
could wrap org.eclipse.ui.internal.QuitAction instance with a class that
implements IWorkbenchWindowActionDelegate, I'll try that.

> Take a look at IDEWorkbenchAdvisor. It
> creates the standard menus and has a lot of the code you can emulate for
> your own menus and those contributed by Eclipse plug-ins that you may wish
> to reuse (e.g., text editor plug-in assumes you've created the standard Edit
> pulldown).

I will. Thanks for help.

Michal Tkacz

Previous Topic:	Eclipse and Free TTS
Next Topic:	Build Running/Complete API???

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

Current Time: Thu Jul 10 01:55:19 EDT 2025

.:: Contact :: Home ::.

Breadcrumbs

Sign up to our Newsletter