Eclipse Community Forums: ServerTools (WTP) » problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if output folder is WebContent/WEB-INF/class

Home » Language IDEs » ServerTools (WTP) » problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if output folder is WebContent/WEB-INF/class

Show: Today's Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator

problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if output folder is WebContent/WEB-INF/class [message #489551]

Sun, 04 October 2009 19:13

Ivica Loncar

Messages: 41
Registered: July 2009

Member

Hi all,

I have a problem publishing project directly to the tomcat installation.

Dev environment is Eclipse 3.5, WTP 3.1.1, and I use IVYDE (latest version
from trunk) to resolve dependencies.

I know it is somehow related to the IVYDE but I suspect it's also related
to the Tomcat publisher.

Tomcat server is configured so that deploy uses tomcat installation and deploy
path is ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps

This is a scenario that works:

Setup:
- create dynamic web project using vanilla WTP
- associate IVY configuration with the project (IVYDE contributes classpath
containers to the project)
- in "Java EE Module dependencies" select ivy container for export into
WEB-INF/lib
- resolve IVY libs
- clean project
- publish to tomcat
Result:
- jars put directly under ${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/lib are published into
${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs
- jars resolved using IVY are located in ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs

This scenario doesn't work:
- now go to the "Project properties" -> "Java build path" and change Default
output folder from {PROJECT_NAME}/build/classes to {PROJECT_NAME}/WebContent/WEB-INF/classes

- resolve IVY libs
- clean project
- publish to tomcat
Result:
- jars put directly under ${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/lib are published into
${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs
- jars resolved using IVY are NOT published into ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs

I was trying to revert to original setting but sometimes it works, sometimes
it doesn't work and I can't figure what's different. Files in the .settings
folder look just the same.

Export to the WAR file works just fine.

How does the publisher know that some classpath container has to be exported
to the WEB-INF/lib?
Is there a documentation for the WTP extension developers (like: how to add
custom classpath container such that WTP picks it up properly)?

P.S. I have tried to follow publishing process of WTP but it's too complicated
so I ask help from someone who understand it.

--
Ivica Loncar

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if output folder is WebContent/WEB-INF/c [message #489697 is a reply to message #489551]

Mon, 05 October 2009 15:25

Larry Isaacs

Messages: 1354
Registered: July 2009

Senior Member

A classpath container declaration in the ".classpath" file would need a
WTP defined attribute like the following to be included in WEB-INF/lib:

<attribute name="org.eclipse.jst.component.dependency"
value="/WEB-INF/lib"/>

Enabling the "container" on the Java EE Module Dependencies page should
add this attribute.

Note that configuring your project to place build artifacts into your
project's source area (i.e. compiling the Java classes into
WebContent/WEB-INF/classes) triggers special WTP behavior that has
proven difficult to get to work correctly for all use cases. Your
non-working scenario could be tripping over some issue related to that.

Cheers,
Larry

Ivica Loncar wrote:
>
> Hi all,
>
> I have a problem publishing project directly to the tomcat installation.
>
> Dev environment is Eclipse 3.5, WTP 3.1.1, and I use IVYDE (latest
> version from trunk) to resolve dependencies.
>
> I know it is somehow related to the IVYDE but I suspect it's also
> related to the Tomcat publisher.
>
> Tomcat server is configured so that deploy uses tomcat installation and
> deploy path is ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps
>
> This is a scenario that works:
>
> Setup:
> - create dynamic web project using vanilla WTP
> - associate IVY configuration with the project (IVYDE contributes
> classpath containers to the project) - in "Java EE Module dependencies"
> select ivy container for export into WEB-INF/lib
> - resolve IVY libs
> - clean project
> - publish to tomcat
> Result:
> - jars put directly under ${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/lib are published into
> ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs
> - jars resolved using IVY are located in
> ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs
>
>
> This scenario doesn't work:
> - now go to the "Project properties" -> "Java build path" and change
> Default output folder from {PROJECT_NAME}/build/classes to
> {PROJECT_NAME}/WebContent/WEB-INF/classes
> - resolve IVY libs
> - clean project
> - publish to tomcat
> Result:
> - jars put directly under ${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/lib are published into
> ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs
> - jars resolved using IVY are NOT published into
> ${TOMCAT_HOME}/webapps/${PROJECT_NAME}/WEB-INF/libs
>
>
> I was trying to revert to original setting but sometimes it works,
> sometimes it doesn't work and I can't figure what's different. Files in
> the .settings folder look just the same.
>
> Export to the WAR file works just fine.
>
>
> How does the publisher know that some classpath container has to be
> exported to the WEB-INF/lib?
> Is there a documentation for the WTP extension developers (like: how to
> add custom classpath container such that WTP picks it up properly)?
>
> P.S. I have tried to follow publishing process of WTP but it's too
> complicated so I ask help from someone who understand it.
>
>
>

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolder is WebContent/WEB-INF/cl [message #490004 is a reply to message #489697]

Tue, 06 October 2009 20:21

Ivica Loncar

Messages: 41
Registered: July 2009

Member

Hello Larry,

> A classpath container declaration in the ".classpath" file would need
> a WTP defined attribute like the following to be included in
> WEB-INF/lib:
>
> <attribute name="org.eclipse.jst.component.dependency"
> value="/WEB-INF/lib"/>
>
> Enabling the "container" on the Java EE Module Dependencies page
> should add this attribute.
>
> Note that configuring your project to place build artifacts into your
> project's source area (i.e. compiling the Java classes into
> WebContent/WEB-INF/classes) triggers special WTP behavior that has
> proven difficult to get to work correctly for all use cases. Your
> non-working scenario could be tripping over some issue related to
> that.

Thank you for the hints. I have isolated the problem and it seems to be related
to the multiple IVYDE classpath containers in the J2EE module dependencies
and the order they appear in the JAva Build Path ordering tab.

If I reorder classpath containers in Java Build Path's such that classpath
container that should be exported to the WEB-INF (the one marked under J2EE
module dependencies) comes first I get all required jars exported.

If I reverse the ordering I do not get jars contained in bothe classpath
containers.

I'm still trying to figure out if this is related to the IVYDE classpath
container or the way J2EE dependencies get exported to the WEB-INF/lib.

--
Ivica Loncar

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolder is WebContent/WEB-INF/cl [message #490125 is a reply to message #490004]

Wed, 07 October 2009 13:05

Larry Isaacs

Messages: 1354
Registered: July 2009

Senior Member

Ivica Loncar wrote:
> Hello Larry,
>
>> A classpath container declaration in the ".classpath" file would need
>> a WTP defined attribute like the following to be included in
>> WEB-INF/lib:
>>
>> <attribute name="org.eclipse.jst.component.dependency"
>> value="/WEB-INF/lib"/>
>>
>> Enabling the "container" on the Java EE Module Dependencies page
>> should add this attribute.
>>
>> Note that configuring your project to place build artifacts into your
>> project's source area (i.e. compiling the Java classes into
>> WebContent/WEB-INF/classes) triggers special WTP behavior that has
>> proven difficult to get to work correctly for all use cases. Your
>> non-working scenario could be tripping over some issue related to
>> that.
>
>
> Thank you for the hints. I have isolated the problem and it seems to be
> related to the multiple IVYDE classpath containers in the J2EE module
> dependencies and the order they appear in the JAva Build Path ordering tab.
>
> If I reorder classpath containers in Java Build Path's such that
> classpath container that should be exported to the WEB-INF (the one
> marked under J2EE module dependencies) comes first I get all required
> jars exported.
>
> If I reverse the ordering I do not get jars contained in bothe classpath
> containers.
>
> I'm still trying to figure out if this is related to the IVYDE classpath
> container or the way J2EE dependencies get exported to the WEB-INF/lib.
>
>

Sounds like a bug, but where? Are you able to determine if the content
of the classpath containers makes a difference, or just the order? If
you can post the relevant portions of the ".classpath" file, I could try
some experiments with some simple classpath container code I have.

Cheers,
Larry

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolderis WebContent/WEB-INF/cla [message #490379 is a reply to message #490125]

Thu, 08 October 2009 13:52

Ivica Loncar

Messages: 41
Registered: July 2009

Member

Hello Larry,

> Ivica Loncar wrote:
>> If I reorder classpath containers in Java Build Path's such that
>> classpath container that should be exported to the WEB-INF (the one
>> marked under J2EE module dependencies) comes first I get all required
>> jars exported.
>>
>> If I reverse the ordering I do not get jars contained in bothe
>> classpath containers.
>>
>> I'm still trying to figure out if this is related to the IVYDE
>> classpath container or the way J2EE dependencies get exported to the
>> WEB-INF/lib.
>>
> Sounds like a bug, but where? Are you able to determine if the
> content of the classpath containers makes a difference, or just the
> order? If you can post the relevant portions of the ".classpath"
> file, I could try some experiments with some simple classpath
> container code I have.
>

This is .classpath entry where compile comes before runtime (#1):

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<classpath>
<classpathentry kind="src" path="src"/>
<classpathentry kind="con" path="org.eclipse.jst.j2ee.internal.web.container"/>
<classpathentry kind="con" path="org.eclipse.jst.j2ee.internal.module.container"/>
<classpathentry kind="con" path=" org.eclipse.jst.server.core.container/org.eclipse.jst.server .tomcat.runtimeTarget/Apache
Tomcat v6.0">
<attributes>
<attribute name="owner.project.facets" value="jst.web"/>
</attributes>
</classpathentry>
<classpathentry kind="con" path=" org.eclipse.jdt.launching.JRE_CONTAINER/org.eclipse.jdt.inte rnal.debug.ui.launcher.StandardVMType/jdk ">
<attributes>
<attribute name="owner.project.facets" value="jst.java"/>
</attributes>
</classpathentry>
<classpathentry kind="con" path=" org.apache.ivyde.eclipse.cpcontainer.IVYDE_CONTAINER/?ivyXml Path=ivy%2Fivy.xml&confs=compile "/>
<classpathentry exported="true" kind="con" path=" org.apache.ivyde.eclipse.cpcontainer.IVYDE_CONTAINER/?ivyXml Path=ivy%2Fivy.xml&confs=runtime ">
<attributes>
<attribute name="org.eclipse.jst.component.dependency" value="/WEB-INF/lib"/>
</attributes>
</classpathentry>
<classpathentry kind="output" path="build/classes"/>
</classpath>

Contents of WEB-INF/lib in tomcat directory after publishing is:

aspectjrt-1.6.5.jar
aspectjweaver-1.6.5.jar
commons-pool-1.3.jar
easymock-2.5.1.jar
spring-aop-2.5.6.jar
spring-context-support-2.5.6.jar
spring-jms-2.5.6.jar
spring-web-2.5.6.jar
spring-webmvc-2.5.6.jar

(these are the jars that are resolved by the the runtime configuration but
not by the compile configuration).

and this is classpath entry where runtime comes before compile (#2):

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<classpath>
<classpathentry kind="src" path="src"/>
<classpathentry kind="con" path="org.eclipse.jst.j2ee.internal.web.container"/>
<classpathentry kind="con" path="org.eclipse.jst.j2ee.internal.module.container"/>
<classpathentry kind="con" path=" org.eclipse.jst.server.core.container/org.eclipse.jst.server .tomcat.runtimeTarget/Apache
Tomcat v6.0">
<attributes>
<attribute name="owner.project.facets" value="jst.web"/>
</attributes>
</classpathentry>
<classpathentry kind="con" path=" org.eclipse.jdt.launching.JRE_CONTAINER/org.eclipse.jdt.inte rnal.debug.ui.launcher.StandardVMType/jdk ">
<attributes>
<attribute name="owner.project.facets" value="jst.java"/>
</attributes>
</classpathentry>
<classpathentry exported="true" kind="con" path=" org.apache.ivyde.eclipse.cpcontainer.IVYDE_CONTAINER/?ivyXml Path=ivy%2Fivy.xml&confs=runtime ">
<attributes>
<attribute name="org.eclipse.jst.component.dependency" value="/WEB-INF/lib"/>
</attributes>
</classpathentry>
<classpathentry kind="con" path=" org.apache.ivyde.eclipse.cpcontainer.IVYDE_CONTAINER/?ivyXml Path=ivy%2Fivy.xml&confs=compile "/>
<classpathentry kind="output" path="build/classes"/>
</classpath>

Contents of WEB-INF/lib in tomcat directory after publishing is:

aopalliance-1.0.jar
aspectjrt-1.6.5.jar
aspectjweaver-1.6.5.jar
commons-fileupload-1.2.1.jar
commons-io-1.4.jar
commons-logging-1.1.1.jar
commons-pool-1.3.jar
dom4j-1.6.1.jar
easymock-2.5.1.jar
spring-aop-2.5.6.jar
spring-beans-2.5.6.jar
spring-context-2.5.6.jar
spring-context-support-2.5.6.jar
spring-core-2.5.6.jar
spring-jms-2.5.6.jar
spring-tx-2.5.6.jar
spring-web-2.5.6.jar
spring-webmvc-2.5.6.jar

(these are all of the jars resolved by the runtime configuration).

Here's the ivy.xml file I use in the "sample" project:

<ivy-module version="2.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"
xsi:noNamespaceSchemaLocation="http://ant.apache.org/ivy/schemas/ivy.xsd">

<info organisation="net.croz" module="IntegrationWeb" status="integration">
</info>

<configurations>
<conf name="default" />
<conf name="compile" />
<conf name="runtime" />
<conf name="test" />
<conf name="sources" />
</configurations>

<publications>
<artifact name="IntegrationWeb" type="war" ext="war"></artifact>
</publications>

<dependencies>

<dependency org="com.ibm.websphere.appserver" name="runtime" rev="6.1"
conf="compile->default" />


<dependency org="javax.jms" name="jms" rev="1.1" conf="compile->default"
/>

<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-aop" rev="2.5.6"
conf="runtime->default" />

<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-jms" rev="2.5.6"
conf="runtime->default" />
<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-web" rev="2.5.6"
conf="runtime->default" />
<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-webmvc" rev="2.5.6"
conf="runtime->default" />
<dependency org="org.aspectj" name="aspectjrt" rev="1.6.5" conf="runtime->default"
/>
<dependency org="org.aspectj" name="aspectjweaver" rev="1.6.5" conf="runtime->default"
/>
<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-context-support"
rev="2.5.6" conf="runtime->default" />
<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-test" rev="2.5.6"
conf="test->default" />
<dependency org="org.springframework" name="spring-jdbc" rev="2.5.6"
conf="test,compile->default" />
<dependency org="commons-fileupload" name="commons-fileupload" rev="1.2.1"
conf="test,compile,runtime->default" />
<dependency org="commons-io" name="commons-io" rev="1.4" conf="test,compile,runtime->default"
/>
<dependency org="dom4j" name="dom4j" rev="1.6.1" conf="test,compile,runtime->default"
/>
<dependency org="javax.servlet" name="jstl" rev="1.2" conf="compile->default"
/>
<dependency org="javax.servlet" name="jsp-api" rev="2.0" conf="compile->default"
/>
<exclude org="xml-apis" module="xml-apis" />

<override org="junit" module="junit" rev="4.5" />
<override org="org.slf4j" module="slf4j-api" rev="1.5.6" />

</dependencies>

</ivy-module>

Compile configuration will resolve to the following jars:

C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\aopalliance\aopalliance\jars\ao palliance-1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-logging\commons-logging \jars\commons-logging-1.1.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-bean s\jars\spring-beans-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-core \jars\spring-core-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-cont ext\jars\spring-context-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-tx\j ars\spring-tx-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-fileupload\commons-file upload\jars\commons-fileupload-1.2.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-io\commons-io\jars\comm ons-io-1.4.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\dom4j\dom4j\jars\dom4j-1.6.1.ja r
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\bootstrap\jars\boots trap-6.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.mq\jars\com. ibm.mq-6.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.mqjms\jars\c om.ibm.mqjms-6.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.ejbportab le\jars\com.ibm.ws.ejbportable-6.1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.emf\jars\ com.ibm.ws.emf-2.1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.portletco ntainer\jars\com.ibm.ws.portletcontainer-2.0.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.runtime.d ist\jars\com.ibm.ws.runtime.dist-6.1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.runtime\j ars\com.ibm.ws.runtime-6.1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.sib.serve r\jars\com.ibm.ws.sib.server-2.0.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.sip.conta iner\jars\com.ibm.ws.sip.container-6.1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.wccm\jars \com.ibm.ws.wccm-6.1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\com.ibm.ws.webcontai ner\jars\com.ibm.ws.webcontainer-2.0.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\dhbcore\jars\dhbcore -6.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\j2ee\jars\j2ee-6.1.j ar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\mail-impl\jars\mail- impl-6.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\marshall\jars\marsha ll-6.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\org.eclipse.emf.comm on\jars\org.eclipse.emf.common-2.2.1.v200609210005.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\org.eclipse.emf.comm onj.sdo\jars\org.eclipse.emf.commonj.sdo-2.1.0.v200609210005 .jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\org.eclipse.emf.ecor e.change\jars\org.eclipse.emf.ecore.change-2.2.0.v2006092100 05.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\org.eclipse.emf.ecor e.sdo\jars\org.eclipse.emf.ecore.sdo-2.2.0.v200609210005.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\org.eclipse.emf.ecor e.xmi\jars\org.eclipse.emf.ecore.xmi-2.2.1.v200609210005.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\com.ibm.ws\org.eclipse.emf.ecor e\jars\org.eclipse.emf.ecore-2.2.1.v200609210005.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\javax.jms\jms\jars\jms-1.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-jdbc \jars\spring-jdbc-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\javax.servlet\jstl\jars\jstl-1. 2.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\javax.servlet\jsp-api\jars\jsp- api-2.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\javax.servlet\servlet-api\jars\ servlet-api-2.4.jar

Runtime configuration will resolve to the following jars:

C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-aop\ jars\spring-aop-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\aopalliance\aopalliance\jars\ao palliance-1.0.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-logging\commons-logging \jars\commons-logging-1.1.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-bean s\jars\spring-beans-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-core \jars\spring-core-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-jms\ jars\spring-jms-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-pool\commons-pool\jars\ commons-pool-1.3.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-cont ext\jars\spring-context-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-cont ext-support\jars\spring-context-support-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-tx\j ars\spring-tx-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-web\ jars\spring-web-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.springframework\spring-webm vc\jars\spring-webmvc-2.5.6.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.aspectj\aspectjrt\jars\aspe ctjrt-1.6.5.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\org.aspectj\aspectjweaver\jars\ aspectjweaver-1.6.5.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-fileupload\commons-file upload\jars\commons-fileupload-1.2.1.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\commons-io\commons-io\jars\comm ons-io-1.4.jar
C:\Documents and Settings\iloncar\.ivy2\cache\dom4j\dom4j\jars\dom4j-1.6.1.ja r

--
Ivica Loncar

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolderis WebContent/WEB-INF/cla [message #490396 is a reply to message #490125]

Thu, 08 October 2009 14:15

Ivica Loncar

Messages: 41
Registered: July 2009

Member

Hello Larry,

> Sounds like a bug, but where? Are you able to determine if the content
> of the classpath containers makes a difference, or just the order? If
> you can post the relevant portions of the ".classpath" file, I could
> try some experiments with some simple classpath container code I have.

I have posted .classpath file as you requested in the earlier post.

Let's say that we have two classpath containers A and B that share some of
the jars.

Their union: is A(runtime) + B(compile) = C (runtime + compile)
Relative complement of B in A is: A (runtime) - B (compile) = D (jars from
runtime configuration that do not appear in compile configuration)

If I order containers in the Java Build path such that A (runtime) comes
before B (compile) and mark A (runtime) for export into WEB-INF/lib under
Java EE module dependencies
then I get A (runtime) under the WEB-INF/lib
This is expected behaviour.

If I reorder containers such that B(compile) comes before A(runtime) and
mark A(runtime) for export into WEB-INF/lib
then I get D (jars from runtime configuration that do not appear in compile
configuration) under the WEB-INF/lib
This is not expected.

Unfortunately I don't have custom classpath container (except IVYDE) that
could mimic this behaviour.
Do you know of an example?

--
Ivica Loncar

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolderis WebContent/WEB-INF/cla [message #490397 is a reply to message #490396]

Thu, 08 October 2009 14:28

Ivica Loncar

Messages: 41
Registered: July 2009

Member

> Unfortunately I don't have custom classpath container (except IVYDE)
> that could mimic this behaviour.
> Do you know of an example?

Actually, I've remembered the example - "User libraries".
If I create two user libraries that share some of the jars I can reproduce
the same behaviour.

Bug in WTP? :-(

--
Ivica Loncar

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolderis WebContent/WEB-INF/cla [message #490439 is a reply to message #490397]

Thu, 08 October 2009 16:13

Larry Isaacs

Messages: 1354
Registered: July 2009

Senior Member

Ivica Loncar wrote:
>> Unfortunately I don't have custom classpath container (except IVYDE)
>> that could mimic this behaviour.
>> Do you know of an example?
>
> Actually, I've remembered the example - "User libraries".
> If I create two user libraries that share some of the jars I can
> reproduce the same behaviour.
> Bug in WTP? :-(

If you have a jar appearing in two different classpath containers, one
set for inclusion in WEB-INF/lib and the other set not to be included in
WEB-INF/lib, I'm not sure what to expect? I'm don't know whether WTP
includes handling to try to resolve this ambiguity that isn't working
quite right, or doesn't include such handling. You could check there is
already a bug for this and report a new one if not found. I would guess
it would be found under WebTools -> WTP Java EE Tools -> jst.j2ee.
Thanks for the investigative work.

Cheers,
Larry

Report message to a moderator

Re: problem publishing web project into tomcat installation if outputfolderisWebContent/WEB-INF/clas [message #490475 is a reply to message #490439]

Thu, 08 October 2009 18:13

Ivica Loncar

Messages: 41
Registered: July 2009

Member

Hello Larry,

> If you have a jar appearing in two different classpath containers, one
> set for inclusion in WEB-INF/lib and the other set not to be included
> in WEB-INF/lib, I'm not sure what to expect? I'm don't know whether
> WTP includes handling to try to resolve this ambiguity that isn't
> working quite right, or doesn't include such handling. You could
> check there is already a bug for this and report a new one if not
> found. I would guess it would be found under WebTools -> WTP Java EE
> Tools -> jst.j2ee. Thanks for the investigative work.

Thank you for the help Larry.

I would expect WTP to export what user told it to export, or to give a warning
if someone finds it necessary (but not an error!).
Also, it's not obvious that ordering classpath containers in Java Build Path
has anything to do with Java EE Module Dependencies.

I have searched WTP bugs and I can't find something similar so I'm filling
a bug against WTP.

--
Ivica Loncar

Report message to a moderator

Previous Topic:	Does WTP support Tomcat servers with multiple Service elements in server.xml?
Next Topic:	javascript editor and IStorageEditorInput

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [

]

Current Time: Sat Apr 20 01:27:36 GMT 2024

.:: Contact :: Home ::.

Breadcrumbs

Sign up to our Newsletter