Eclipse Community Forums: Eclipse 4 » @Optional doesn't work as I expect

Help

Home

Home » Eclipse Projects » Eclipse 4 » @Optional doesn't work as I expect

Show: Today's Messages :: Show Polls :: Message Navigator

@Optional doesn't work as I expect [message #731600]

Sat, 01 October 2011 20:03

Missing name Missing name is currently offline

Missing name Missing name
Messages: 18
Registered: September 2011

Junior Member

I've got a method:

class MyClass {

...

@Inject
void setSomething(@Optional Something something) {
// do something with something
}

}

I want this method to be called only if I've placed something in the context to be injected. Trouble is, when I construct a MyClass, a Something gets constructed to satisfy the injection. That's not what I want. How can I make this truly optional so that DI won't default construct something in order to call it? I'd settle for a call to setSomething(null).

Report message to a moderator

Re: @Optional doesn't work as I expect [message #731635 is a reply to message #731600]

Sun, 02 October 2011 03:15

Thomas Schindl
Messages: 4462
Registered: July 2009

Senior Member

Hi,

I also saw this "strange" behavior when Something has a default
constructor. Is this the case for you as well? I need to talk to Oleg to
find out why this happens and will follow up with you one I know more.

Tom

Am 02.10.11 02:03, schrieb grillo321:
> I've got a method:
>
> class MyClass {
>
> ..
>
> @Inject
> void setSomething(@Optional Something something) {
> // do something with something
> }
>
> }
>
> I want this method to be called only if I've placed something in the
> context to be injected. Trouble is, when I construct a MyClass, a
> Something gets constructed to satisfy the injection. That's not what I
> want. How can I make this truly optional so that DI won't default
> construct something in order to call it? I'd settle for a call to
> setSomething(null).

Report message to a moderator

Re: @Optional doesn't work as I expect [message #731754 is a reply to message #731600]

Sun, 02 October 2011 19:02

Missing name Missing name
Messages: 18
Registered: September 2011

Junior Member

Thanks for the reply Tom. Of course now I can't reproduce the problem, but I think the times I've seen it have involved a default constructor or at least a constructor that can be injected successfully.

And I've got another question about how @Optional is supposed to work.

If I write:

@Inject
@Optional
void someFunc(SomeClass someThing) {
...
}

I would expect that the call wouldn't be made if there's no SomeClass in the context. What I see is that the call is made but null is passed in. This is the same result as putting the @Optional on the parameter. Or putting it in both places for that matter.

Is this working as intended?
What's the best place to find doc on how this should work?

Report message to a moderator

Previous Topic:	When Processor method is called ?
Next Topic:	Change Part size dynamically

Goto Forum:

-=] Back to Top [=-

[ Syndicate this forum (XML) ] [

]

Current Time: Sat May 18 16:15:06 EDT 2013